Home
Twitter
RSS
Newsletter
Cian Hassett
14 Sep, 2011

NHL 12 Review

360 Review | A lesson in how to make a sports game.
Oh boy, it's that time of year again, when the market becomes flooded with annual updates to various different sports games. And who could it possibly be other than Electronic Arts to churn out these updates? They're masters of it, for better or worse. NHL 12 is here and is arguably the most successful of their main franchises (the others being Madden and FIFA). It doesn't sell the most copies but it has, over the past ten years at least, been the most consistent and rewarding sports game out there. And that winning streak has continued for another year, because NHL 12 is truly brilliant across the board.

Playing ice hockey in this country is a welcome breath of fresh air. Apologies in advance for this generalisation, but some Australians are obsessed to the point of ignorance with the cultural bogan festivities surrounding 'Aussie Rules'. So if you're in the same boat; fed up with the endless coverage of a sport that rewards you for missing (strange, eh?), and generally irked by the chants from obese, VB craving construction workers, then you might find a friend in NHL 12. You won't have to listen to people screaming "Good on ya son! CARN PIES!!", or similar phrases to make you wonder about how many intelligent people follow AFL. Ahem, like we said, it's a generalisation and the Americans aren't exactly role models either. Wait a second... we're supposed to be talking about NHL 12, aren't we? Fair dinkum, or something.

So little space, so much win...

So little space, so much win...
Close
It's as simple as this - NHL 12 is the best sports game of the year and it's highly unlikely that anything is going to change that. Where it succeeds and stands out more so than any other EA title, is in its 'Be A Pro' mode. The concept is far from new, but it's integrated much better than FIFA's version and really makes you feel part of a team. You can create a player and make him (or her) look perfectly normal or like something from a fifty year old science fiction movie. Afterwards, you can start in the lowest league and build up your attributes to create a heavy tackling, shot slapping machine. Again, nothing terribly new or revolutionary, but it's the presentation that really ties it all together. The support given by your coach and fellow players, the dynamic camera angle that always works properly, the superb commentary, the highlight reels... everything, it's second to none. Even if you're pulled from the rink because of your poor performance or struggling fitness, it just gives you more of an incentive to get back out there and perform well.

That's where you're going to find the heart and soul of not just NHL 12, but of the sport in general. No other sports game from EA, or even 2K, has been able to deliver so much and keep it so personal at the same time. There's an abundance of extra modes too (it's quite ridiculous actually), including the online based 'Ultimate Team' which is a lengthy journey in itself. Even within Be A Pro, you'll find more options including 'Be A Legend' where you can relive the career of some of the sport's greatest players. That's only the start of NHL 12, there's an enormous amount of content to play around with. Slight improvements have been made to the physics engine too, making every hit feel extra crunchy and every slick move feel extra smooth. Also, the glass around the rink can be broken, and if you really want to embarrass the opposition, then how about slamming them over the railing and into the benches?

Ouch, he won't be walking straight anytime soon.

Ouch, he won't be walking straight anytime soon.
Close
Of course the gameplay is still terrific as you'd expect it to be: fast, brutal, punishing, rewarding, deep, accessible, and never boring. Ice hockey has infinitely more versatility than any grass sport. Traditional football is made up of models who throw tantrums if their salary is less than six figures per week, rugby is susceptible to sluggish passages of play, and we've already mentioned the flaws of the local Australian football. Although to be fair, NHL 12 will take some time to become familiar with if you're not a supporter, but once you get your head around the rules then it's fairly simple. The controls are excellent too, with all of your shots mapped to the right analogue stick for power and precision, while defensive and passing moves are left to the shoulder pads. Some other, more technical aspects of play require the face buttons but it's not mandatory if you're playing casually or simply looking to start a fight.

And those fights can be seen up close in extreme detail, much like the rest of the game which looks brilliant once again. It's not an overhaul by any stretch of the imagination (since when has that ever been the case?), but it's still a gorgeous looking game even with all of those clones in the crowd. NHL 12 looks great where it matters - on the ice; player likenesses, scrapes and scratches, it doesn't get any more authentic. The whole package is practically free of problems in the gameplay department, but it does suffer from a long running problem with EA Sports - the bloody menus. Why can't they run smoothly and why hasn't this been fixed? The same issue plagues FIFA every year and they're obviously sharing assets between studios, so why not address the problem? You'll constantly get slowed down in the career modes as a result and it almost ruins the otherwise flawless presentation. EA servers are notoriously unreliable and nothing has changed, and this is partly why the flow evaporates outside of the actual matches. Just be thankful you don't have to spend an overly lengthy period of time off the ice.

Men should not be this flexible in their lower regions.

Men should not be this flexible in their lower regions.
Close
The only other way that you could possibly fault NHL 12 is by asking the question, is it enough of an improvement over the game we bought twelve months ago? That's your decision to make. NHL 12 is essential for pure, hardcore fans of ice hockey who've already made up their mind. In fact, they're probably playing it right now. If you're a casual fan then you're not going to be one hundred percent satisfied with this as it's more of a refinement and less of a full upgrade. And if you want to get into ice hockey for the first time, then look no further. Realistically, NHL 12 is going to last you until the end of 2011 with the single player modes alone. When you bring it online, the game becomes endless. There was a minor bit of lag because the only games available were hosted in America, which is to be expected, but it's still playable which is impressive given that ice hockey is the fastest sport in the world. When it's released tomorrow, everything is ready to go for those wishing to get stuck into the online modes straight away. Just don't tell your partner that you're buying it.

NHL 12 is the pinnacle of sports games, whether it's football or rugby or polo or lawn bowls. The game understands what makes the sport so damn good in the first place and never tries to improve it with fancy gimmicks or stupid new additions. By concentrating where it matters most, EA has delivered one of their finest ever sports games. It's the closest you'll get to being there yourself, but you can do it in the comfort of your own home without falling flat on your arse, or even worse, being knocked unconscious. NHL 12 is a triumph, setting an example that others will hopefully follow. It hasn't revolutionised the sport because it doesn't need to, it just keeps focusing on what's already great. NHL 12 is more than great, it's the best yet, and God knows how they're going to top this next year...
The Score
NHL 12 is the new benchmark that sports games will aspire to challenge, it's also the best and most complete title that EA Sports has released in years. 9
Looking to buy this game right now? PALGN recommends www.Play-Asia.com.

Related Content

NHL 12 trailer
14 Jul, 2011 Slam and score.
NHL 09 Review
26 Sep, 2008 EA scores.
NHL 2K8 Preview
23 Sep, 2007 Looking like an improvement?
10 Comments
1 year ago
You lost me at the 2nd paragraghs rant, what were you last picked for the Aussie Rules team at school? still hurtin'?

As a Kiwi living in here its actually quite clear Aussies are infact very multi-coded with their winter sport support, AFL, NRL, Super Rugby and Football(Soccer) all feature strong support here, Unlike NZ's one-eyed Rugby fascination.
1 year ago
i somehow doubt that his school played aussie rules at all

"carn' dublin" or similiar
1 year ago
Haha, exactly the reaction I was expecting...but I never expected the humour/observation to translate very well.

I'll put it to you like this (in fear of starting a pointless debate), when the "footie" takes priority over the tenth anniversary of 9/11, then I have a problem with it. Readers of The Age will understand. And as for the back pages of The Herald Sun...jesus christ :/

Also the people I work with (not here), are terribly cliched. DOGGIES, YEEEEEHHH ROOOOIIIIGHTTT!!! Stuff like that.

It's difficult to explain if you're not seeing it from an outsider's perspective.
1 year ago
It's difficult to explain even if you've grown up in Melbourne all your life! One thing I will say for our AFL supporters is that they don't partake in the riots and alcohol-infused violent behaviour (on a grand scale) typified by soccer (yes, I know, 'football') fans.

I digress! Nice review, Cian. My experience with ice hockey games is restricted to good old Wayne Gretzky 64.
1 year ago
NBA 2K11 is a better sports game than this for the end game highlight reels alone.
1 year ago
I will be picking this up like I do every year since 94.

I loved the demo, the slight gameplay changes are great, especially in front of the net and also the free flowing puck.

The only setback is that I bet there will be 1000000 interference calls now you can wallop the goaltender.

The changes to be a pro I'm really looking forward to playing with. I hope that you can request trades or be involved with trades etc.

How is the online? Is it the same as last years? Is it smooth vs. North Americans?
1 year ago
myzz wrote
How is the online? Is it the same as last years? Is it smooth vs. North Americans?
It doesn't jitter around like FIFA, if that's what you're asking. Although there is a noticeable second delay so defending can be tricky at times, you should be able to manage ok with the offence though. Hopefully a few locals pick it up and stick with it, I'll be playing it well into next year.

If you're on XBL then you can add me for a game (I'm rubbish): Bushy Wookiee
1 year ago
Ridiculous "commentary" in that second paragraph. I assume you're not a bogan if you only indulge in competitions based overseas? Just absurd and completely irrelevant to the review of this game.

I can't think of a footy fan that doesn't enjoy other sports in addition to their, as you put it, obesity and alcohol-fuelled obsession with their native game. Surprised you didn't throw in a broad, sweeping generalisation on dental hygiene while you were hitting those heights.

Haven't played this yet, but I'd be surprised if it has replaced the benchmark NBA 2K11 set.
1 year ago
mrpookles wrote
I can't think of a footy fan that doesn't enjoy other sports in addition to their, as you put it, obesity and alcohol-fuelled obsession with their native game. Surprised you didn't throw in a broad, sweeping generalisation on dental hygiene while you were hitting those heights.
I considered it, but Irish teeth are notoriously yellow so I'm in no position to judge.

I'd love to show you where I work, a place where footy is the only sport and you're pretty much labelled as an outcast if you don't follow it. Don't get me wrong, I have no issue whatsoever with people supporting their native sport, it's natural and it's to be expected, but there's no balance here. You'd be lucky to find two pages of information on the Rugby World Cup in most papers...you know, an event that only takes place every four years. But instead you get fifteen pages of AFL and every other sport in the world is crammed into the remaining five. And you know I'm right on that point.

Sorry if I offended y'all, it's just what I've noticed over the past four years here. It's a shame because if it wasn't for the majority of supporters, I actually wouldn't mind following AFL, but I have zero tolerance of ignorance in sport. Drives me crazy, and it's rife in Melbourne which is ironic seeing as it's the 'capital of sport'. Maybe I just need to get out of the eastern suburbs...actually scrap that, maybe it's just Ringwood? That might explain it.
1 year ago
I saw a video clip of this on nhl.com with the following at the end.
Nice to see palgn’s writers get some recognition.
It's just a pitty the didn't add the .au LOL

congrats i guess, mr bigtime.

Add Comment
Like this review?
Share it with this tiny url: http://palg.nu/4Ze

N4G : News for Gamers         Twitter This!

Digg!     Stumble This!

| More
  Pre-order or buy:
    PALGN recommends: www.Play-Asia.com

Australian Release Date:
  15/09/2011 (Confirmed)
Publisher:
  Electronic Arts
Genre:
  Sports
Year Made:
  2011

Read more...
Currently Popular on PALGN
Australian Gaming Bargains - 08/12/11
'Tis the season to be bargaining.
R18+ Legislation
R18+ Legislation
Naruto Shippuden: Ultimate Ninja Storm Generations Preview
Hands on time with the game. Chat time with the CEO of CyberConnect 2.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2007
24 titles to keep an eye on during 2007.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2008
And you thought 2007 was populated.