Home
Twitter
RSS
Newsletter
Sacha Siadatan
16 Mar, 2003

Project Gotham Racing Review

Xbox Review | PALGN.com is recapping an old classic from Microsoft and Bizarre-Creations to correspond with the release of Project Gotham’s sequel.
Although the Dreamcast had a wide variety of great games, that even today are significantly noted and cherished in the gaming society, one game stood out among them all. That game was Metropolis Street Racer. It was an enormous hit, selling millions across the world. It had a unique system that no one had heard of before, it had great graphics, amazing cars, and some of the best audio effects ever heard. People still pronounce it today as the best racer ever created.
One thing set MSR into a near flipside failure, it was filled with bugs. Thousands of gamers had to send back their exquisite game to Sega.

Now, with a new publisher, a new city, a new console, superior graphics, and the game being improved in every way possible, MSR’s brother is released PGR.
I’m sure you’ve heard many critics underlining this game. They disregarded is as a simple sequel, a simple port, nothing compared to Gran Turismo they declare. Well, trust me on this, they’re wrong. This game shouldn’t be counted as a port, or sequel, prequel or anything else. It should be classed as a pioneering, and innovative game; something which many gamers don’t seem to notice.

The Xbox launched with a lot of great looking games, and as you may have already guessed this is absolutely no exception. The car models are what really stand out. From Ferraris, to BMWs, to Mercedes-Benz. They look great, simple as that. And I really mean it. They look almost, real. From the hub-caps to the drivers themselves, every single inch of the cars seems to be amazingly well depicted.





Not only that, but PGR was the first game ever to successfully implement real-time-shadowing. You see nylon reflections bouncing off the windows and bonnets, off the headlights and even the tyres! As you turn the shadows turn with you, the sun reflects into you, the buildings shine onto you, and it gives of an effect that really should impress any practical gamer.

PGR was one of the only games where you could damage your car. This was prohibited by many car developers simply because they didn’t desire their beloved designs to appear faulty. I don’t know how Microsoft did it, but they seem to have purchased the rights of car damage. Although to be honest; this is a serious let down. Cars can barely be scratched! In fact, I once attempted crashing to see how much I could damage my trustworthy motor (Audio TT Cooper), and I came to a conclusion that all I could accomplish is smash the lights, and make a slight dent on the sides, and bonnet of the vehicle. I’m not really sure why Bizarre Creations developed a game, which by all means could’ve had amazingly realistic damage, had very much appalling damage. Perhaps car developers put a limit on how much their vehicle could be ill-treated, who knows. As you may have guessed, car damage is superficial. If you manage to crash your car it won’t do anything to the performance of the vehicle.

The tracks look amazing in this game. Not quite as impressive as the Car Models, but impressive enough to hand it the position as best in-game track graphics I have ever seen in a racing game, and yes that does include GT3. The Weather effects are definitely the best element of the game; in fact levels look most paramount when it’s raining. I just love the splash of water as it steams up from under the tyres, and the blast of four wheels shooting of at 120mph, as slippery wet water rumbles out from my speakers.
The amount of tracks available is tremendous. I’m talking of 200 plus unique circuits. All of which are in gleaming the cities of London, Tokyo, San Francisco and New York.
Reflections off buildings are apparent, and the Sun shining from behind rooftops gave a nice touch, that even I seem to adore after being blinded from the utter intensity.

Every inch of every city has been converted into photo-realistic in-game graphics. I’m accustom with the streets of London, since it’s my home city, and I can honestly say the game is accurately alike. Every street, every building, every tree, and every pavement seem to be there. It’s almost unbelievable. I drive down Trafalgar in my new Ferrari F55 and my memory is recapped with the times I managed to get myself lost, and the time I found myself drunk in the dramatic streets of London.




MSR was much admired for its innovative Kudos system. A system in which you had to drive with style, but safety. For example when turning a corner you have the chance to lock on the handbrake and do a 3 second skid around the bend, this will give you a Kudos score, but if you manage to loose the control over the car, and it hits a wall, another car, a tree, or anything solid you’ll loose that temporary kudos score. If you get around the bend without crashing, the Kudos you gained will be added to the main Kudos score which you can not be lost.

Not only must you obtain a minimum Kudos score to complete a level, you’re obligatory is also to conclude the task the game sets.
These range from Time Attacks, to Over Take Challenges, to One on One Races, to Kudos Challenges and even Street Races.
The Kudos System is something I am very impressed with. You get these tense moments where you have the choice to either employ your brake and take the corner as carefully but speedily as possible, or push-down the hand brake and risk jeopardizing loosing speed and the handle of the car, but gaining Kudos. When you’re both short on time and Kudos you’ll need to decide how to drive your car in the most competent and resourceful way. This generates a great sentiment to the game; it’s basically the only driving game which I had to use my brain to complete.

However the Kudos System has been pushed down on the importance level a bit with PGR. On MSR you completed levels solely to gain Kudos since Kudos was the heart of the game. You needed Kudos for cars, secrets maps, different stages, levels, jokers, and many other items. On PGR however it’s much less important. In fact Kudos is basically there to impress gamers. There’s not much need for it. A new System which I like to call the Medal System seems to be dominating here. In each stage there are a set number of levels. You have the choice to either raise the difficulty, or lower it. If you raise it high enough, and manage to complete the level on the difficulty you altered it to you’ll get either a Gold or Silver medal. If you leave it at the default difficulty you’ll acquire a bronze medal. You need at least a bronze on every echelon to advance onto the next stage. This eliminates the bug in which experienced gamers could complete the whole game playing less than a quarter of it, which was very common on MSR.




On top of the very long-lasting single player game, you can also participate with another 3 people on a split screen mode. I find it rather odd though; that the multiplayer doesn’t have the same feel as the single player, it’s also rather slow moving. The multi-player is a failure to put it to short. With worse graphics, less polygons, slower gameplay and a change in the control system I wonder what happened at the studio.

The AI on Project Gotham is amazing. Drivers skid in front of you to discontinue you from exceeding them, they demolish the back of your car to try and get you off control, and they push you into secret parts of levels, it’s just marvellous. Its nothing like GT3’s moaning AI. This is probably one of the greatest AI’s I have seen on any game so far.

The Audio on PGR is great. Each car has its own unique engine, and therefore it creates its own sound. The tyres skidding on the ground, the cars hitting a wall, two rival competitors scratching each others doors while they turn a corner are all very realistically taken to life by the great a sound that I’m sure Bizarre Creations spent months studying. I find the engine noises and crashes truly believable. They actually sound genuine; this must be the first racing game that actually has proper pragmatic audio effects.
PGR has the very well known custom sound-track option that many Xbox owners are in discussion about. This makes it possible for CDs to be downloaded onto the Hard Drive, and then played in game.
You’ll probably jump at that idea, but there’s no need to. The Music on PGR is great. It has a mix of everything, from Trance, Rock, Metal, Country, Hard-Rock, Rap, Dance and many others. Although Rock seems to be the dominate style that I had the impression of. I have to say, PGR has the best sound tracks on any game, I have ever played. It’s just great. I found myself sitting in my room, with the reply option on pause, listening to all the songs on PGR. That’s how great it is. The sound track is incredibly appropriate for a Racing game.
The Score
All in all Project Gotham Racing is a great, great game. It has everything any gamer should need. 9
Looking to buy this game right now? PALGN recommends www.Play-Asia.com.

Related Content

Easy Mode Volume 2.6
07 Sep, 2007 10 things I hate about you.
The SpudGun
31 Aug, 2007 Mona Lisa plagued with launch week problems.
Rez Review
20 Feb, 2003 A 3D shooter, made by a Sega sub-division specialising in music games, eighteen months in the making and dedicated to the Russian abstract artist Wassily Kandinsky? How can you NOT be interested?
19 Comments
6 years ago
Do you guys actually read these reviews before posting them or just do a spell check?

Quote
Although the Dreamcast had a vide variety of great games,
looks like the validation is working icon_rolleyes.gif
6 years ago
Of course, Slasher is the oracle of all things spelling and grammar. icon_rolleyes.gif
6 years ago
Quote
Of course, Slasher is the oracle of all things spelling and grammer
*grammar icon_lol.gif

Seriously guys, don't start.
6 years ago
Quote
Of course, Slasher is the oracle of all things spelling and grammer.
I don't claim to be, I couldn't give a flying **** about spelling in forum posts, but this is a review. The writer should have picked it up and if he/she didn't thats what the validation is for. Well I thought thats what it was for.
6 years ago
sonicwired wrote
Of course, Slasher is the oracle of all things spelling and grammer. icon_rolleyes.gif
From yourdictionary.com

Quote
"Sorry, no words matching "grammer" were found "
There are some good reviews on the site but this one leaves a lot to be desired; basic spelling mistakes, poor reviewing style and an inflated score... icon_sad.gif
6 years ago
If you're going to quote my posts, stop changing my spelling. icon_razz.gif
6 years ago
sonicwired wrote
If you're going to quote my posts, stop changing my spelling. icon_razz.gif
Sonic you just edited your post from grammer to grammar to avoid looking like a fool...

At least place an EDIT at the bottom of your post icon_sad.gif

EDIT:Just to clarify I know the board lists an edit in posts automatically, but the poster should note what the edit is for, especially in this case...
6 years ago
As an Admin, I'm allowed to do that.

If you have so many problems with our reviews, I suggest that you write a sample and submit it so we can see how "great" your writing skills really are.

If you read other gaming websites, quite a few of their reviews have typos including the big boys like IGN and Gamespot. Writers make mistakes and although they have people proof-reading the articles, some errors still creep through.
6 years ago
Sonic you seem to be making this a personal issue...Others have responded to this review with negative opinions, please don't personalise this issue...I suggest you ask some of your better writers their opinion on the review...

sonicwired wrote
If you read other gaming websites, quite a few of their reviews have typos including the big boys like IGN and Gamespot.
Not on the level of this one...

sonicwired wrote
If you have so many problems with our reviews, I suggest that you write a sample and submit it so we can see how "great" your writing skills really are.
Hmm...Would my review be of a better standard than this one-hell yes...If I was to comply with your request it would give you the impression I am seeking a staff position here, which is NOT the case...

sonicwired wrote
As an Admin, I'm allowed to do that.
Shouldn’t there be rules that bind all posters?

EDIT:Let me know if you want a review of either Pokemon Ruby or Spahire on the GBA-the PAL releases of course icon_wink.gif
6 years ago
I actually agree here. Validation does NOT seem to be working. Many times I have submited an article to be Validated, only to go back and seem spelling mistakes in there after. Alsthough there is always going to be the chance of missing something there really should only be one or a max of two things missed.

~SubElement~
6 years ago
Meh, inquisitor/slasher stop whinging. As sonicwired said, if you've got a problem with the writers, submit your own application and shut the hell up.
6 years ago
apoc x wrote
Meh, inquisitor/slasher stop whinging. As sonicwired said, if you've got a problem with the writers, submit your own application and shut the hell up.
What kind of attitude is that...You got a problem with the current US Space program-Go and build your own shuttle! icon_razz.gif

You want people to visit the site don't you?(obviously)...How do you do this-with quality content...

PS-Of course I could write up a better review than that...It is however irrelevant to this issue...
6 years ago
Quote
You want people to visit the site don't you?(obviously)...How do you do this-with quality content...
Exactly, you need someting up to or above the standard of other sites or people will go elsewhere.
6 years ago
Unless you are actually going to do something other than whine about our staff's writing skills, be quiet. You say that you could write so much better than all of our staff yet when given the chance to prove it, you shrug it off.

Almost every website on the internet contains spelling errors and typos, it happens and no amount of proof-reading will ever weed out every mistake. Gamespot and IGN have reviews with spelling mistakes that go unchanged for years, it's not like they would fire Fran for a typo in a year old review.

Either get over it or show us why you think you can do it better.
6 years ago
sonicwired wrote
Unless you are actually going to do something other than whine about our staff's writing skills, be quiet. You say that you could write so much better than all of our staff yet when given the chance to prove it, you shrug it off.
I never said that I could "write so much better than all your staff", just this particular review...

What game do you want me to review, Pokemon Ruby, Saphire or the PAL version of Metroid Prime...?I currently have all of them...

EDIT:spelling icon_wink.gif
6 years ago
Point taken. I messed up by missing out a few errors I should have corrected in this review. Apologies given to all that want them. icon_redface.gif
6 years ago
So what exactly was the problem with the review? A few typos is what I’m hoping but people seem to be complaining about a lot more than that…
6 years ago
IGN Frequently have typos in their reviews. Why don't you go and spam them with complaints? icon_razz.gif
6 years ago
Bronzetiger wrote
IGN Frequently have typos in their reviews. Why don't you go and spam them with complaints? icon_razz.gif
They are only looking out for the future of the site. And few people care about IGN.

I think I agree on the over inflated reviews. As good as PGR is it clearly isn't a 9.0, something I would only give to exceptional games, and PGR clearly isn't exceptional, perhaps just my tastes (I'm not that keen on simulation games because they never are realistic enough and I don't believe games are about doing things you can do in reality). I think the thing I dislike about this game is my brother was saying how good the graphics were, when the reflections were lagging terribly and were hardly an accurate reflection of the environment. The cars in my experience seemed to handle poorly and that isn't my idea of fun. Maybe I'm biased against this game though.
Add Comment
Like this review?
Share it with this tiny url: http://palg.nu/1SX

N4G : News for Gamers         Twitter This!

Digg!     Stumble This!

| More
  Pre-order or buy:
    PALGN recommends: www.Play-Asia.com

Australian Release Date:
  Out Now
European Release Date:
  Out Now
Publisher:
  Microsoft Game Studios
Developer:
  Bizarre Creations
Players:
  4

Read more...
Currently Popular on PALGN
Bioshock 2 Review
Welcome back to Rapture...
Win 1 of 10 Bioshock 2 packs
Includes free stuffs!
PALGN Weekly Releases - 08/02/10
Christmas in February?
Nier Preview
Nierly as dark and twisted as Drakengard.