Home
Twitter
RSS
Newsletter
Adam Ghiggino
22 Sep, 2010

Kingdom Hearts: Birth by Sleep Review

PSP Review | Conceived immaculately.
So, we all know by now that Kingdom Hearts is an experiment that should never have worked. We mean, come on. Mickey Mouse fighting alongside Squall Leonheart? Donald Duck and Goofy participating in an Action RPG as party members? Suspiciously homosexual overtones between members of an almost entirely male organisation in a game with Disney branding? But, work it did. And sell it did. And here we are, with a series of games by Square-Enix that is immensely successful, and a fanbase that is equally interested in the formative years of King Mickey, as it is interested in cosplaying as weird characters with enough gel in their hair to almost ensure premature baldness. You could say the series is on something of a hiatus right now, as the team toils endlessly away on Final Fantasy spin-off Final Fantasy Versus XIII, but two portable games have been released to keep the fans satisfied. Birth By Sleep is the second game to be released, a prequel on PSP. Is it extraneous filler, or a genuine addition to the franchise?

As an extremely story-driven game, it's perhaps best to start with the story. Well, what we can make out of it anyway. The story of Kingdom Hearts has always been a little vague and convoluted, given the hefty task of reconciling several completely different universes. As a prequel, Birth By Sleep had the perfect opportunity to explain and simplify some of the more complex plot points which have arisen in the series. It doesn't. If anything, it's made things even more convoluted.

The game takes place many years before the original Kingdom Hearts and shifts the focus of the series onto three protagonists, Terra, Ventus and Aqua. All three are training to become Keyblade Masters under the wise Master Eraquus. However, as soon as the obviously-villanous Master Xehanort arrives to observe their exam, the mysterious monsters known as the Unversed begin to manifest on several worlds. All three characters leave to combat this threat, and to uncover Xehanort's plans. It's all very Star Wars, and a lot of geeky information that would have been helpful to know, such as what exactly a Keyblade Master is, how many there are, or even what the Keyblade War that everyone talks about entailed, is left out so that even more tenuous 'links' between characters can be provided, as they are born, re-incarnated, split apart, re-join, and have their hearts toyed with more than an episode of The Hills. Furthermore, the characters are mostly bland. Terra is so naive it's painful, Aqua won't stop giving idealistic speeches, and Ventus is just a Roxas clone, but without his personality. Nevertheless, fans will get a kick out of seeing several familiar faces, including a host of characters fated to end up in the antagonistic Organisation XIII. For gamers looking to get into this series with Birth By Sleep, prepare to be very confused.

If they start eating ice cream, I'm out of here.

If they start eating ice cream, I'm out of here.
Close
However, Birth By Sleep benefits immensely by the way it has been treated by its developers. Rather than simplifying the gameplay for a portable console, the game has a full-fledged battle system that actually improves upon the systems seen in past games. Birth By Sleep allows you to collect spells, attacks, commands which you find in the world (and multiples of them) and use them to form your own command 'deck'. This deck is built in the menu, and accessible in battles from the on-screen menu. You always have a default attack command, but you can customise your display to have any other commands you own. These commands also 'level up' as you battle, and once they are at their maximum level, you can 'meld' two commands at a time (along with an extra ingredient for passive benefits), for instance combining 'Fire' and 'Fire' to create 'Fira'.

On top of this, a mini-game called the 'Command Board', can also be accessed to gain new commands and level up your current ones. In a derivation of Monopoly, three players play on a board game (two are AI controlled) and complete circuits to collect points and buy tiles. If you land on another player's tile, you have to pay a toll. There are several themed boards, each with their own unique paths and power-ups which keep things interesting, and while we were dreading having to play a board game to level up (not that you have to, as it's entirely optional), we found ourselves enjoying it quite a bit by the end. But, there's even more to combat - your character has 'limit breaks' of a sort that depend on combos you string and what commands you use, and allow you to unleash elemental or physical based special attacks over a short time frame. Finally, you forge 'D-Links' throughout the game that, despite their name, do not help you route your internet, but allow you to emulate the command decks of other characters (as well as receive a health boost).

Combat is fast and fluid - in fact - much more fluid than past games in the series. The analogue nub and face buttons are much better than the DS controls utilised for 358/2 days and you'll rarely find yourself frustrated with the gameplay. That said, on those occasions when you do, it'll be due to the wonky camera and somewhat fidgety lock-on controls. It's fine locking onto something, but completely unlocking or switching targets can sometimes be a hassle, and cost you valuable time in some of the more heated battles.

Ha ha! Your souls shall be mine! Ha ha!

Ha ha! Your souls shall be mine! Ha ha!
Close
You're given the choice of playing through the game as either Terra, Ventus or Aqua, who each have their own strengths and weaknesses - for instance, Terra is powerful but slow, while Ventus is young and speedy, etc. You'll need to complete the game with all three characters to unlock the final story (and the secret ending, if you're playing on a higher difficulty). This does mean that there is a fair bit of re-treading across worlds, but thankfully Square Enix have added enough variety to each story so that it feels as though you are exploring different areas, completing different tasks and experiencing different portions of each world's story as you play through with each character. Expect to see new worlds drawn from Cinderella, Sleeping Beauty and Snow White and the Seven Dwarves, as well as returning worlds from films like Hercules and Peter Pan.

Another component of the game is mulitplayer, which has been introduced, called the Mirage Arena. It allows players to play in standard one-on-one matches, or more interestingly, fight against waves of Unversed, as well as play on the Command Board. It's not a vital component of the Birth By Sleep experience, and performance issues do arise when playing it, but it's there and quite fun.

Where's a pumpkin carriage when you need it?

Where's a pumpkin carriage when you need it?
Close
Graphically, Birth By Sleep rivals its PlayStation 2 predecessors, and is quite a showcase for the PSP. Animations are smooth, and highly detailed character models are well-animated in certain cut-scenes. The music for the game is outstanding, and has some memorable tracks and capable voice actors, with special mention going to Mark Hamill as Eraquus and Leonard Nimoy as Xehanort, in his last performance before his retirement.

Kingdom Hearts: Birth By Sleep may seem to be the logical choice for newcomers to the series, as it is chronologically the first game in the series' timeline. It may even set their expectations for the rest of the franchise too high. The gameplay and depth of Birth By Sleep are leaps and bounds ahead what could have been expected of a PSP incarnation of the series, and it shines as a true instalment of the series, rather than a half-baked interquel or spin-off. It may even be the best playing Kingdom Hearts game so far. Confusing storyline and bland characterisation aside, this is a very fun and fluid action role playing game to play on your PSP, and if that sounds like it's your bag, then by all means check it out.
The Score
The story of Kingdom Hearts gets more and more complicated, but the gameplay gets better and better. Birth By Sleep plays extremely well for a PSP game, and has plenty of fun, depth and variety.
Looking to buy this game right now? PALGN recommends www.Play-Asia.com.

Related Kingdom Hearts: Birth by Sleep Content

Kingdom Hearts: Birth By Sleep Special Edition Announced
03 Aug, 2010 Some extra pretties for PAL regions.
New Kingdom Hearts: Birth By Sleep screens
09 Jun, 2010 Peter Pan and Snow White join the mix.
Kingdom Hearts Birth By Sleep announced for Australia
18 May, 2010 The Keyblade is back in town.
14 Comments
3 years ago
While I liked this review, some points were just dumb.
"Suspiciously homosexual overtones between members of an almost entirely male organisation" Wow, that's just perverted. I wonder if Adam has a male friend. Is he homophobic?

"information that would have been helpful to know, such as what exactly a Keyblade Master is, how many there are, or even what the Keyblade War that everyone talks about entailed" The Master is more than obvious. Just a title like Colonel. Even at some point, the characters state that they are only Keyblade wielders left, considering a lot died in war. The Keyblade War is told in the three story modes, but I won't spoil what was it.
3 years ago
I think that one of the good things about the KH games is that the battle system has improved a lot over time. The first game was very basic, the second one added quick commands and transformations, and now this game has shown off a way to completely customise your character's moves - which is a great idea and much better executed here than in 385/2 Days. Story wise, we got some answers, but also a few new questions which will surely be answered.
3 years ago
PALGN wrote
Suspiciously homosexual overtones between members of an almost entirely male organisation in a game with Disney branding?
I lol'ed.

The story in kingdom hearts 2 took it self way to seriously it was goofy! So I can imagane this one being just as silly. I'll be passing on this but nice review. Definitely one for a few laughs!
3 years ago
sainta wrote
While I liked this review, some points were just dumb.
"Suspiciously homosexual overtones between members of an almost entirely male organisation" Wow, that's just perverted. I wonder if Adam has a male friend. Is he homophobic?
Just pointing out the obvious. There's nothing wrong with it. In fact, Sora better end up with Riku by the time this series is over.
3 years ago
Quote
As a prequel, Birth By Sleep had the perfect opportunity to explain and simplify some of the more complex plot points which have arisen in the series. It doesn't. If anything, it's made things even more convoluted.
Bummer... I've only nearly finishing KH1 (until my PS2 decided to corrupt the save and my memory card was an official one). Didn't want to play further even though I own KH2 until I finish 1.

O well, I'll buy the special edition anyway, bring the PS2 out of the box and start doing catchups!!!


Release KH1 and KH2 on PSP!!! (majority of my gaming is portable).
3 years ago
sainta wrote
"Suspiciously homosexual overtones between members of an almost entirely male organisation" Wow, that's just perverted. I wonder if Adam has a male friend. Is he homophobic?
Gotta agree with Adam on this one. The subtext has always been there, even from the first game, probably has something to do with the number of fangirls KH has.
Anyways, pointing out an objective fact does not make you homophobic, that kind of attitude is political correctness gone crazy.
3 years ago
having such a storyline heavy series spread out over 4 consoles just seems mean to me.
3 years ago
I like the series but certainly not enough to buy a psp.
3 years ago
Benza wrote
having such a storyline heavy series spread out over 4 consoles just seems mean to me.
seconded, I'm trying to justify buying a PSP just so I can keep up on the wonderfully intricate (NOT convoluted) story XD
3 years ago
"Anyways, pointing out an objective fact does not make you homophobic, that kind of attitude is political correctness gone crazy." If we consider there is a romantical relationship between two male friends, we can even say that Donald and Goofy are a gay couple just because they are always together and Donald started crying when Goofy almost died. Or how about saying that there was a homosexual relationship between Zack and Cloud in Crisis Core, or Vincent and Reeve in Dirge of Cerberus? If people keep pointing a possible romantical relationship between two male friends, then what is correct about Adam's statement?
3 years ago
^Or maybe it's just an observation that doesn't deserve as much analysis as you seem to want to give it? Why would it upset you so much if some of the characters were gay?

Seriously though, personal attacks over fictional characters are a little uncalled for, yes? I actually really enjoyed the Organisation's storyline, as well as Axel and Roxas' relationship in 358/2 Days.

Can't a throwaway observation just be a throwaway observation?

Edited: To make myself a little clearer.
3 years ago
"Why would it upset you so much if some of the characters were gay?" Was I ever upset? I just found that pointing any discussion between two people and see they have a thing, sounds like those anime fans who always look to create any fanfiction
3 years ago
^Shall we agree that neither of us is homophobic then, and kiss to seal the deal? icon_smile.gif
3 years ago
...I think it's better to know each other before that... LOL
Add Comment
Like this review?
Share it with this tiny url: http://palg.nu/4i2

N4G : News for Gamers         Twitter This!

Digg!     Stumble This!

| More
  Pre-order or buy:
    PALGN recommends: www.Play-Asia.com

Australian Release Date:
  9/9/2010 (Confirmed)
Publisher:
  UBI Soft
Genre:
  Action RPG
Year Made:
  2008
Players:
  1

Read more...
Currently Popular on PALGN
Australian Gaming Bargains - 08/12/11
'Tis the season to be bargaining.
R18+ Legislation
R18+ Legislation
Naruto Shippuden: Ultimate Ninja Storm Generations Preview
Hands on time with the game. Chat time with the CEO of CyberConnect 2.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2007
24 titles to keep an eye on during 2007.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2008
And you thought 2007 was populated.