Home
Twitter
RSS
Newsletter
Chris Sell
21 Mar, 2006

Perfect Dark Zero Review

360 Review | Far from perfect.
Launch titles are always crucial to sell a console. Halo alone was responsible for shifting more Xboxes than anyone could have expected. It had everything: great graphics, 5.1 sound and was full to the brim of non-stop action only possible with the added power of new hardware. But with Halo 3 still far away, what better launch game could there be than a follow-up to Rare’s N64 classic Perfect Dark, itself the spiritual sequel to Goldeneye?

Unfortunately, it’s clear from the start that this isn’t the same Rare who brought us those two FPS classics on the Nintendo 64 all those years back. The controls are the first thing to set alarm bells ringing with some of the twitchiest aiming in the history of console first person shooters. Lining up a headshot can be a real hit and miss affair; there’s none of the smoothness that the likes of Call of Duty 2 or Halo offer. If Perfect Dark Zero was on a PC then it wouldn’t be much of a problem, as mouse control would work superbly, but you need a small degree of aim assist when it comes to aiming with an analogue stick. That’s not to say that having no aim assist is the sole reason of the problem because the recent Black on the Xbox doesn’t have any and nailing headshots isn’t half as troublesome as it can be here.

Altering the sensitivity settings can improve things somewhat, but still often frustrates as you miss a headshot by millimetres then naturally nudge the stick to correct it only to see the next shot miss by the same distance past the other side of the enemies face. It wouldn’t be such an issue if Perfect Dark's combat wasn’t so focussed on getting a quick headshot, but when enemies can take the amount of body shots that they do here it becomes a problem. There are times where the battle against the control is tougher than the battle against the enemies themselves and the fun factor is greatly reduced as a result.

Perfect Dark's 'cover mode' in action.

Perfect Dark's 'cover mode' in action.
Close
Aside from the aiming-related issues, there’s little else to complain about regarding control. General movement feels good and the whole thing runs at a decent speed. In fact, in a nice touch you actually move at different speeds in relation to the weight of the weapon you are carrying. Put your guns away and you’ll move much quicker than you would with a large sniper rifle in hand. Weapon switching is handled with the D-pad, while the triggers deal with your standard, secondary and tertiary firing modes.

It all sounds like most other FPSs so far but Perfect Dark Zero features two things that few games have ever incorporated. The first is the roll move which is handy to avoid enemy fire and get yourself out of harms way quickly. The second how ever is the ‘cover mode’. Pressing A against a wall will put Joanna's back towards it and the camera will shift into third person. From here you can aim a shot before stepping out and firing a clip into the face of an unsuspecting enemy. It’s not perfect - you'll sometimes ‘stick’ to a wall you didn’t want to and there are too many things in the levels that you can’t use the cover mode on that you wish you could - but it’s a novel addition all the same.

Fourteen missions make up Perfect Dark Zero's single player campaign and while the length is adequate, the actual quality of the missions is incredibly inconsistent. The game has its moments with a fair few flashes of brilliance. Mission 2, for example, is one of the highlights of the game, offering a good mix of stealthy CCTV camera shooting with frantic all-out firefights. That, along with level design that offers the players multiple ways through the environment is what more of the game should have been like. You start mission 2 in a parking lot fending off a gang of enemies. Once they’re all dead how you move is up to you. You can use the key card to go out the front entrance and make your way to the warehouse dodging cameras. Or you could take a detour and program a robot to get you in the front entrance. Or you could avoid all that and use a demolition charge to blow the wall of the parking lot and take you right around to the side of the warehouse. Excellent.

Some of the more linear levels are dealt with well too by ramping things up the action stakes. The rooftops level that we’ve all seen in preview videos is a great example of this, as is one of the later levels where you storm through a town at night, guards swinging down from drop ships all over the place. Had this quality been offered throughout the game, Perfect Dark Zero could have been a killer FPS to kick off the 360’s life. But a lot of the level designs border on the mundane and far too often you’re left to wander around repetitive-looking corridors trying to complete your next disappointingly vague mission objective. Had the objectives been remotely satisfying, things might have been different, but to reward the player with little more than a line of congratulatory text isn’t enough these days. Back in the day of Goldeneye and the original Perfect Dark, lavish cutscenes and set pieces were almost unheard of in FPS’s, but the genre has moved on since then. Call of Duty 2 is a good example of an objective based shooter and does a wonderful job of rewarding the player for completing their goals. And when you’ve got that competing on the same system, a game like Perfect Dark Zero pales by comparison.

Many weapons come equipped with a trusty scope.

Many weapons come equipped with a trusty scope.
Close
The AI is rather questionable too, with some potentially good levels ruined by it. Take Mission 7 for example, a stage that could have been a superb stealth-orientated mission that’s spoilt entirely by the AI. There’s a large room in the middle portion of the stage where there are cameras everywhere. Having made your way very slowly through the room, eliminating all the cameras with a silenced pistol, it was crushing to have a pack of guards suddenly attack. Were you seen by a camera? No. Heard by a guard? No. So where is the justification of suddenly being attacked when Sam Fisher would have been proud of your stealthy route through the building? If a game contains stealth sections, why punish the player for being silent?

It’s not all bad though. The range of weaponry on offer is impressive in both quality and quantity, with an arsenal that includes some delightfully original secondary fire modes. Old favourites like the Laptop Gun are back (complete with wall-mounted turret of course) but some of the newer weapons are even more inspiring. There’s an SMG with a hologram function that projects a copy of your own self to fool enemies, a rifle with cloaking abilities (similar to the one in the original game) and there’s even a gun that will drug enemies so that they turn on each other when hit. There are also swords, shields and spinning blade discs in the mix too, along with the usual selection of pistols, shotguns, grenade launchers and sniper rifles. You could argue the point that a couple of the guns are a little too similar to each other, but for the most part the weapon selection on offer is Perfect Dark Zero’s biggest strength.

The same can’t be said however for the vehicles, which are uniformly dire. It’s probably not so much the fault of the vehicles themselves, although they don’t exactly handle well by any degree but more in the way that they are used. The vehicles, like a lot of the game, feel like they were thrown in just so they can tick off a box on a ‘things to include in an FPS’ checklist. Flying has rarely worked well in an FPS and Perfect Dark Zero’s jetpack certainly doesn’t. The Banshee in Halo 2 controlled very well and the levels offered the kind of space needed to make them a successful addition. With the jetpacks here, control is clumsy and the environments unsuitable, and it’s the same situation with the hovercraft.

Thankfully they can be turned off in the multiplayer, which co-incidentally is by far the strongest portion of the game. It plays a little like the old N64 game but more like the PC classic Counter Strike. There’s a wide selection of modes on offer to suit your multiplayer needs, each split into 2 styles of game. The ‘Deathmatch’ setting contains Killcount, which is your typical Deathmatch mode, and that can be played in teams along with games like CTF and Territories. The ‘Dark Ops’ mode however borrows heavily from Counter Strike. Using the same weapon purchase system at the start of the round you can play team elimination games as well as Sabotage where you try to cause as much damage to the other team’s base as possible. Onslaught has you defending a base for a set time limit against a respawning team carrying weaker weapons while Infection is a PALGN favourite. Here it’s a free-for-all game where you must avoid being killed by the skeleton players. Should you die you then become a skeleton and hunt down the rest of the ‘living’ players. Only if you survive the round do you get any points.

Gotta love the X-ray vision mode.

Gotta love the X-ray vision mode.
Close
The maps on offer are huge, present some nice variety in environments and contain a couple of smaller maps within them by cleverly changing the boundaries around each area. Still, with just six maps you can’t help feel a little shortchanged. Even moreso when people generally avoid two of the poorest ones (Temple and Desert), leaving only four. There may be more to come through the Live Marketplace, but we’re four months on from the USA release and there hasn’t been any word yet. On the plus side, the game runs like a dream on Xbox Live. When creating a room it’s easy to fill it with 16-32 players without it lagging. How it does that is a mystery; whether it’s just amazing netcode or whether it denies access to anyone with insufficient upload speed (which would explain the connection problems many have), it’s impressive either way as it’s refreshing playing a large game on Xbox Live without having to worry about lag.

On a technical ground, Perfect Dark Zero is as equally inconsistent as the rest of the game. Visually it can look very impressive at times. Super sharp texturing, eye catching environments and well modelled weaponry certainly give the game a next-gen look about it in parts. Plus the framerate is notably solid. But in other areas it’s disappointingly bland-looking. Lighting and shadowing appears incredibly basic and while the intentional almost cartoon-esque art style suits the game, it doesn’t excuse flat uses of colour or boxy geometry throughout the game.

Aurally, it's also a mixed bag. The soundtrack has that Rare quality and the general sound effects compliment the game well, but the voice acting is pure torture. Which is surprisingly really, given that Kameo contains some superb vocal work. Perhaps Rare's entire acting budget went on that, because the in game chatter in Perfect Dark Zero is hideous. On a related note, the 5.1 positioning does seem a little off, especially in multiplayer. There are times where it sounds like you’re getting shot from behind when in reality they’re to the side of you. It’s not a huge problem, but it does get confusing at times and really shouldn’t be happening when games like Halo and Rainbow Six 3 got it right perfectly on the original Xbox.

So after five years of waiting, it’s clear, at least from this, that Rare isn’t quite the same company it used to be when it comes to first person shooters. From just a few hours of play you get the feeling that although they’ve taken the basic elements that made their N64 games such a hit (the wide array of weaponry, the mission objectives, etc) something just isn’t right. The twitchy control, the inconsistent level design quality and the far from impressive AI puts Perfect Dark Zero’s single player campaign well within the depths of mediocrity. It has its moments, but they’re too few and far between to recommend this game at full price for anything other than multiplayer use.

As a multiplayer game it’s solid. Not fantastic, not great even, but enjoyable enough to warrant putting time into. With lots of options, a wealth of weapons, and lots of modes to play around with, it’s one of the stronger 360 games when it comes to online play, especially given how smooth it runs. Having said that, if the Call of Duty 2 multiplayer patch is released soon it would be very easy to suggest skipping on this completely, even more so with Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter, Battlefield and Far Cry on the near horizon. A few months ago things were different, but with those games arriving soon the whole Perfect Dark Zero thing is all a little redundant now.
The Score
Try before you buy. You could do a lot worse in terms of multiplayer gaming but for those wanting a single player game Perfect Dark Zero will probably be a disappointment. An enjoyable diversion a few months in the US/Euro launch lineup, but an irrelevant game now with bigger/better FPS’s now on the 360.
Looking to buy this game right now? PALGN recommends www.Play-Asia.com.

Related Perfect Dark Zero Content

Perfect Dark to receive 'true' sequel?
16 Oct, 2007 A perfect rumour?
Man invents robot to complete 360 game
01 Mar, 2007 And gain final Achievement points.
2 new classic maps for Perfect Dark Zero
01 Nov, 2006 Facility, anyone?
30 Comments
3 years ago
6.5!!!

HOOOOOOOOO BOY this is gunna piss some people off hardcore.
3 years ago
great review

it amazes me that everyone over at http://www.xboxworld.com.au/forums
has purchased this title.

there's just better stuff out now imo.
3 years ago
In hindsight I would not of purchased this now that the console has launched so late! But alas, I got one of those stupid VIP packs, so I'm stuck with it!
3 years ago
Spot on... normal graphics, lousy AI, so-so sound effect & ok game play
3 years ago
Looks like I'm still the resident PDZ nut, most likely due to a combination of hype as well as my love for the original. I find a lot of conflicting reviews flying around and this is no different. Gamespot gives it a 9.0 and here we are with a 6.5. You praise the second stealth level, yet others slam it for one reason or another.

For this reason I'm still going to stick with this game and find out for myself rather than deny myself the experience.
3 years ago
Bah, she no longer has her sexy british accent, so it fails instantly.
3 years ago
The fact that she turned from a Pom to an american really questions how much effort Rare put into the game.
3 years ago
Why weren't there different versions of the VIP released?Like say a 'racers' pack that had pgr in it or an 'action' pack that had kameo.Sorta sucks to lump people up with pdz.

Maybe we'll see figures of pdz being sold in the kabillions and rare touting it's the highest selling 360, purely cause most people had no other choice.
3 years ago
Jibbs wrote
Why weren't there different versions of the VIP released?Like say a 'racers' pack that had pgr in it or an 'action' pack that had kameo.Sorta sucks to lump people up with pdz.

Maybe we'll see figures of pdz being sold in the kabillions and rare touting it's the highest selling 360, purely cause most people had no other choice.
amen to this - i wanted a PGR3 pack.

i probably would have even got a kameo pack.
3 years ago
lol harsh, but probably fair. It's good to have reviews that contrast against other ones.. for example Gamespot who gave a 9.0.
3 years ago
Well I also have the game due to the VIP pack and am happy I have it. I'll find out tomorrow night whether I like it or not. I'm stuck with it for a while, considering I can't afford any more games.
3 years ago
Beepos wrote
lol harsh, but probably fair. It's good to have reviews that contrast against other ones.. for example Gamespot who gave a 9.0.
How is it good to have conflicting reviews? Just means people who actually pay for games can get lumped with a crappy game, that a retard gave a high score!
3 years ago
which is why you should check the reviewer's history.

has he/she (ha, who am i kidding? icon_razz.gif) liked/hated games you've liked/hated?

that sort of thing.

i tend to trust PALGN a whole lot more than most places i've read reviews.
3 years ago
It's good to have conflicting reviews as it shows we all have different opinions. If you buy a game based on a high score and it sucks well you derserve it. Reviews are simply opinions at the end of the day, and before purchasing a game you should read a wide array of them and decide if the game is for you.. not base it on one person.
3 years ago
plufim wrote
Bah, she no longer has her sexy british accent, so it fails instantly.
Indeed, I am incredibly dissapointed in this.

jameseybuddy wrote
How is it good to have conflicting reviews? Just means people who actually pay for games can get lumped with a crappy game, that a retard gave a high score!
I see, so if a game is given two scores, only the lower score is correct. Brilliant argument.
3 years ago
Hmmm... interesting indeed.
I bought the collectors edition yesterday, Im sure ill enjoy this game anyway.
3 years ago
Cerebral wrote
Looks like I'm still the resident PDZ nut, most likely due to a combination of hype as well as my love for the original. I find a lot of conflicting reviews flying around and this is no different. Gamespot gives it a 9.0 and here we are with a 6.5. You praise the second stealth level, yet others slam it for one reason or another.

For this reason I'm still going to stick with this game and find out for myself rather than deny myself the experience.
Don't worry Cer, I'm on the exact same stance you are. (with the only difference being that you will play the game before I will icon_wink.gif)
While I appreciate seeing the different viewpoints on this game I will still be giving it a thorough run before making my decision. Even if it does turn out to be crap I owe Rare at least one run through the game considering how much I love the original. (it is the best game ever, remember? icon_razz.gif)
Although...


plufim wrote
Bah, she no longer has her sexy british accent, so it fails instantly.
This disappoints me immensely. Can't believe Rare went ahead and changed the accent, such a shame.
3 years ago
NismoR34 wrote
plufim wrote
Bah, she no longer has her sexy british accent, so it fails instantly.
This disappoints me immensely. Can't believe Rare went ahead and changed the accent, such a shame.
To my untrained ears it sounds like she has a posh Pommy accent...

Multiplayer is a blast though, grab the RCP-90 or Shockwave and go to town on the bots. Oh and be sure to turn of jetpacks, the bots run for them like a bag of lollies!
3 years ago
Question: What attracted me to the original Perfect Dark so much was the futuristic setting (Flying cars, nifty buildings and what have you)

From most of the previews/pictures I've seen, it doesn't look very futuristic at all, I'm seeing jungles (?) and carparks, but no flying car goodness - how much of the game looks futuristic? (Meaning, the atmosphere has a futuristic feel)

(Apologies for bumping this back up)
3 years ago
The very first level of the game is as futuristic as it gets, really. Large offshore installation with a glowing blue datacore and camspy shenanigans? Yes please.

However as the game wears on, it does seem like the settings go from urban to rural. There's still your fair share of funky futuristic laboratory architecture though.
3 years ago
Well, being a prequel to Perfect Dark I guess it isn't too wise to expect the same amount of futuristic content but yeah, it does seem a little lacking in that department based on screenshots and so forth.
3 years ago
correct me if i'm wrong, but wasn't the story of the original Perfect Dark Joanna's first mission?

how is this a prequel? or is there some big spoiler that i haven't discovered yet (ie: PD had Joanna's memory wiped and she was a spy in a previous life too, The Long Kiss Goodnight style). or is PD0 not Joanna?

i know i could've asked this before, but it hasn't really bothered me all that much before.
3 years ago
I played the game at a friend's place...correction....i could only bear to watch a friend play and these are a couple of things I noticed....dirty wooden fences in back alleys have recently had a new coat of varnish cuz they produce more shine than puddles of water, the physics (or lack thereof) suck....it's almost impossible to blast someone off a ledge even with a shotty. There are about 3-4 enemy models (at least in the areas I saw) and they all look crap (e.g punk rocker with/without shirt/hair) Some areas look cartoony and some areas try to have a realistic look....they conflict horribly! There are sooooooo many bland textures.....just look at the cars....ewww! The explosions were horrible aswell.

I really don't know what it is about the game but i really dislike it. Granted almost all my negative points on the game are from a graphical perspective sooo.....don't mind me....I just really needed to get that out (damn Rare for changing the accent!).
3 years ago
not blowing people 20m with a gunshot is actually more physically realistic, unless the kickback from the gun also propels the shooter 20m in the other direction.

just a thought.

(yes, i watch Mythbusters, but yes, i was also aware of this Physical error before i saw that episode)
Add Comment
Like this review?
Share it with this tiny url: http://palg.nu/1BX

N4G : News for Gamers         Twitter This!

Digg!     Stumble This!

| More
  Pre-order or buy:
    PALGN recommends: www.Play-Asia.com

Australian Release Date:
  Out Now
European Release Date:
  Out Now
Publisher:
  Microsoft Game Studios
Developer:
  Rareware
Players:
  1-32

Extra:
Upto 32 players via Xbox Live

Read more...
Currently Popular on PALGN
Bioshock 2 Review
Welcome back to Rapture...
Win 1 of 10 Bioshock 2 packs
Includes free stuffs!
PALGN Weekly Releases - 08/02/10
Christmas in February?
Nier Preview
Nierly as dark and twisted as Drakengard.