Home
Twitter
RSS
Newsletter
Chris Leigh
04 Jul, 2006

LocoRoco accused of racism

PSP News | "Institutionally racist," says blogger.
Is apparently innocent PSP puzzler LocoRoco racist? Well, if you're 1UP blogger Alejandro Quan-Madrid, then yes.

In one of the recent posts over at his 1UP blog, the elaborately named Quan-Madrid contends that the Sony-developed blob-'em-up features racist characters, in the shape of the dark Moja enemies that appear in the game. According to Quan-Madrid, the Moja are just a little too close for comfort to the "blackface" image that was peddled by performers and dancers from the early 20th Century. The same look was revived in the BBC's Black and White Minstrel Show, a TV programme that appeared in both the UK and Australia until 1978, when it was scrapped following accusations of racist overtones.

"Today in virtually any public sphere in the US, a depiction of a blackface character is not met without much murmurings and harsh criticism," wrote Quan-Madrid. "In comparison, some countries such as Japan (where LocoRoco was developed) do not have significant black populations and so blackface images can come about without any criticism. The images are also then okay to be labelled as the enemy or even serve as representations of black characters in general, despite the racist images they perpetuate. That and I hear that Japanese people (in Japan) at times can be pretty innocently racist."

Quan-Madrid isn't suggesting that LocoRoco is consciously racist then, and he goes on to assure us that he's "not accusing the developers of being racist, nor of LocoRoco being a racist game. I simply believe that this is a product of unchecked institutionalised racism that needs calling out. I do feel these racist undertones, whether intentional or not, would stop me as well as others from fully enjoying this game".

Sony was happy to counter Quan-Madrid's arguments however, stating that, "LocoRoco is a fantasy game geared towards a worldwide audience that takes place in a vibrant pastel world with colorful landscapes and characters and is not based on real-life places, people or things." It's not the first time this year that a game has come in for accusations of racism, either - in February, Activision apologised after a Native Americans rights group accused the company's GUN of containing 'derogatory, harmful and inaccurate' depictions of Native Americans.

Racist representations or innocent blobs?

Related LocoRoco Content

LocoRoco Christmas demo released
12 Dec, 2006 Christmas is coming.
LocoRoco Christmas freebie
25 Nov, 2006 Free Xmas stage from kindly Uncle Sony.
LocoRoco Review
10 Jun, 2006 It's Loco, but is it any good?
23 Comments
5 years ago
"Institutionally retarded"

This comes from the australian website 'PALGN''s poster 'jibbs', who goes on further to state that 'this guy(1ups blogger) is, unintentionally or not, a retard, and has suceeded in drawing interest and traffic to his own website by using the hottest of all hot buttons, racism, and a well known, recently released game.Just add water.'


He(jibbs) went on to add further that 'Never mind the fact that they(the moja chracters depicted in loco-roco) don't have arms or legs, and the only thing that they have in common with humans is a face, it seems to me the only ones offended by this are people who are looking TO be offended.I'd bet my house this blogger, for example, isn't black himself, african american, aboriginal or otherwise.'

Controversial stuff.Will jibbs be labelled a racist as his has been in the past by those misinformed or will they finally be able to step out of their monochrome world and see the light.Stay tuned for this sure to be fiery debate!
5 years ago
^ LoL! icon_lol.gif icon_lol.gif I was thinking of something to say along these lines....but wouldnt've achieved the same amount of wit or humour.
5 years ago
Japanese people wouldn't even be aware that "Blackface" is possibly racist, they still have singers and comedians that dress up like that. Japan is still a pretty "racist" place to be, though not a bit as bad at 20 years ago.
5 years ago
they look like black pineapples imo.

we need more black pineapples in games.
5 years ago
Jibbs wrote
'this guy (1-up blogger) is, unintentionally or not, a retard and has suceeded in drawing interest and traffic to his own website by using the hottest of all hot buttons, racism and a well known, recently released game.
So this is what I'm forgeting to add to my blog posts.
5 years ago
That is absolutely ridiculous.
He himself must be ultra racism aware if he came to that conclusion...because I would have never seen them as racial stereotypes,just game characters.
I can't stand people who just look for stuff to pick at and whinge so they get a bit of notoriety.
5 years ago
There is definetly something wrong with that guy... Since when do people look like a ball of... Ummm. Jelly?

The thing is, we use black and white as the basis for many things, for example: Good and Evil, chocolate flavours/textures (brown/dark brown chocolate as well as white chocolate) and various other things. Unless LocoRoco went out and said something racist like "all <insert colour here> people are tools," I wouldn't consider anything wrong with it.

Personally, I think the game has a cute look and feel to it.
5 years ago
The phrase "reading too much into something" springs to mind and I'm sure you can find exactly what you want to find if you look hard enough.

I'm pretty much of the opinion that every game could be viewed as any one of the following...

Racist
Ageist
Anti-Feminist
Anti-Religion
Promoting violence
Social stereotyping
Cultural stereotyping
Promoting Addiction
Promoting Laziness
Promoting Ignorance
Promoting Temptation
Promoting Greed
Promoting bad language
Promoting sex
Promoting Smoking
[Insert prejudice and or vice here]

For emample: Tetris promotes temptation, bad language, greed, violence and the original version also had a form of cultural stereotyping.
5 years ago
What about the yellow LocoRoco blobs isnt that racist towards_____ NO!!!!!!! the answer is no.
5 years ago
I recall the Zelda series being slanted as Feminist when an ad capaign for OoT was doing the rounds on TV. Nintendo ended up taking the ad off TV anyway (due to a sell out of the game and no new stock avaliable for a brief period).
5 years ago
Dark Shadow wrote
I recall the Zelda series being slanted as Feminist when an ad capaign for OoT was doing the rounds on TV. Nintendo ended up taking the ad off TV anyway (due to a sell out of the game and no new stock avaliable for a brief period).
Is that the "will you rescue the girl... or play like one?" thing? If so, then thats not feminism, thats sexism. Feminism would pretty much be the opposite.
5 years ago
^ No way is that real. icon_lol.gif
5 years ago
Ocarina of Time was pretty racist towards Ganondorf. He was a "sand n*****" and just happened to be evil? RACIST! There were also undertones of polygamy, what with a garudo man being born every 100 years...
5 years ago
ObsoletE wrote
they look like black pineapples imo.

we need more black pineapples in games.
This guy could seriously stick a black pineapple up his "you know what"!!

That poster would of created soooo much controversy if it is real :S

But seriously, come on as sonicwired has stated if you do analyse anything too deeply you could find something racist, etc in anything! These are the kind of people I would like to keep further away from the gaming scene. It's a game for christs sake, they are ment to be for enjoyment and fun, not to be take literally!
5 years ago
This is the exact same reasons that a Jynx-centric Pokemon episode was banned.

Meh.
5 years ago
^ They are for enjoyment and fun, but are an artistic medium in themselves. We should never say videogames are exempt from criticism because they are "just a game".

Lots of colurs have meaning. Red can stand for passion, or evil. Yellow for fear. Green for envy. Black has the distinction of being the absence of all light, and there is no more primal fear than being scared of the dark.

Many innocent books written in an unenlightened time (Brer Rabbit and some of the Noddy Stories featuring Golywogs) have been removed from general circulation. Is it political correctness gone mad or a necessary step to quell cultural racism?

Children dont learn racism from books or games though... they learn it from us. Loco Roco may be 'just a game' so let us be reminded that there is no reason to be scared of the dark.
5 years ago
döppelganger wrote
Children dont learn racism from books or games though... they learn it from us.
I strongly disagree with that, to be honest. I firmly believe that books, television and other media forms all play a role in the socialisation of a child, just as parenting, education, religion, laws and other social institutions contribute to a child's outlook on life.
5 years ago
döppelganger wrote
^ They are for enjoyment and fun, but are an artistic medium in themselves. We should never say videogames are exempt from criticism because they are "just a game".

Lots of colurs have meaning. Red can stand for passion, or evil. Yellow for fear. Green for envy. Black has the distinction of being the absence of all light, and there is no more primal fear than being scared of the dark.

Many innocent books written in an unenlightened time (Brer Rabbit and some of the Noddy Stories featuring Golywogs) have been removed from general circulation. Is it political correctness gone mad or a necessary step to quell cultural racism?
That's an awesome point!

I heard on the radio this morning about Enid Blyton books being changed because of political correctness. Stuff like Dick and Fanny from the Famous Five being changed to Rick and Frannie. And from the Faraway Tree series there is a black character with a name normally associated with slavery called "Bessie" that is being changed to a white girl named Beth.

I mean seriously I had no idea of any of these things.....and I read Enid Blyton (alot) when I was younger. It's a dumb idea digging up this old crap! I mean I had no idea Bessie was an old black Slave name.....but I do now!
5 years ago
GTPod wrote
^ No way is that real. icon_lol.gif
It is real. It's currently touring a few European countries at the moment.

It isn't the first time Sony has had such ads:

5 years ago
they're good ads too, regardless of your stance on the content, they do EXACTLY what they're supposed to, get a product in as wide a circulation as possible. the company hired by Sony are using controversy to achieve that.

it's a bit like that Dutch Brewery giving out those pants that were confiscated at the World Cup recently. if they let them wear them, minimum exposure, because they were told to take off their pants, every newspaper in the world picked it up and the brewery gets global exposure.
5 years ago
That Sony PSP ad IS real...
5 years ago
DancesInUnderwear wrote
Dark Shadow wrote
I recall the Zelda series being slanted as Feminist when an ad capaign for OoT was doing the rounds on TV. Nintendo ended up taking the ad off TV anyway (due to a sell out of the game and no new stock avaliable for a brief period).
Is that the "will you rescue the girl... or play like one?" thing? If so, then thats not feminism, thats sexism. Feminism would pretty much be the opposite.
Yes it was that. My mistake, sexism.
Add Comment
Like this news?
Share it with this tiny url: http://palg.nu/c7

N4G : News for Gamers         Twitter This!

Digg!     Stumble This!

| More
  Pre-order or buy:
    PALGN recommends: www.Play-Asia.com

Australian Release Date:
  Out Now
European Release Date:
  Out Now
Publisher:
  Sony Computer Entertainment Inc.
Developer:
  Sony Computer Entertainment Japan

Read more...
Currently Popular on PALGN
Australian Gaming Bargains - 08/12/11
'Tis the season to be bargaining.
R18+ Legislation
R18+ Legislation
Naruto Shippuden: Ultimate Ninja Storm Generations Preview
Hands on time with the game. Chat time with the CEO of CyberConnect 2.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2007
24 titles to keep an eye on during 2007.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2008
And you thought 2007 was populated.