Home
Twitter
RSS
Newsletter
Brendan
26 Sep, 2008

NHL 09 Review

360 Review | EA scores.
Ice hockey, then. Not the most popular sport in PAL regions, especially not in Australia - which is hardly surprising, given the almost complete lack of snow and ice in the country. Regardless, more than a few people enjoy the games, which are usually of a very high quality. This has been especially the case in recent years, with the battle for ice hockey gaming supremacy being hotly contested between EA's games and Visual Concepts' 2K series. With NHL 09, EA is taking a more realistic, simulation-based approach, with features such as the new Be A Pro and EA Sports Hockey League modes. By contrast, NHL 2K9 moves the series towards a more arcade-based game than it has been in recent years, bringing ice hockey to the Wii for the first time. That was probably a good move on Visual Concepts’ behalf, because NHL 09 plays a brilliant game of hockey.

Cutting straight to the chase, the new Be A Pro mode is one of NHL 09’s big selling points. While past hockey games have allowed individual players to control an entire team, switching players when required, the Be A Pro mode puts players in the skates of just one player for an entire match. It’s not an entirely new concept, having been tried in various other sports games over the years, but it has never quite clicked, usually due to having to players spend too much time watching while the play comes to them. It’s a different story in NHL 09. Given that there are only six players on the ice at any one time – including the goalie – the puck is never too far away, allowing players to always feel like they are part of the action. Players can also call for the puck with a press of the button, and CPU teammates are always willing to oblige, no matter how ridiculous the pass may be.

You put your left stick in, you put your left stick out.

You put your left stick in, you put your left stick out.
Close
It doesn’t just stop with controlling the one person on the ice, either – players can take full control over their virtual alter ego’s career. Players can customize the appearance of their character before starting in a minor league. From there, they have to work their way up to the NHL. This is done by achieving milestones the coach sets for the player, such as scoring a certain number of goals, having a high enough save percentage, and so on. After each game, players receive grades on their performance, as well experience points, which can be used to boost attributes in a variety of areas. It’s not massively in-depth – there are no contract negotiations and no way to initiate contact with the coach or general manager, for instance – but it does provide a nice little twist on the typical sports game, and can become incredibly addictive very, very quickly. It is also rather slow paced. A good game will result in roughly 20 experience points in each of the three categories - offense, defense and athletics. Upgrading a single attribute by one point out of 99 can take over 200 experience points - that adds up to 10 games for one attribute point boost. Don't expect to have a 99 overall character overnight - unless you choose the option of taking over an existing NHL players career. But really, where's the fun in that?

However, the individual position play comes into its own online. Up to 12 players can battle it out online with a quick team play match, with five skaters and one goalie per team. Much more interestingly, players can also take their offline Be A Pro character online (though experience earnt online and offline are separate, so the character only looks the same), where they can join a club of other players from around the world, or make their own, and battle it out in the EA Sports Hockey League. Clubs can have many members and really brings a team atmosphere to the game – a built in clan system, if you will, that really pushes the team aspect of the game. In order to be successful, teamwork is crucial. The problem of puck hogs is greatly reduced by the grading system – if players are out of position too long, their positioning grade will suffer, and they will lose out on experience points. However, the biggest problem with the online system is connection issues. Expect to experience an unusually high disconnection rate, which will make some players incredibly unhappy as it reflects in the player’s statistics.

Get over here!

Get over here!
Close
Single player Be A Pro isn't without its flaws either, being somewhat buggy. When the human character needs to hit the bench to rest (never for too long though – only fifteen seconds are needed to recover all stamina), pressing the X button to force a line change doesn’t always work. Instead, the player can lose control of their character and the CPU will take over, draining stamina further and affecting stats. The player is forced to watch until the next break in play in order to regain control of their character, which is incredibly annoying. Making things worse, sometimes when a character is on the bench, the line change button doesn’t work, so again the player is forced to watch the CPU have all the fun out on the ice. Don't even think about a line change immediately after coming out of the penalty box either, as the player will just skate around aimlessly in the middle of the rink. It doesn’t happen often enough to be game destroying, but it is still rather frustrating. Of course, this problem can be circumvented by removing line changes – it takes away from the realism, but it is infinitely less frustrating.

Outside of the two big new modes, the menus are rather similar to last year. Dynasty is back and is addictive as ever. Versus play is still excellent online, though it also suffers from connection issues. The controls haven’t changed much from last year, either – a good thing, since they still work so well. The right analog stick reflects the movement of the player’s stick on screen, which, when combined with the left stick, allows for accurate shots, smooth dekes and swift puck movement. When the player doesn’t have the puck, it allows the player to check in any direction, or, when combined with the left bumper, lets the player to use their stick for poke checks. The most significant new control feature is the stick lift, which can be used to rob players attempting to shoot up close – incredibly satisfying for defenders trying to stop that sure-fire shot. Hitting is also somewhat more realistic, with hits only likely to knock over the opposition if they are suitably ‘charged’ – that is, the player doing the hitting must be moving at high speed.

The crowd is rather excited to see the game's cover boy, Dion Phaneuf.

The crowd is rather excited to see the game's cover boy, Dion Phaneuf.
Close
Close up, the game looks quite attractive, with well animated players who look just like their real life counterparts. Clipping is also very good, relative to other sports games. Zooming the camera out to a practical level brings things down a notch though, resulting in the waste of a lot of the detail. The close up camera angle does tend to have massive frame rate drops when all 12 skaters are on screen – though this is usually only when the puck is behind the net at the bottom of the screen. Cut scenes also suffer from low frame rates, but it could be argued that this is intentional as they never seem to dip or rise significantly.

It’s difficult to fault NHL 09. From a technical standpoint, it’s fantastic – controls are smooth and easy to come to grips with after a few hours play, it looks great and the commentary is actually quite good. Feature wise, the game is also jam-packed – Be A Pro is incredibly addictive offline, and the EA Hockey Sports League will have plays battling it out online until NHL 10 inevitably surfaces in roughly twelve months time. The game could have used another coat of polish, with some bugs and slow down occasionally causing frustration. Aside from that, NHL 09 is a fantastic and completely engaging game that every puck fan will enjoy.
The Score
NHL 09 is an outstanding hockey game. EA has delivered two truly new features to the genre, in the form of the EA Sports Hockey League and the Be A Pro mode, which have well and truly moved the goal posts. Or net, in this instance. Grab your controller and become a hockey legend today.
Looking to buy this game right now? PALGN recommends www.Play-Asia.com.

Related NHL 09 Content

NHL 09 shots
09 Jul, 2008 Hockeying around.
NHL 2K8 Review
15 Nov, 2007 There are no Lindros style concussions here.
NHL 2K8 Preview
23 Sep, 2007 Looking like an improvement?
7 Comments
4 years ago
Sounds awesome. I hope the Wii version translates well. I cant imagine how the motion controls will bode for it though..
4 years ago
I'll be snapping this one up, I love Ice Hockey, its so much more fast paced than other sports and a lot more brutal. The idea of "Be A Pro" also has me very excited.
4 years ago
Again no Devils screens... when will EA learn... no one cares about Calgary...

Definitely picking this up; probably have to be the PC version for me, as much as I prefer using a controller to a keyboard. Somewhat hyped for it in fact, having read this review.
4 years ago
S.Jaworski wrote
Sounds awesome. I hope the Wii version translates well.
There is no Wii version - just 360, PS3 and PC. 2K9, however, will be on the Wii.

Gtpod wrote
Again no Devils screens... when will EA learn... no one cares about Calgary...
And even less people care about New Jersey. icon_razz.gif
4 years ago
I've gone for NHL 2K9 this year on the strength of reading comments by some hockey nuts who think its actually the more accurate simulation. I played EA's game solidly last year and enjoyed it but it always seemed a little too perfect, passes would always go to your team mates no matter how difficult, the puck never really skidded and bounced and the presentation was a little lacking for me. Still, if I get bored of 2K9 I'll definitely give this a try.

PS. Had to import 2K9 though, its not getting an Australian release, sales figures must have been quite bad last year over here.
4 years ago
Picked it up at JB-HIFI for $80 on 360. Having fun so far. I suck at shooting for goal, though. icon_sad.gif
4 years ago
Brendan wrote
And even less people care about New Jersey..
I'd love to see you eat those words if the Devs picked him up next season!
Add Comment
Like this review?
Share it with this tiny url: http://palg.nu/Jk

N4G : News for Gamers         Twitter This!

Digg!     Stumble This!

| More
  Pre-order or buy:
    PALGN recommends: www.Play-Asia.com

Australian Release Date:
  25/9/2008 (Confirmed)
Publisher:
  Electronic Arts
Genre:
  Sports
Year Made:
  2008

Read more...
Related Media
 
Currently Popular on PALGN
Australian Gaming Bargains - 08/12/11
'Tis the season to be bargaining.
R18+ Legislation
R18+ Legislation
Naruto Shippuden: Ultimate Ninja Storm Generations Preview
Hands on time with the game. Chat time with the CEO of CyberConnect 2.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2007
24 titles to keep an eye on during 2007.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2008
And you thought 2007 was populated.