Home
Twitter
RSS
Newsletter
Adam Ghiggino
10 Jul, 2009

XBLA: Magic: The Gathering: Duels of the Planeswalkers Review

360 Review | Ho, ho, ho, it's magic, you know. Never believe it's not so.
Magic: The Gathering is the original modern card-collecting game, and with over six million players fighting each other with their decks of cards for over twenty years, it's got a lot of staying power. We have to admit that we previously never had the chance to try out the endearing card game, but luckily Magic: The Gathering: Duels of the Planeswalkers appeared to set us straight. The XBLA game is intended to be more accessible to new players, representing a much more 'arcadey' version of the card game. So, will Duels of the Planeswalkers float your boat if you're a hardcore player, or is it best left to the newbies?

The game follows the same rules as Magic: The Gathering, as you'd expect. You take on the role of a 'Planeswalker', some kind of wizard, and you have to duel with another Planeswalker through the use of summoning cards. That solves the mystery of the title, then. The main single-player campaign has sixteen AI-controlled opponents for you to go up against. There are five kinds of coloured decks, each of which seem geared towards different playing-styles. For instance, cards from a red deck will be advantageous for attacking as often and early as possible, while cards from the blue deck are all about control and countering your opponent's spells.

Each player has twenty points of life, and the object of each match is to attack your opponent until their life reaches zero. Each match usually begins with each player laying down some mana or 'land cards'. You can play one of these every turn, and the amount (and the colour) of the mana you have determines what cards you can play. Players take turns to summon creatures, deal damage, 'enchant' their creatures for greater strength, or play other spells to heal themselves or such. It's a very deep system, and when playing through the single-player campaign, it's often as useful to memorise and know exactly what cards your opponent has in his deck, as it is to know what's in yours, so that you're prepared for every move they make.

Oh wow, it's like the most spectacular battle I've ever seen!

Oh wow, it's like the most spectacular battle I've ever seen!
Close
Duels of the Planeswalkers tries to get new players off to a good start with a tutorial mode, which takes you through a sample battle. To be honest, we found the tutorial to not be that helpful, and we learnt more from actually playing the game and just seeing what different cards did for ourselves, and before long we got into the swing of the game very nicely. The game adds a separate timer to every stage of the battle to try and speed things along, which means you can't dilly-dally too much when deciding which card to play or which cards to block or attack with. It's an interesting addition, although it feels very stop-start at times, and sometimes slows things down more than it's meant to. We wish there was some way to skip the opponent's turn altogether in the single-player mode. Once you're into the game and can make decisions more quickly, it is annoying waiting for your timers to do their thing, and even moreso waiting for your opponent's.

There are some other niggles for the newcomer as well. Often, you'll mess up by stupidly continuing when you should have played a card, and want to restart a match, but there is no option to, except to exit the game, and re-enter the match, facing two loading screens. It's a small problem, but an annoying one. For longtime Magic fans, there are some other problems which might put them off this release. For one, there is no deck construction, with the game instead forcing you to choose from a selection of pre-constructed decks. By playing through the game, you can unlock more decks as well as special cards you can insert into your decks to make them more powerful, but experienced players may be left wanting a little more control over their cards.

My God this is epic! This is, like, ten times more epic than the final battle of Lord of the Rings!

My God this is epic! This is, like, ten times more epic than the final battle of Lord of the Rings!
Close
However, the game does offer several modes of gameplay. Alongside the single-player campaign, there's a 'Challenge' mode which poses a Magic situation to you and asks you to solve it in one turn. There is also the option to play (offline) co-operatively with a friend against the computer, and finally there's the multiplayer mode over Xbox Live, which is where you'll be spending a lot of your time if you're a Magic fan. It's worth ploughing through the single-player mode before you tackle online, as you'll have a better range of decks to select from, but the fact that the people you're going up against are most likely using the same range of cards that you have access to makes it seem a little more balanced.

There's not a lot to say about the presentation of Duels of the Planeswalkers. The graphics do the job, giving you a variety of themed tables to look at, and the cards are represented in quite a high quality fashion, and can be zoomed in to see further details. The special effects which represent attacks and blocks are fairly standard, with only a few animations. The music is well-orchestrated although a little generic. Overall, it's a clean, if unspectacular, looking game.

Magic: The Gathering: Duels of the Planeswalkers is quite obviously a cut-down version of the real game. While experienced players will miss basic features like being able to construct their own decks, and new players may feel a little lost when they start, the core gameplay of the card game translates well enough to make the game very fun and extremely addictive. If you're looking for a cheaper way to play Magic: The Gathering, or just a fun arcade-styled card game, Duels of the Planeswalkers fits the bill nicely.
The Score
Although there are some niggles for both newcomers and pros, Magic: The Gathering is a great card game that translates well into a fun video game.
Looking to buy this game right now? PALGN recommends www.Play-Asia.com.

Related XBLA: Magic: The Gathering: Duels of the Planeswalkers Content

Xbox Live Deal of the Week - 11/01/10
12 Jan, 2010 Gather around the Marketplace for some magical fun.
Magic: The Gathering coming to XBLA
19 Feb, 2008 Will also be coming for the PC.
Meteos: Disney Magic Review
03 Jul, 2007 Magic is in the eye of the beholder.
5 Comments
2 years ago
YAY!!!!!!!!! This is best news since...well....EVER!

Am a huge MTG fan. Will definitely be downloading this icon_smile.gif
2 years ago
It is a good game i just wish they never gimped it so much icon_sad.gif
2 years ago
@Adam

a friend of mine, who is a Magic fan. It took him a while to realize that you were being sarcastic in those captions. icon_lol.gif
2 years ago
I enjoyed this game.

Even better, the starting green deck is actually very similar to one of the Odyssey's pre-constructored deck because I was familiar with most of the cards there, which happened to be my starting deck (got it for free because my best friend didn't get Magic) when I first time played Magic.

So many of the cards are quite old in a sense and because of it, I do feel quite at home since I had a rest from Magic since the Timespiral era even when I started with Ravinca, which was my initial fear or just seeing cards post-Timespiral, but I guess that really didn't happen, phew.

I agree with Itachi, its too gimpy. Its so annoying having to wait for the stack to clear with its sparkly tornado graphics and its ringing sound, I just wanna cry "hurry up!!!". But I guess its understandable that its time so that people have enough time to pause the game to put a counter-spell or add cards to the stack but you really don't need the amount of time they give to press the blue button!!!

Apparently it meant to be a gimp version of the older Magic game nicknamed Shandalar but the official title I think was Magic:The Gathering (its a very old game). Its available at Abandonware sites and there is a fan community who worked so hard to make it multiplayer as well.
2 years ago
I said to Fetidchimp a while back if they didnt gimp this had heaps of cards and been able to FULLY edit your deck it would of been the best game imo. I can think of reasons why they didn't thoe with magic online and the real card game..... icon_sad.gif sigh
Add Comment
Like this review?
Share it with this tiny url: http://palg.nu/3zh

N4G : News for Gamers         Twitter This!

Digg!     Stumble This!

| More
  Pre-order or buy:
    PALGN recommends: www.Play-Asia.com

Year Made:
  2009

Read more...
Currently Popular on PALGN
Australian Gaming Bargains - 08/12/11
'Tis the season to be bargaining.
R18+ Legislation
R18+ Legislation
Naruto Shippuden: Ultimate Ninja Storm Generations Preview
Hands on time with the game. Chat time with the CEO of CyberConnect 2.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2007
24 titles to keep an eye on during 2007.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2008
And you thought 2007 was populated.