Home
Twitter
RSS
Newsletter
Jeremy Jastrzab
05 Nov, 2009

Grand Theft Auto: Episodes from Liberty City Review

360 Review | Two stories for the price of less than a new one.
While it took a lot longer than initially promised, Rockstar has finally delivered the two downloadable episodes to compliment Grand Theft Auto IV. The Lost and Damned and The Ballad of Gay Tony are now both available on Xbox Live. However, those who don’t have access to Live, can get both of these DLC episodes on the one retail disc. And they won’t even need a copy of GTA IV to play.

Upon loading the game, players will have access to both The Lost and Damned and The Ballad of Gay Tony from the outset. Both stories are self-contained within the Liberty City of GTA IV, so you don’t need to have played the original though experience will help. In truth, both DLC episodes assume that you’ve already played as Niko, given that both skip through a lot of formalities and intricacies that were so carefully spelled out in GTA IV, both through gameplay and story. On the plus side, it means that you’re pretty much in the thick of things from the get go.

Be part of Johnny's low-life gang...

Be part of Johnny's low-life gang...
Close
The Lost and Damned has you playing as Johnny Klebitz, a senior member from the bikie gang, ‘The Lost’. Johnny’s story revolves around the growing instability of Billy, the leader of The Lost. And it’s up to Johnny to make sure that the gang and club is still functioning, while putting up with his enigmatic leader. The Ballad of Gay Tony, puts you in the shoes of Luis Lopez, the right hand man and cleaner to nightlife tycoon, Tony “Gay Tony” Prince. Luis’ story revolves around the debts owed on the clubs that he runs for Gay Tony and how they’ve jumped in bed with the wrong people.

While both tell a decent story about moving forward with past baggage and 'all in a day's work', neither of the episode stories contains the sombre karmic undertones from the original. However the real beauty behind the stories is how they all come together with Niko’s story, and in particular, how some of the things you did as Niko were set up or followed up by either Johnny or Luis. In particular, the whole business revolving around the ‘diamonds’ and the missions around the museum will all come together but be all these references will be completely lost on those who haven’t played through GTA IV. Still, some references are difficult to pick up 18 months down the track, even if you have played through all three stories.

As mentioned above, both the Johnny and Luis arcs skip a lot of the formalities introduced in the Niko arc that revolved around ‘building’ the character. Johnny is already firmly entrenched as a bottom feeder, while Luis will spend time in slightly more illustrious company. The presented contrast between all three is quite interesting, but TLAD does the best job of really providing a contrasting experience from both a story and gameplay perspective. As Johnny, you really feel like you’re part of a bikie gang. TBOGT on the other hand is probably a bit too similar, as it only does more of what Niko didn’t do very often, such as riding in helicopters and Luis sometimes feels too much like the lackey that Niko often was, despite being one of the more likeable characters.

Or part of the high life with Luis.

Or part of the high life with Luis.
Close
Since both of these stories are building off the original game, most of your missions are pretty nuts from the get go. With Johnny, you have all your contacts already in place and you’ve got missions that allow you to take gang members to help you out. With Luis on the other hand, you do stupid things like steal a military helicopter, tank and a subway cart. The handiest addition to both of these is a checkpoint system that doesn’t require players to restart from the beginning of each mission. TBOGT also adds a score to the end of each mission, which can be improved upon once the game has been completed. Each story has its highlights and each of them will take about 10 hours to complete. As such, you’re pretty much getting around 20 hours of story-based gameplay from this entire package.

Of course, the story is only part of the game, as both Johnny and Luis have brought some extra tricks to the party. In TLAD, you have races (where you can belt other riders with bats), gang wars and stealing custom bikes. Furthermore, there have been a handful of new and thematic multiplayer modes, ‘Witness Protection’ and ‘Chopper Vs Chopper’. The latter has one player on a bike and another in a helicopter. In TBOGT, you have a golf shooting range, nightclub dancing, drug wars and cage fighting championship, as well as the welcome return of parachuting and base jumping, to both single and multiplayer. Some of the other diversions are comparatively weak though, such as the night club dancing which is very easy to stumble through and get the ‘reward’. Other additions to the game include three new radio stations (such as Vice City FM), along with newly recorded audio for existing stations.

Most DLC is released very close to the original game, but releasing these episodes so late hasn’t been the most favourable move. Why? Well, while GTA IV has some impressive improvements over it’s predecessors, a lot of people got too excited about it at time and as such, the fundamental flaws of the original were not critiqued and stick out much worse 18 months down the track. And since DLC is based off the same game, there is no room for improving these fundamentals. So while new players lose out on the story, veterans often have to put up with an exacerbation of gameplay faults.

Gliding is for wimps!

Gliding is for wimps!
Close
In the 18 months between now and the release of GTA IV, the faults are much more grating. Whether it’s a case of the original’s design being better or the mechanics were simply not up to scratch, the tradition of failing missions on fighting the controls and a lack of luck rather than skill still infuriates. All three protagonists are way too clunky in their movements, the cover system only works well in set pieces and gets confused more often than not, enemy AI is very erratic in their skills and the targeting system is borderline on busted in firefights of more than a few enemies. While still a visually impressive set of titles, the over ambition is at times harshly exposed, as something has gone wrong in the conversion of this game. Along with the graphical conversion, the lazy achievement design, where all of the achievements from GTA IV are still unlockable, even if you don’t have the original game point to a rushed job.

As a value package, Grand Theft Auto: Episodes from Liberty with it’s streamlined stories and budget price is a very good proposition. This is a GTA that most people will be able to finish. Johnny’s story has some genuine distinguishing factors, while Luis is all about going large. However, new players won’t be privy to the intriguingly intertwined story, while veterans are putting up with mechanics and gameplay quirks that really should have been better upon the initial release of GTA IV. Furthermore, there is evidence that the compilation was a rushed effort. As far as a package goes, it’s all here and all has the potential to provide a riot of a time but Rockstar would do well to get their mechanics up to scratch once the production of GTA V gets under way.
The Score
Grand Theft Auto: Episodes from Liberty City is a robust and highly enjoyable package that is held back by the limitations of the original game.
Looking to buy this game right now? PALGN recommends www.Play-Asia.com.

Related Grand Theft Auto: Episodes from Liberty City Content

GTA Episodes head to the PS3 and PC
29 Jan, 2010 You should've known it was coming.
Another GTA: Episodes From Liberty City Trailer
08 Oct, 2009 There's always a girl!
New The Ballad of Gay Tony character video
10 Sep, 2009 The man himself.
21 Comments
3 months ago
The reviews for this game demonstrate just how quickly technology moves in the gaming industry. What was a technical marvel only 18 months ago is already looking dated.

I'll have to pick up Ballad of Gay Tony once I'm done with uni, looks like a lot of fun.
3 months ago
Is this disc hitting the PS3 library?
3 months ago
The episodes are exclusive to 360, they're not appearing on PS3.
3 months ago
I'm willing to bet its a timed exclusive thingy, I'm sure it will end up on PS3 at some stage just like the Fallout 3 content. In any case ill be picking this up tonight.
3 months ago
I'd be surprised if it's a timed exclusive actually. Microsoft paid US$50m for this.
3 months ago
I might wait a few weeks until I move, but I think I'm just going to have to buy a 360. I have to play this, and I'm sure once I have an Xbox I'll find other exclusive games to make it a worthwhile purchase.
3 months ago
Does anyone know if the episodes on disc are censored at all?

I asked this in the DLC thread but got no reply :/
3 months ago
Jeremy?

Maybe you could help me out! icon_biggrin.gif
3 months ago
As far as I'm aware, The Lost and Damned is censored.

In The Ballad of Gay Tony, I can't say for sure. For one, the cut-scenes are definitely uncensored. But as for the... extra cirriculars, they come in various and new forms, so I never got back to seeing whether the older parts are censored.

I didn't notice too many pools of blood or damage models either, so I'd say that neither are here either.
3 months ago
Nuts icon_sad.gif

It's just the blood pools and pain skins that are missing from TLaD right? Please tell me the cutscenes are untouched!
3 months ago
keyofx wrote
Nuts icon_sad.gif

It's just the blood pools and pain skins that are missing from TLaD right? Please tell me the cutscenes are untouched!
Is it going to stop you from buying it? Just get it and check it out for yourself.....I'm sure it wont kill the experience for you.
3 months ago
Of course it will kill the experience, especially if the cutscenes have been gimped!

I wouldn't buy a censored DVD, CD or book so why shouldn't the same standards be applied to a videogame?
3 months ago
Jeremy wrote
As far as I'm aware, The Lost and Damned is censored.

In The Ballad of Gay Tony, I can't say for sure. For one, the cut-scenes are definitely uncensored. But as for the... extra cirriculars, they come in various and new forms, so I never got back to seeing whether the older parts are censored.

I didn't notice too many pools of blood or damage models either, so I'd say that neither are here either.
Well buddy if you had actually read it, it appears they aren't, well at least for THBOGT...pretty sure it would apply to TLAD as well....one scene in GTAIV was censored i'm pretty sure and I still played it to death and loved every moment of it. The experience will be what you make it....Anyway R* are pretty good at doing it alternative for cotton wool wrapped Australia.

If you never knew it was gimped would you still be upset? Like a tree falling in the woods?
3 months ago
But the fact is I DO know. Why wouldacouldashoulda at all?

And anyway, That's you. This is me. Let it be.

I'd still appreciate it if Jeremy took the time to answer that little query icon_biggrin.gif
3 months ago
You dont know about TLAD so don't ask ha ha icon_wink.gif
3 months ago
You mean for TLAD? From what I remember (having played it back in February), it didn't seem that any of the cut-scenes were touched. There still is that ONE scene that caused a stir so, I doubt there was anything censored in cut scenes. But truthfully, I can't say for sure.

Either way, the disc version is identical to the downloads. So what's on the downloads will be on the disc.
3 months ago
Jeremy wrote
Either way, the disc version is identical to the downloads. So what's on the downloads will be on the disc.
THIS is what I was worried about. I've been reading that the DLC version of TLaD was UNCENSORED here! Something about R* patching the game after release that unlocked the blood pools, etc. I was kinda hoping that they've leave it the same way for the disc version too.

Ah well.

Anyhow, at least the cutscenes are alright. Excellent, thanks Jeremy icon_biggrin.gif
3 months ago
TLAD is definitely uncut both on the DLC and he disc. TLAD DLC also used to make the cut version of GTAIV uncut also if I remember correctly. So far in BoGT I can't see anywhere that the game would be censored so far after playing 10 or 12 hours. The cut scenes don't feel they have been cut at all.
3 months ago
TheAnswer wrote
TLAD is definitely uncut both on the DLC and he disc. TLAD DLC also used to make the cut version of GTAIV uncut also if I remember correctly. So far in BoGT I can't see anywhere that the game would be censored so far after playing 10 or 12 hours. The cut scenes don't feel they have been cut at all.
Uncut *including* blood pools and pain skins??

/excited again!
3 months ago
It gets under my skin how ignorant people can be sometimes. Honestly, do you people think to do the slightest bit of research? You're just perpetuating ignorance.

It was common knowledge some time ago that PC version of GTA IV was passed uncut by the CB. As a result Rockstar also released the DLC uncensored, which consequently patched the original console versions as well.

Some reviewer Jeremy is, what has become of critics? Just a few moments ago I was reading about Modern Warfare 2 being censored in Germany and the author just went ahead and *assumed* the Australian release is also censored. This is despite the Classification Report stating otherwise and details of it being published more more than a week ago.

Does the press do nothing but publish crap these days? It's all assumptions and sensationalism. For the sake of your integrity and self respect, get the bloody facts right!!!!
3 months ago
MikeZombie777 wrote
It gets under my skin how ignorant people can be sometimes. Honestly, do you people think to do the slightest bit of research? You're just perpetuating ignorance.

It was common knowledge some time ago that PC version of GTA IV was passed uncut by the CB. As a result Rockstar also released the DLC uncensored, which consequently patched the original console versions as well.

Some reviewer Jeremy is, what has become of critics? Just a few moments ago I was reading about Modern Warfare 2 being censored in Germany and the author just went ahead and *assumed* the Australian release is also censored. This is despite the Classification Report stating otherwise and details of it being published more more than a week ago.

Does the press do nothing but publish crap these days? It's all assumptions and sensationalism. For the sake of your integrity and self respect, get the bloody facts right!!!!
Last I checked the whole point of being a reviewer is to talk about your impressions of the game and how it runs, not know whether or not it was censored.
Add Comment
Like this review?
Share it with this tiny url: http://palg.nu/3L1

N4G : News for Gamers         Twitter This!

Digg!     Stumble This!

| More
  Pre-order or buy:
    PALGN recommends: www.Play-Asia.com

Australian Release Date:
  29/10/2009 (Confirmed)
Standard Retail Price:
  $69.95 AU
Publisher:
  Rockstar Games
Genre:
  Action
Year Made:
  2009
Players:
  1

Read more...
Currently Popular on PALGN
Bioshock 2 Review
Welcome back to Rapture...
Win 1 of 10 Bioshock 2 packs
Includes free stuffs!
PALGN Weekly Releases - 08/02/10
Christmas in February?
Dante's Inferno Review
Is it Divine, or unwittingly Comedic?