Home
Twitter
RSS
Newsletter
Jeremy Jastrzab
17 Aug, 2010

Red Dead Redemption: Legends & Killers Review

360 Feature | Once were legends.
Back in May, we reviewed a little game called Red Dead Redemption. It was good. Later, the developers at Rockstar released free downloadable content in the form of the Outlaws to the End co-op mission pack. And free is good. Now, the first of four paid downloadable content packs, Legends & Killers, has become available. So, is it still good?

Legends & Killers is a relatively small download, clocking in at about 40MB, and is available for Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3 for 800 MS points and AU$15.95 respectively. For all the merit in the multiplayer of Red Dead Redemption, the plain and simple truth is that the game’s primary shining star is the single player. While Legends & Killers primarily expands on the multiplayer, there have been a few minor additions that can be used in single player.

There's a new sheriff in town.

There's a new sheriff in town.
Close
This comes in the form of a new weapon: the Tomahawk, which can be purchased at the Manzanita Outpost. For use in both single and multiplayer, this versatile little do-hacky can be considered both a melee and ranged weapon. In the single player, you’ll get a whole new set of challenges to accompany your new toy, which will take you a while to get through. In multiplayer, there is nothing quite as satisfying as hitting a ‘Hail Mary’ on an unsuspecting opponent. Used sparingly, it can be fun. But as the saying goes, don’t bring a Tomahawk to a gun fight…

Simply put, if you’re only in Red Dead Redemption for the single player, a Tomahawk and a few challenges isn’t really worth your points/dollars. However, the multiplayer has been given the most additions. Free Roam still remains pretty much the same, though a DLC pack is meant to add to this mode before year’s end. Otherwise, the Legends & Killers pack is adding to your maps and characters for the more traditional multiplayer modes. These additions are easily accessible from the multiplayer menu and will open up upon purchase.

Horsey fights back.

Horsey fights back.
Close
Upon purchase of the Legends & Killers pack, you’ll have access to eight characters from the cast of the game’s spiritual predecessor, Red Dead Revolver. This includes Red Harlow, the protagonist, and instantly recognisable characters such as Pig Josh (who like Red, has a new achievement attached) and Ugly Chris (no, that's not an ironic name). All characters manage to retain their looks while adapting to the more realistic locales of Red Dead Redemption. Furthermore, it seems that people can see your Red Dead Revolver character in Free Roam, regardless of whether they've purchased it as well.

Aside from the addition of characters, nine multiplayer maps have been added. Encouragingly, this substantially increases the number of playable maps. Disappointingly, all of these ‘new’ maps are simply recycled from the single player/Free Roam. We guess that this explains the download size. To the game’s credit, these maps actually make for good multiplayer maps, but it’s disappointing that more wasn’t done. For example, there are no maps that pay homage to Red Dead Revolver. Also, additions such as the Gatling guns aren’t too useful, as you’re essentially giving away your position way too easily and becoming a sitting duck, while some individual spawn points aren't the best considered, often leading to concurrent spawns or positions that favour campers.

I smell bacon!

I smell bacon!
Close
Three of the existing maps: Diez Coronas, Pacific Union Railroad Camp and Tumbleweed are now available with more playable modes. Interestingly, it seems that a lot of the players that are still plugging away at the frantic multiplayer matches have jumped on the Legends & Killers bandwagon, as the multiplayer was well-populated and often free of lag. The regular multiplayer modes seem to have been… deserted.

As often seems to be the talking point with DLC, the big question around Legends & Killers; is it worth the money? Well, if all you do is play single player, then no. It’s disappointing that the theme of rekindling Red Dead Revolver really hasn’t been utilised to the fullest possible extent and that the new multiplayer maps, while applied well, aren’t really 'new'. However, there was the little matter of a DLC pack called the Stimulus Package for this other little game, which cost more and didn’t give you that much… So as far as multiplayer packs go, Legends & Killers in the very least provides the minimum from what any multiplayer afficionado would expect from a multiplayer DLC pack.

Worth buying? Maybe

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Downloadable content ratings system

We've given a 'buy' rating of 'Yes', 'Maybe', or 'No'.

Yes means that the content is either great value or brings some substantial additions to the game, or possibly both.

Maybe means that the content may be fun while it lasts, but may either be too short or not enough to fully justify the price tag.

No means that we don't recommend downloading this insubstantial content.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Related Red Dead Redemption Content

XBLA: Red Dead Redemption Undead Nightmare Review
09 Nov, 2010 Boogey boogey boogey!
Red Dead Redemption: Liars and Cheats trailer
16 Sep, 2010 Did you just say...explosive rifle?
7 Comments
2 years ago
Thanks for the comprehensive review. $16 is a little too steep for me, so I might give it a miss...... for now.
2 years ago
Nice review and I agree, the price is a bit too dear. Having just finished single player, I was surprised to see how lag free and empty multiplayer was. Now I know why, it's because of this addon.
2 years ago
Not necessarily, I have had those issues with empty multiplayer from day one. Sometimes I start a freeroam and there is no one, but if I load a diferent free roam there are suddenly heaps of other players. The multiplayer really needs a lobby so you can at least have the option of selecting games where players are manually.
2 years ago
Great review.. $16 is way too pricey for such a small DLC... I guess for those who prefer the more "traditional" multiplayer gaming but set in a western environment, this would be ok.. though still seems a little expensive for the amount of content being added... which is not that much at all really.
2 years ago
Thanks for the review, it was very useful in making an informed decision. Was interested in getting back into this game, but it seems this is not the DLC for me (especially at that price).
2 years ago
would much prefer single player DLC.
2 years ago
Yeah, multiplayer DLC is obviously a lot easier to do because this is a much richer single player game so you think that would be the emphasis.

Even if they introduced a DLC pack with a few new stranger missions and some new animals to hunt I'd buy it.
Add Comment
Like this feature?
Share it with this tiny url: http://palg.nu/4es

N4G : News for Gamers         Twitter This!

Digg!     Stumble This!

| More
  Pre-order or buy:
    PALGN recommends: www.Play-Asia.com

Australian Release Date:
  21/05/2010 (Confirmed)
Publisher:
  Take 2 Interactive
Genre:
  Shooter
Year Made:
  2009
Players:
  1

Read more...
Currently Popular on PALGN
Australian Gaming Bargains - 08/12/11
'Tis the season to be bargaining.
R18+ Legislation
R18+ Legislation
Naruto Shippuden: Ultimate Ninja Storm Generations Preview
Hands on time with the game. Chat time with the CEO of CyberConnect 2.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2007
24 titles to keep an eye on during 2007.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2008
And you thought 2007 was populated.