Home
Twitter
RSS
Newsletter
Matt Bassos
10 Oct, 2004

Silent Hill 4: The Room Review

Xbox Review | PALGN wonders what’s inside that room…
If you have never played a Silent Hill game before, then you are missing out on some of the best scares a video game can ever give you. Silent Hill 4: The Room is no exception and like previous games in the series, it has plenty of disturbing horror which will no doubt keep you up at night. Even better however, is the fact that beyond the horrifying imagery the game paints, is an enjoyable survival horror game, which integrates some well thought-out ideas which help intensify the atmosphere that little bit more. Silent Hill 4: The Room, is one ghastly trip, so get ready for some mentally distressing sequences and a bucket load of gore.

Welcome to Silent Hill..err..I mean Ashfield

Interesting enough, this is the first game in the series that doesn’t actually venture into Silent Hill. Instead the story focuses around the neighbouring city of Ashfield and as the games title subtly hints, takes place inside an apartment named room 302. You play as Henry Townshend, an everyday, ordinary man, aged someone in his mid-twenties. Unfortunately for poor Henry the apartment he has been living in for the past two years is cursed, and recently he has been having strange, unexplainable, recurring nightmares. Things only get weirder when Henry finds his front door locked, chained from the inside, his windows bolted shut, and all electronic devices in his house busted, except for his radio. Henry virtually becomes a prisoner in his own apartment, until something strange happens within his very bathroom. A bizarre tunnel has somehow appeared in the centre of his bathroom wall, which leads to alternative worlds of darkness. Henry of course has no other option, so takes the lunge through the tunnel, which then leads to a new kind of nightmare.

Spacious Living

The first thing you will notice with Silent Hill 4: The Room is how the game is divided into both first person perspective scenes while Henry is in the confines of his apartment and third person perspective scenes while Henry is visiting the alternative world. Controlling Henry around your apartment is a pretty straightforward affair, using one analog stick to look around and the other one to move. While in Henry’s apartment you can do a fair bit of exploring, and nose around his meagre possessions. If something worth noticing comes across your screen, an eye icon will appear and by pushing “X” players will examine the object with greater detail.

His apartment consists of one bedroom, a lounge room, a bathroom, a laundry, and a kitchen, but that doesn’t mean you can’t have fun looking about. There are photos about the place, a radio to occasionally listen to, and windows to gaze out of if you wish to see people doing their daily business while you’re trapped in a personal nightmare.


Item Chest cliché anyone?

Then there are the sequences which take place in the alternative nightmarish world. By entering the tunnel found in Henry’s bathroom you are taken to many strange places where creatures lurk in the shadows. These scenes are played in traditional Silent Hill third person perspective and if you have played any of the previous games, you should feel right at home here. Similarly to the other games, combat is done by going into an aggressive stance, which is achieved by holding down the right trigger. Once in this pose, you can swing or fire to your hearts content. Replacing the block ability in Silent Hill 3, is the dodge manoeuvre, which can be triggered while in the combat stance and allows you to quickly move out of harms way against creature’s attacks. Selecting weapons and items have also been streamlined in Silent Hill 4 over its predecessors, and no longer does the action pause if you need to switch weapons or use an item. Instead a categorized menu appears at the bottom of the screen and lets you change weapons or use items on the fly. You can however, only carry a limited amount items with you at any given time, so the handy dandy item chest which will store all those unneeded items, found in Henry’s apartment lounge room, becomes a necessity.

Combat is predominately the same from other titles in the series. Unlike games in the Resident Evil series, Silent Hill 4 thankfully lets you move about while you are in the combat pose, thus giving the player more freedom, as well as the flexibility to use the dodge manoeuvre. (unless you count Resident Evil 3) A new feature has been added to combat in the form of a charge meter. Certain melee weapons can be charged up, (by holding down the button) for extra powerful attacks, which will knock most enemies back in one hit. Most weapons in the game are in melee format, with very few firearms found in the game. This isn’t too much of a problem however as most melee weapons are enjoyable to use and have their own strength, attack speed, combo strings and charge attacks to make each weapon feel unique. While in Henry’s apartment and in first-person perspective you cannot attack with any weapon.

Home sweet home

The first-person apartment scenes and the third-person alternative world scenes co-exist with each other flawlessly throughout the game. In the beginning the apartment will act as a safe zone, a place to escape the nasty alternative world. In fact, at the start of the game you will be looking for exits out of the alternative world (in the form of tunnels) as much as possible, as while Henry is back at his apartment, his life will slowly recover, and you can save your game and take a moments breather without the fear of being ripped to shreds.

As the plot thickens Henry’s once safe apartment becomes a hell zone in its own rite. As the story progresses the apartment degenerates and becomes a haunting ground for spirits. Furthermore the once healing effect found in your apartment is gone, and you may want to reconsider leaving the alternative world to come back home, as a series of spiritual attacks can occur at any time through in the once secured environment. Fortunately there are ways to combat these spirit attacks while you’re in this first person perspective (seeing how you can’t use weapons), and include such things as lighting holy candles to purge rooms clean for short periods of time.


Backtracking to the item chest, now there’s a cliché!

The game is not without its faults. While item selections may have been streamlined, your item inventory is still inefficient, as things like pistol ammo and health drinks cannot be stored together and take up an individual inventory space each, which results in a lot of aggravated back tracking between the apartment and the alternative world. Another thing must be said about a certain type of enemy named victims, which are more or less floating ghosts. These enemies can come out of nowhere and will emit an evil aura which will damage Henry, if they are close by. This wouldn’t be a problem except for the fact that you lack the means to kill these types of enemies early on in the game, which results in you running from them most of time and not allowing you to explore an area properly without having an invincible foe pursue you.

If you hate escort missions in video games with a passion, maybe you should stay away from Silent Hill 4, as a great part of the game will have another character tagging along behind you. Although this character can use weaponry, it is always a pain to look after someone, especially for long periods of time.

The graphics in Silent Hill 4 is what you would come to expect from a survival horror game. Distorted, gritty and washed out are all good words in describing the environment in the game, not to mention the blood stains splattered about the place. During you travels in the game you will visit many places such as a subway, a forest, a prison and even a hospital, and all these locations are dark and moody, which sets up the perfect atmosphere to creep you out. The sound is also well established, which furthers enhances the eeriness of the game. Most sound effects are spot on, and the music will definitely help contribute to the scares in the game.

Distorted, gritty and washed out...yep must be a Silent Hill game

Distorted, gritty and washed out...yep must be a Silent Hill game
Close
Silent Hill 4 comprises of some appealing puzzles, which help stretch the overall lifespan of the game. While the game itself isn’t terribly long and can be finished within twelve hours, there are four endings in total (depending on how you play the game) and quite a few unlockable game modes which will have you coming back and giving the game another go.

Silent…but deadly!

Silent Hill 4: The Room will be one game that will surely scare you in some capacity. Its well implemented concepts of both first person and third person perspectives and its centralisation between an apartment and an alternative world offer a rare kind of gameplay experience. If you are looking for a good survival horror game, or simply an intriguing plot surrounded in mystery and you can handle a few disturbing images, Silent Hill 4: The Room will be a winner.
The Score
Excellent game if you're ready for some scares and a bit mystery. A must buy for fans of Silent Hill, or anyone who digs survival horror games. 8
Looking to buy this game right now? PALGN recommends www.Play-Asia.com.

Related Content

Silent Hill 3 Review
08 Jun, 2003 This review may contain scenes which are violent or may be considered cruel.
46 Comments
7 years ago
A Short History of Doom 3 and E3 Awards
Wins:

2002
Best of Show
Best PC Game
Best Action Game
Best Sound
Best Graphics

Shorter History of Resident Evil 4 and E3 Awards...
Wins:
None...
Nominated:
2004
Best Console Game (lost to Halo 2)
Best Action/Adventure Game (lost to Splinter Cell 3)

next time you're going to use awards as an argument, make sure it actually won...

...and if you dislke this site so much, feel free to **** right off...
7 years ago
I agree, be wary of the almighty hype machine. RE4 may be the best thing ever according to "game" sites, but we'll have to wait and see. For example, say if its only 6 hours long, then "the game of the year" turns into a flop.
7 years ago
i have been forward in time and seen it will score higher then 9/10.
7 years ago
leonmc wrote
I agree, be wary of the almighty hype machine. RE4 may be the best thing ever according to "game" sites, but we'll have to wait and see. For example, say if its only 6 hours long, then "the game of the year" turns into a flop.
Actually the game is over 20 hours long, also what game sites did you get the awards from?palgn?lol

ign-resident evil 4 = action game of e3
ign-resident evil 4 = game of the show
ign-resident evil 4 = technological excellence of e3
7 years ago
I'm glad you like the RE series, but don't forget people may also like the SH series, everyone is entitled to an opinion. As for RE4 I hope it's a good game, but I will never get to play it being on the gamecube and all. icon_sad.gif
7 years ago
TransgenicX wrote
also what game sites did you get the awards from?palgn?lol
What does it matter? You assume because Palgn isn't brimming with commercialism we can't be trusted to bring you quality news? As long as they are facts, they remain constant no matter what website.
7 years ago
you gave an average game 8/10, it doesnt deserve it, and i was just messing with him saying where did he get the awards from, from an earlier post.
7 years ago
In my opinion it did deserve 8/10, hence why I'm the reviewer and you're the reader. Remember in the end reviews are someone's opinion and I refer you to this excellent article.
7 years ago
TransgenicX wrote
i have been forward in time and seen it will score higher then 9/10.
First of all, that quote above right there shows why you're an idiot.

Secondly..
Transgenic wrote
ign-resident evil 4 = action game of e3
ign-resident evil 4 = game of the show
ign-resident evil 4 = technological excellence of e3
Those awards were given to the game from IGN's editors. It was their opinion and not the actual results of the E3 awards.

Face it, your statements are pretty weak and you can't prove to us that RE 4 will be the better game based on hype alone.
7 years ago
it was alot of other sites opinions as well and i take them over you.
7 years ago
That's your choice to do so but if you want to believe the hype, then don't be surprised if you are let-down big time.
7 years ago
no re game has let me down before and i dont expect this one to and if you have seen any movies you would know it wont either.
7 years ago
How can you/we glean any information purely from a video? In some cases, the game we see presented in a Video turns out to be excellent, like myself and F-Zero GX. However, in some cases, regardless of how it looks in the videos, the game itself turns out to be total rubbish.

Of course, this is just my opinion, I don't like either SH or RE, and both scare the living **** out of me anyway.
7 years ago
Look at it in this perspective then Transgenic.

If there was a video of a new released car doing a burnout, would it mean that the car is absolutely awesome? No it wouldn't. Until you drive the thing, you won't know what the top speed is, how it handles and etc.

Sure you can read future articles on the car and watch video footage of people driving it at top speed to find the answers, but you won't know until these videos are released as proof. You'll never know how it handles either unless you drive the bloody thing.

Same applies for the trailers. Yes I agree, RE4 looks absolutely brilliant and I think it is safe to assume it will be brilliant too, but I/we won't know for sure until we put the game disc into the Cube for the first time.

Just because previous games haven't let you down, doesn't mean future ones will continue the trend.
Again I use Driv3r as an example - I loved both Driver and Driver 2 so I was definitely pumped (to say the least) about the release of Driv3r. The trailers and information on the game sounded brilliant.
Heck I even ignored the online reviews about it being **** until I played it for myself. They were right in this case and it was indeed ****. I know that, the whole world knows that.

The point is, I got caught up in the hype and was seriously disappointed upon play. The same could happen with RE4.

(very doubtful though)
7 years ago
yes very doubtful.
7 years ago
well, silly me, here was i thinking you were referring to the actual, official E3 Awards, not 3rd party awards...

yes, the awards i mentioned were the real, official awards given out by the hosts/sponsors and other judges (over 300 official voters) of the show... and i'd think they'd know games...

in that case:
IGN 2004 Best Adventure Game - Silent Hill 4
as well as console specific awards for PS2 and Xbox...
GameChronicles.com 2004 Game of Show - Driv3r
GAME 2004 Most Wanted E3 award - Driv3r
XBox Solutions Best of E3 - Driv3r
for gods sake IGN gave DOA: Extreme Beach Volleyball an award in 2002... if thats not enough to convince you pre-release awards are not worth anything, i don't know what is...

and i agree, it will probably end up being very good, but i didn't think much of 2 and 3 as i thought they were MOTS... and remember, it doesn't have to be a shoddily made game to be a disappointment...
7 years ago
ign ps2 gave it best adventure game, not overall best adventure game.icon_wink.gif
7 years ago
not from where i'm sitting...
PS2, XBox and overall...

but now looking at actual Ign.com rather than another site (my computer doesn't like ign.com for some reason... rarely loads it properly...) i see it was only PS2 and Xbox awards... i stand corrected...

doesn't take away from my point though, considering they didn't give an overall award in that category...
7 years ago
it doesnt matter anyway, every re game has always outscored every sh game and it wont be any different this time.
7 years ago
trans, i have played every sh game and every re game, and sorry to let you in on something bud, but after re2, the whole series went south. while i am currently still playing sh4, i really dont even care that re4 is coming out, as i am sure i will be dissapointed.

imo, re took the same road as the FF series. I was a huge fan of FF until, X came out, i played through it, and even brought myself to play through X2, and now, i cant believe im saying this, but i dont even care that FF12 is coming out. Square has lost their minds.

re 1 & 2, were great, but 3+ were just the same thing, over and over and over and over and over.

like someone mentioned in a previous post, you probably dont have the mental capacity to be scared by SH. i dont mean this to knock you, (well i do a little bit cause your a moron) but you must be a young child. you cant comprehend something that actually takes time to build up to scare you, you need that "instant gratification." i feel sorry for any women that you are with as im sure they will be dissapointed in *ahem* certain areas of your relationship. a little too fast im thinking.

re does rely on cheap scare tactics, where silent hill uses well though out plot twists and indepth characters. think about it, would re even be scary if it didnt have all the **** jumping out at you? NO! it would just be another game.

all of your points have no real backing. you say things like re is better, sh sucks, but you never give any REAL reason as to why. was it the graphics, sound, gameplay, etc, and what exactly you didnt like about them.

watch the movie jacobs ladder, which silent hill is based on, and tell me if that doesnt scare you. for anyone else reading this who enjoyed sh, you should watch it too. sh was not a re rip off, it was based on jacobs ladder, and if you want to say that, well, re is a rip off, of alot of things aswell, the whole zombie thing is not new to gaming.

try playing any of the silent hills, alone, in a dark room, BY YOURSELF. play through the whole game, and tell me you werent scared. yes its easy to play it in daytime, with your friends around, and all kinds of things going on in the background, but try reading a book in that same setting, and im sure you will find it hard to really enjoy it. same goes for silent hill. i honestly never thought i would have said that a video game scared me, but sh did.

try growing up a little bit, opening your mind, and not looking for that britney speers, coca cola, mtv, cheap thrill that re has become. have a little patience, and let yourself truely enjoy a great game.
7 years ago
o...m...f...g
These guests are getting more intelligent!

Except I disagree with one point, Square Enix have NOT lost their minds icon_razz.gif
7 years ago
Wish they would SIGN UP!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Add Comment
Like this review?
Share it with this tiny url: http://palg.nu/Lt

N4G : News for Gamers         Twitter This!

Digg!     Stumble This!

| More
  Pre-order or buy:
    PALGN recommends: www.Play-Asia.com

Australian Release Date:
  Out Now
European Release Date:
  Out Now
Publisher:
  Konami of Europe
Developer:
  Konami Computer Entertainment Tokyo
Players:
  1

Read more...
Currently Popular on PALGN
Australian Gaming Bargains - 08/12/11
'Tis the season to be bargaining.
R18+ Legislation
R18+ Legislation
Naruto Shippuden: Ultimate Ninja Storm Generations Preview
Hands on time with the game. Chat time with the CEO of CyberConnect 2.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2007
24 titles to keep an eye on during 2007.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2008
And you thought 2007 was populated.