Home
Twitter
RSS
Newsletter
Kimberley Ellis
14 Jul, 2009

XBLA: Battlefield 1943 Review

360 Review | Back to basics.
Servers crashing, people unable to connect to the game, a broken party system - these were some of the issues that have dominated the launch of DICE's downloadable title, Battlefield 1943, last week thankfully, many of those hiccups have been ironed out. But despite all of the setbacks that it has suffered, Battlefield 1943 lives up to the high standards set by its forefather, the PC classic Battlefield 1942, presenting gamers with a solid multiplayer shooter that will keep the console brethren clamouring back for more.

While it is sold as a downloadable title, don't let the platform or bargain price fool you - this game has been lovingly crafted by the development team at DICE, built from the groundwork of it entertaining console brother Battlefield: Bad Company - which we here at PALGN thought quite highly of.

The importance of good tank maintenance cannot be overlooked.

The importance of good tank maintenance cannot be overlooked.
Close
For those that are familiar with the popular FPS series, you won't find any surprises with the gameplay in Battlefield 1943. This title returns players to the era that made the Battlefield name, World War II. Though this time it take a fresh spin on quite a stale genre by setting the game in the Pacific theatre of war with the Americans taking on the might of the Rising Sun. Initially this may seem like just another generic WWII shooter, which die-hard Battlefield veterans will most likely scoff at due to the bare bones nature of the game, but DICE should be commended for bringing something different to the table. This cheap title presents players with a stripped back edition of Battlefield that is fast, fun and easy to learn - not to mention it's pretty good looking to boot.

At the moment, 1943 contains only one game mode, Conquest. The mode divides players into two armies ( US forces and the Japanese) where teams will duke it out against each other over capture points that are placed in different sections of each map. The objective of the game is for each team to capture the points to gain tactical advantage over the opposition, giving you a better chance to wipe out enemy reinforcements before they can establish a foothold in your territory. The to-and-fro nature of Conquest allows for some very intense and competitive battles, with players banding together to capture a point. Like most multiplayer titles there is always a gung-ho lone wolf type hanging around, but for the most part we were lucky enough to find ourselves working co-operatively amongst our squad members to help turn the tide of battle. Nevertheless, twenty-four players crammed onto one map makes for some hella good run-and-gun action.

A second game mode - Air Superiority - has been confirmed, which will see players jump into the cockpit and take to the sky for an online aerial battle for air superiority of the Pacific. We are unable to experience what Air Superiority has to offer as DICE are not making it available until players have completed the Coral Sea Challenge - a competition which pits Xbox 360 players against PlayStation 3 players in a race to collectively reach forty-three million kills in order to unlock the mode and the fourth game map 'Coral Sea'.

We can only imagine what's in-store for gamers when air superiority arrives.

We can only imagine what's in-store for gamers when air superiority arrives.
Close
One of the hallmarks of the Battlefield series is vehicular combat, and 1943 is no different, giving players four different vehicles to choose from. For those that like to make their presence felt, the tank proves to be the vehicle of choice as this slow-moving beast can easily carve up enemy units and structures. The jeep is mainly used for quickly transporting the troops (or hooning around the map if you're into that kind of thing), but loaded up with a few good men, it can prove to be a quick and deadly form of attack. Boats have only one singular purpose, but it's a rather important one - getting the troops from the aircraft carrier to the battlefield. If you can manage to stop the boats from reaching the island, you'll effectively cut off the oppositions line of reinforcements. The final vehicle is by far the best - the aeroplane. These planes can take off from both land or sea and prove to be quite a handful as they can easily strafe enemy infantry or bomb the enemy into submission.

One of the most important factors of an FPS title is how well it handles, and while many purists will say that nothing compares to the good, old mouse and keyboard combo, the gap between console controllers and the classic PC combination is closing. Those familiar with Battlefield: Bad Company will feel quite at ease with the controls of 1943. Controlling the aeroplane will likely prove to be the most taxing aspect of the title to master, but after a short session with the game you'll be dropping bombs like a genuine bombardier. The other vehicles are quite easy to get the hang of, as is the general control of your infantry soldier.

Take me down to the paradise city, where the grass is green and the bombs are pretty.

Take me down to the paradise city, where the grass is green and the bombs are pretty.
Close
Which brings us to the class system of Battlefield 1943. The game breaks down infantry classes into three separate types, each with their own pros and cons. The rifleman comes equipped with a standard issue rifle, complete with iron sights which allows players to pick off targets from both close range and long range (which easily makes it the number one choice for gamers who like to maneuver in-and-out of the action) along with grenades to help you take out some pesky enemy vehicles. The scout class is for those who like to partake in the action from a distance, coming equipped with a sniper rifle and pistol, plus a satchel charge. Thanks to the large scale of the game's maps you'll have many opportunities to put your snipping skills to the test. For players who like to get up and personal, the infantry class is your best bet. While this class' sub-machine gun presents players with some short range limitations, the secondary bazooka weapon makes this class handy to have when you find yourself up against an enemy tank. The infantry class also allows players to repair your army's vehicles, but this is a feature that we've rarely found used during our extensive look at the title. Of course, at the end of the day it all boils down to player preference as to which player class gets your vote of confidence.

From a visual standpoint, 1943 is not the bees knees of what we have come to expect out of the Xbox 360, though it must be said that for a downloadable multiplayer title that boasts twenty-four players in online play, we are quite impressed with the detail that has gone into each map. Look closely though and you'll spot a few jaggies.

Whether you bleed for all things Battlefield or are just a gamer after a moderately priced casual shooter that is fun to pick up and play, you can't go past the entertaining gameplay of Battlefield 1943. However, we can't help but wonder whether players will stick around the 1943 servers once Battlefield: Bad Company 2 arrives. Until then though, the tropical setting of the title best describes our opinion of Battlefield 1943 - utter paradise.
The Score
Whether you bleed for all things Battlefield or are just a gamer after a moderately priced casual shooter that is fun to pick up and play, you can't go past the entertaining gameplay of Battlefield 1943.
Looking to buy this game right now? PALGN recommends www.Play-Asia.com.

Related XBLA: Battlefield 1943 Content

Xbox Live Deal of the Week - 16/02/10
16 Feb, 2010 This battlefield will be a glorious wasteland.
Battlefield 1943 breaks records
26 Jul, 2009 1943 smashes digital title sales figures.
Battlefield 1943 dated and priced
25 Apr, 2009 Get set to return to Wake Island later this year.
18 Comments
2 years ago
I'm a big fan of this game, personally. Been playing it a little now, can't wait until I have a few days off to play it for the day.
2 years ago
I like this game but the only thing i hate is that you can't do your own private matches unless you have 16 people.... (anyone got a way around this)
2 years ago
Great review, but I'm really surprised Kimberley that you didn't catch on to the latter part of the title, 1943. It's purposely named as such as it's a almost identical in gameplay and presentation to the very first title in the serious, Battlefield 1942.

In fact, it pretty much IS Battlefield 1942 albeit with updated graphics. That game is also where they've derived the maps from (these are all extremely popular maps played by and familiar to millions of people around the world for years).

That feeling of nostalgia is half the reason I purchased it on PS3, and why I'm loving it so much :)

Anyway, just thought I'd give the heads up!
2 years ago
PS3 Keyboard & Mouse support??? Steam Release??? No! Well it isn't 4 me then.
2 years ago
For me, I see, rather then investing in continuing the series (BF3) they rather rehash the begining. I mean as it has been said, it's BF1942 with updated graphics, less maps, less vehicles, less infantry class'.

Come on DICE, quit with these download titles and give us some real substance.

I am correct in saying that BF:BC2 is on the PC? If it is then finaly an new BF game that returns to the platform that made the BF series great. (And a platform I own)
2 years ago
Walk away haters, this is THE S*** !!! For the price, the number of hours worth of gameplay make 80% of games on the shelf cry
2 years ago
Slipvayne21 wrote
Walk away haters, this is THE S*** !!! For the price, the number of hours worth of gameplay make 80% of games on the shelf cry
Agreed!
2 years ago
Windburn wrote
Great review, but I'm really surprised Kimberley that you didn't catch on to the latter part of the title, 1943. It's purposely named as such as it's a almost identical in gameplay and presentation to the very first title in the serious, Battlefield 1942.

In fact, it pretty much IS Battlefield 1942 albeit with updated graphics. That game is also where they've derived the maps from (these are all extremely popular maps played by and familiar to millions of people around the world for years).

That feeling of nostalgia is half the reason I purchased it on PS3, and why I'm loving it so much icon_smile.gif
I did touch upon the nostalgia aspect of the game, but I purposely stayed away from making too much of deal over how 1943 is essentially a revamped edition of 1942.

I preferred to look at 1943 with a fresh set of eyes for fear of the review descending into a blow by blow comparison of the two games rather than pointing out what it is about 1943 that makes it so fun and accessible to gamers.
2 years ago
This game makes me want to play 1942 again. And I might do just that. Great game though, and I love the huge levels (awesome for sniping), and the use of colour.
2 years ago
I have to agree with Slipvayne. With another handful of levels this could have easily been released as a budget retail title. Although it only has 3 levels (until we get Coral Sea) it still feels like good value for money. The 6 or so hours I've played have been some of the most intense and fun gaming moments in recent memory. I love how it brings things back to basics. Everyone should buy this, give the trial a go at the very least.
2 years ago
No sniper prone = fail.
Same Bad Company sound mute bug = fail.
Horrible button response to on screen action delay = fail.
Red icons all over the screen to show you where the enemies are = fail.
The game controlling as clunky and limiting as a 5 year old game = fail.

Battlefield 2 still puts anything after it to shame and recent games like COD4 with all of it's polish and close to perfect controls and gameplay make this game look like a disgrace.

Sorry, but true BF fans would know all of this and games like this only serve a purpose as a pit stop to the real games that are due later.

Like Bad Company, this is a shoddy piece of work and anyone who has played polished experiences like Halo, Killzone, COD etc would see that.

As a 30+ year old gamer I'm embarrassed for gaming when something like this is praised.
2 years ago
for some reason all i can think about is how much i want to play 1942 so i can get in a submarine! REMEMBER THE SUBMARINE
2 years ago
Phreakuency wrote
No sniper prone = fail.
Same Bad Company sound mute bug = fail.
Horrible button response to on screen action delay = fail.
Red icons all over the screen to show you where the enemies are = fail.
The game controlling as clunky and limiting as a 5 year old game = fail.

Battlefield 2 still puts anything after it to shame and recent games like COD4 with all of it's polish and close to perfect controls and gameplay make this game look like a disgrace.

Sorry, but true BF fans would know all of this and games like this only serve a purpose as a pit stop to the real games that are due later.

Like Bad Company, this is a shoddy piece of work and anyone who has played polished experiences like Halo, Killzone, COD etc would see that.

As a 30+ year old gamer I'm embarrassed for gaming when something like this is praised.
I don't know what version you were playing (I doubt it's different on XBL compared to the PS3 version) but there were a few things you seem to have missed:

1) The Red Icons all over the screen ONLY appear when the enemy is being literally "targetted" by a friendly, ie. when they say "enemy x spotted", If they evade the friendly, the target will disappear from the radar. I think that's a terrific implementation, personally!

2) Button response - I don't know how you derived this at all? It's ultra sharp and responsive for me (even playing on overseas servers). I'm finding aiming to be far more satisfying than KZ2 (which was already quite good) and it allows you to be very precise. I can't find any flaw in responsiveness, so I was really quite surprised when you pointed this out.

Actually, the only thing I remotely agree with in the entire post is that I too was missing the sniper prone. I can see why it was done though-- it adds an interesting layer of strategy as snipers are quite easy to spot unless they hide in knee-high shrubs, and then they're hard to spot. I think that's a great balance move, beats getting picked off by snipers even lying in low grass and impossible to see.

I'd like to point out one other thing...


...this game sells for $20.

If you can buy "polished experiences like Halo, Killzone, COD" for that price, then please show me where! You cannot possibly expect the full feature set of BF2 in a budget release game, really only designed as a fanfare to tie everyone over until BFBC2.

And credit where credit due, it's a very affordable, very enjoyable PSN/XBL title icon_smile.gif
2 years ago
I played the demo and it just made me want a PC release. I finally got good with flying the planes with a mouse and they make me use some crappy analog sticks.
2 years ago
legend166 wrote
I played the demo and it just made me want a PC release. I finally got good with flying the planes with a mouse and they make me use some crappy analog sticks.
I beg to differ.

I wreckon the analog sticks are soooo much easier than a mouse.
2 years ago
Personally I preferred playing with a stick when flying planes/helicopters in BF2 as well. It made them much much easier to handle. Unfortunately my joystick was rubbish and eventually broke.

However, on foot I'd take keyboard and mouse anyday =P

Reading this review makes me want to boot up BF2 again, I wonder if the community's still going strong...
2 years ago
I think those who made the transition from the PC 1942 to Console 1943 will find it a little difficult. I found it a bit strange since I was so use to the PC 1942 with mouse control etc.

I did play Bad Company a lot so that made the transition a lot easier since I feel, 1943 is a lot like Bad Company in terms of mechanics and overall feel.

I still enjoy 1943 but just find it different since it's console only and feels more like a progression of Bad Company in terms of feel and mechanics of the game but with the skin of 1942.
2 years ago
InvivnI wrote
Reading this review makes me want to boot up BF2 again, I wonder if the community's still going strong...
According to a mate of mine that is often on it, yes.
Add Comment
Like this review?
Share it with this tiny url: http://palg.nu/3zy

N4G : News for Gamers         Twitter This!

Digg!     Stumble This!

| More
  Pre-order or buy:
    PALGN recommends: www.Play-Asia.com

Currently Popular on PALGN
Australian Gaming Bargains - 08/12/11
'Tis the season to be bargaining.
R18+ Legislation
R18+ Legislation
Naruto Shippuden: Ultimate Ninja Storm Generations Preview
Hands on time with the game. Chat time with the CEO of CyberConnect 2.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2007
24 titles to keep an eye on during 2007.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2008
And you thought 2007 was populated.