Home
Twitter
RSS
Newsletter
Matt Keller
29 Sep, 2003

Rugby 2004 Review

PS2 Review | The game of Rugby finally receives a genuinely good videogame, and just in time for the 2003 World Cup.
EA Sports are notorious for delivering yearly updates of American sports games, mainly because the foolish American consumers snap them up without batting an eyelid (check Madden 2004's sales figures if you don't believe me). Occasionally, EA have been kind enough to bless us with English sports such as Cricket and Rugby. The difference is that EA only release these with a minimal interval of 2 years, meaning that you'll see more upgrades and changes than you would with the regular yearly updates of EA's other popular sports. EA Sports Rugby was released about 9 months after the launch of the Playstation 2 - a port of Rugby 2001 for the PC. It wasn't entirely great, filled with flaws and frustrating nuances that made the game difficult to play. Thankfully, EA Sports and HB Studios took the game back to the drawing board and we?re quite pleased with the results.

Carn' the Wallabies!

Rugby 2004 couldn?t have come at a better time, especially with the opening match of the 2003 Rugby World Cup just days away. Rugby 2004 boasts a huge array of improvements over the 2001 game, including a new intuitive control system, vastly improved AI, new rewards points for accomplishing in game goals, a new player editor which lets you edit existing players as well as creating your own, a new career mode, more than 65 highly detailed stadiums, 62 teams with over 1500 players, commentary from John Inverdame and Gordon Bray, and much more.

The Running Game

Chances are that the majority of the readers of PALGN know the ins and outs of the game of rugby, so an in depth explanation of the sport is unnecessary. EA Sports Rugby did a decent job of converting the game into videogame form, but faltered by placing too much emphasis on scrums and rucks, rather than the open field play, which is a crucial component of the game. Rugby 2004 sees the focus shifted onto the open field play, resulting in a much more authentic rugby experience. While the field play is now vastly improved, the scrums, rucks and line outs seem more screwy than ever. The meter in the scrum has been eliminated, which results in a lot of confusion, as well as the computer player winning the majority of the scrums. The rucks are also very messy, with no indication as to where the ball is positioned. Should the ball suddenly pop up, the nearest player is more likely to dog pile the ball, rather than scoop it up and play on, which is a major annoyance.

Rugby 2004 has a few different play modes - the usual training and exhibition modes, as well as 7 different forms of tournament - World Cup, Super 12, World Trophy and a whole host of domestic European leagues. The majority of these tournaments are the same, with the only changing factors being the teams involved and the trophy at the end. During these modes, your players can earn points buy achieving certain objectives - these points can then be spent on enhancing specific attributes, or creating new players.

With all these different tournaments to complete, as well as the multiplayer modes, players should expect to invest a substantial amount of time in Rugby 2004. It would have been nice to see the inclusion of online multiplayer and franchise modes, but we have to accept the fact that HB Studios are a small Australian studio, and probably had a limited budget for this project. Should Rugby 2004 sell well, we may see these in the next version.

Head smacking

Rugby 2004 has seen a substantial improvement in its visual presentation, but still fails to make the grade. It's almost like saying "Scraping your back with nails is more enjoyable when the nails get blunt" - it may be less painful, but you're still scraping your back with nails. The construction of the game's 65+ stadiums is really quite impressive, as they closely resemble their real life counterparts. Unfortunately, the texturing is absolutely horrid, the crowd is flat, and there are jagged polygons everywhere. This horrific appearance extends to the characters, who barely look anything like their real life counterparts in every aspect except skin and hair colour. Furthermore, the animations on these players range from mediocre to somewhat despicable - though a little better than some other recent local sport efforts. The low quality of the graphics just goes to show the sort of limited budget these developers are working with. The default camera takes on the tradition side on presentation that we see in televised games, but we prefer the classic camera approach, as it gives the player better control over kicking, as well as a better view for passing the ball along the line.

The sound department in Rugby 2004 provides a decent aural experience, with the combination of the crowd and sound effects of the game itself giving the player some idea of what its like to be at a rugby match. The commentary team of John Inverdame and Gordon Bray do a decent job, despite the fact that their samples can be horribly disjointed and repetitive in some scenarios. Menu music is decent, with the inclusion of the new INXS track I get up.

Cup of Life

It's probably well documented somewhere in the recorded history of my life that I've not always been a big fan of rugby, but Rugby 2004 delivers the sort of experience that makes rugby enjoyable for those who don't have an interest in the sport, as well as those who live and breathe the game. That said, the game is not perfect, as the flaws in the scrum, ruck and line out portions of the game may drive some players batty, but the improvement to the open field game should please critics of the previous Playstation 2 rugby title.
The Score
If you can overlook the horrible graphics, you'll find that Rugby 2004 provides a solid, easily accessible rugby experience. Give it a try, even if you don't like rugby - you could be suprised. 7
Looking to buy this game right now? PALGN recommends www.Play-Asia.com.

Related Content

AFL Live 2004 Review
03 Sep, 2003 It's the only contender for the cup, yet it manages to win the wooden spoon.
2 Comments
6 years ago
ooh yeah rugby is great .. ive seen when people in wales play it.. pretty funny looking game, its like american "football" without any armors and stuff.. everyone loves rugby
6 years ago
i dont like rugby but i do agree with slipknot_fan with its like american footy
Add Comment
Like this review?
Share it with this tiny url: http://palg.nu/Dr

N4G : News for Gamers         Twitter This!

Digg!     Stumble This!

| More
  Pre-order or buy:
    PALGN recommends: www.Play-Asia.com

Australian Release Date:
  Out Now
European Release Date:
  Out Now
Publisher:
  EA Sports
Developer:
  HB Studios
Players:
  1-4

Extra:
Analog Control
Vibration

Read more...
Currently Popular on PALGN
Bioshock 2 Review
Welcome back to Rapture...
Win 1 of 10 Bioshock 2 packs
Includes free stuffs!
PALGN Weekly Releases - 08/02/10
Christmas in February?
Nier Preview
Nierly as dark and twisted as Drakengard.