Home
Twitter
RSS
Newsletter
Chris Leigh
11 May, 2006

E3 2006: Ubisoft director lays into PS3

PS3 News | Fight! Fight! Fight!
It's been a while since we had a good old-fashioned console wars story, so thank heavens for Clint Hocking. For those not in the know, Hocking is the creative director of Ubisoft Montreal and the man behind titles such as Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory. He also recently hosted an E3 workshop focusing on next-generation game design in which he attacked Sony and the PlayStation 3.

The source of Clint's ire? Yep, you guessed it - the PlayStation 3 controller, and more specifically the way in which it seems to have been - how shall we say this? - 'strongly influenced' by the motion-sensitive feature that's a part of Nintendo's Wii controller. "How much more 'me too' can [Sony] be?," spat an empurpled-with-rage Hocking, before suggesting that it wasn't only Nintendo that Sony was copying: Microsoft also has a reason to feel aggrieved by Sony's mimicking of the highly successful Xbox Live service.

Hocking also went on to have a go at the obsession with improving graphics as each generation passes. He described it as "a fundamental problem of approach" and a method which "forces game developers in to situations where they have to be factory workers. Assemble art texture here, model texture shades here. Repeat." This, argues Hocking, is a waste of time, particularly considering the pitifully slow adoption rate of high-definition televisions.

It all ended - as you might have guessed by now - with Hocking raving about the Wii, and in particular the controller, proclaiming that, "While graphics may add emotion, Wii's new controller interface is more likely to bring emotion directly to the player."

Related Content

E3 2006: Local PS3 pricing and dates revealed
09 May, 2006 You might want to sit down.
E3 2006: Redesigned PS3 controller unveiled
09 May, 2006 To the surprise of nobody (though to the possible annoyance of Nintendo).
PS3 to be region free
23 Mar, 2006 Phill Harrison confirms it, along with some other PS3-related news, at GDC.
31 Comments
6 years ago
By fully central I really meant:
To play online with the original xbox you used XBL- every online game used your XBL tag.

But XBL *is* fully central to the xbox 360 and PSLive was introduced after XBL360.

P.S. I'm still trying to get my hands on a dreamcast. icon_razz.gif
6 years ago
mqphu1 wrote
As a researcher, I say it is not 'copying'. It is a matter of "improving and moving forward". Sony made an intelligent/smart move and have the best of both world (Wii and Xbox360).

"If you can't beat it, then use it" - SONY
HAHAHAHAAAAAAAAA Researcher.
6 years ago
Nev wrote
I think it's worrying to Nintendo's case about the controller being the next leap in gaming, when one of their premiere titles (Smash Brothers Brawl) doesn't even USE it. If you have to pack in an old controller with your new console to play a top-tier game, it sort of muddles the point about a new control scheme being the way forward.
Welcome to Wrongtown, population: you.

SSBB has both gamecube and wiimote control schemes.
6 years ago
plufim wrote
Nev wrote
I think it's worrying to Nintendo's case about the controller being the next leap in gaming, when one of their premiere titles (Smash Brothers Brawl) doesn't even USE it. If you have to pack in an old controller with your new console to play a top-tier game, it sort of muddles the point about a new control scheme being the way forward.
Welcome to Wrongtown, population: you.

SSBB has both gamecube and wiimote control schemes.
Link please. I claim you are mistaken.
6 years ago
I believe SSBB does not use the motion sensitivity of the Wiimote, rather than not use the Wiimore itself. Either the Wiimote or the GCN controller will suffice for this. (Correct me if I am wrong)
6 years ago
Hyperworm wrote
plufim wrote
Nev wrote
I think it's worrying to Nintendo's case about the controller being the next leap in gaming, when one of their premiere titles (Smash Brothers Brawl) doesn't even USE it. If you have to pack in an old controller with your new console to play a top-tier game, it sort of muddles the point about a new control scheme being the way forward.
Welcome to Wrongtown, population: you.

SSBB has both gamecube and wiimote control schemes.
Link please. I claim you are mistaken.
Oh poop, seems I was wrong. Until further notice, it shall be me in Wrongtown, with a dunce hat on to boot. Sorry Nev.

Serves me right for acting how I did, really icon_razz.gif

Seems that I must have been remembering some speculation rather then facts, as a quick check of all my gaming information haunts reveals nothing.
6 years ago
^Big enough to admit your wrong.No shame in that.
Add Comment
Like this news?
Share it with this tiny url: http://palg.nu/3dk

N4G : News for Gamers         Twitter This!

Digg!     Stumble This!

| More
Currently Popular on PALGN
Australian Gaming Bargains - 08/12/11
'Tis the season to be bargaining.
R18+ Legislation
R18+ Legislation
Naruto Shippuden: Ultimate Ninja Storm Generations Preview
Hands on time with the game. Chat time with the CEO of CyberConnect 2.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2007
24 titles to keep an eye on during 2007.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2008
And you thought 2007 was populated.