Home
Twitter
RSS
Newsletter
Tristan Kalogeropoulos
23 Sep, 2008

S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Clear Sky Review

PC Review | The Zone's an unstable place.
The idea that PC gaming is a troublesome chore, not for the faint of heart or technically challenged, stems from a long gone era. A time when megabytes and dollars were trading head to head on the hardware stock market and your average computer gamer had a mighty stack of boot disks, each designed to free up just the right amount of their EMS and XMS memory in order to get their various space shooters up and running. Thankfully things have changed and not even us bunch of geeks can remember what EMS and XMS stand for, let alone how to tweak our autoxec.bat and config.sys files. Thankfully we live in much simpler times. Pop in your game CD and off you go. The myth of the complexity of PC gaming is as close to reality as the idea that the two major political parties hold completely divergent ideals. Unfortunately though, very occasionally a high profile game comes along to prove the exception to the rule, and this time that game is S.T.A.L.K.E.R. Clear Sky.

GSC’s latest game has more bugs than Joe’s Apartment. From bizarre NPC behaviour, such as one enemy who decided he needed to lose some of those polygons he’d been packing on by sprinting back and forth between two walls rather than take aim and fire upon us, to plain and simple dropouts, as if we were playing the game via mobile phone and had wandered into a signal busting tunnel.

At one point a game breaking bug would kick us out every time a fellow Stalker, who was supposed to be leading us through a forest, would come across a band of crazed mutants. His surprised scream would not only alert them to our presence but also leave us confused and staring at our desktop with Clear Sky's bug reporting popup, the game disappearing in front of our eyes. After doing everything we could think of, including uninstalling and reinstalling drivers, running the game with no sound, changing visual quality and making sure we had the most recent patch for the game, the only solution we could find was to shoot our friendly guide in the face before he had the chance to lead us into the depths of the game crashing forest - so much for friends.

Thankfully, alongside its bugs, The Zone still holds some of its oppressive charm.

Thankfully, alongside its bugs, The Zone still holds some of its oppressive charm.
Close
The worst bug we encountered was an issue with our save files near the end of the game whereby, on loading some of them, we’d be inexplicably kicked out after 10 seconds. All this is quite unfortunate, as the game, when everything’s going well, is well worth your time, whether you’re a newcomer to the world of S.T.A.L.K.E.R., or have put in many an hour into the anomaly infested Zone.

Clear Sky takes place a before the events of the first S.T.A.L.K.E.R., Shadow of Chernobyl. Set in the wastelands around Chernobyl, The Zone, as the current crop of Stalkers know it, is changing. New anomalies are appearing and old ones disappearing, blocking some areas off and opening up others. The Zone is angrily sending out energy pulses from its radioactive core. Someone has entered its centre and apparently Zone’s don’t like it when you do that – and hey, who could blame them? You’re a lone Stalker who for some reason isn’t as affected by these radioactive blasts as others and on discovering that The Zone centre trespasser’s actions could lead to catastrophic events you set out to put an end to their intruding ways.

Shadow of Chernobyl presented a lonely, desolate Zone - a place to explore in which the physical space was the main antagonist rather than the Stalkers within. Clear Sky shifts its focus from The Zone itself to the denizens. Now the world’s characters and factions take a lead role in establishing the game’s mood rather than the world itself. For many a game this might be an improvement, but the oppressive nature of the first game’s environment was what made it stand out from the pack. This isn’t to say that that the shift in focus makes for a terrible experience, it just feels as if GSC have tailored this game towards a more Western audience causing it to lose a little of its Eastern European charm.

Exploring many old areas - and some new - especially with different parts opened up and new sections newly covered by radiation is incredibly fun. And battling alongside different factions within these can also be incredibly engaging as they seem to all interact relatively realistically. The new offerings come close to making up for the lack of focus on exploration of the Zone itself.

Hunting for artifacts is now far more rewarding.

Hunting for artifacts is now far more rewarding.
Close
The updated engine, despite its bugs, manages to look fantastic. New effects such as volumetric lighting, smoke and fire and depth of field effects all work together well. And time’s passage is painted beautifully, as bright days become red dawns, which in turn get covered by an inky night. The good thing about the graphics engine is that it’s extremely scalable, so older hardware can run the game well with only a few of the visual trimmings cut back.

The trusty PDA from Shadow of Chernobyl is back – because what Stalker worth his salt would risk missing his 12:00 appointment with the head of the nuclear anomalies department? And just like the game’s engine it has gone through some significant upgrades. With the stronger focus on factions, a new section covering the strength of your relations with each and their standing overall is present. Unfortunately, whilst it’s clearer compared the guessing game in the first S.T.A.L.K.E.R., it’s a little inorganic and detracts slightly from the atmosphere. The quest tracking aspect of the PDA is vastly improved though, allowing you to clearly keep track of what it is you're heading for.

Artifacts, the radioactive items with special stat improving qualities which most Stalkers are in The Zone to find, were a dime a dozen in Shadow of Chernobyl. Thankfully in Clear Sky this no longer the case and these ‘rare’ items are actually treated as such by the game. Artifacts can now only be seen when armed with a detector, and are usually surrounded by deadly anomalies, only fully detectable by throwing metallic bolts ahead of you and watching the sparks fly. These radioactive pockets must be avoided at all costs as getting caught in the centre will undoubtedly tear you limb from limb. As a result of the danger involved and the scarcity of them, obtaining these valuable objects now feels like a significant achievement and can score you some serious Stalker coin when sold.

The Zone is still full of musos.

The Zone is still full of musos.
Close
Although The Zone may have lost some of its oppressiveness, Clear Sky’s weapons and damage systems maintain their ruthless nature. Its weapons recreate realistic aiming difficulty and enemy fire can quickly lead to death, moreso than in many other games. Now there are gunsmiths in each faction headquarters who can upgrade your weapon, making it more accurate or able to hold more ammo etc. which makes things a little easier on that front. Bleeding that must be stopped by bandages is still ever present with each bullet that comes your way, meaning the smallest nick can result in death should you be foolish enough to travel without bandages. So despite being a little more user friendly the zone is still a reasonably inhospitable place.

As a game reviewer you’re often stuck somewhere between critiquing the interactive world that a title offers up and providing a buyer’s guide, ticking a list of boxes on the way to an eventual score representing whether or not you should swap a wad of cash for those bits and bytes on the disc. Looking at its virtual environment, gameplay and the combined experience that these provide, S.T.A.L.K.E.R. Clear Sky sits in a reasonably good position, a little less compelling than the previous title, but still definitely up there with some of the better FPS’s around. Had this been the sole pointer towards our final score a 7.5 – 8.0 would have been on the cards. However, as a pure product, Clear Sky sits around a 3, like a car that is a reasonably smooth drive, but breaks down every 50 or so kilometres. So until a series of patches fix its myriad issues we’re meeting it half way at 5.5.
The Score
Unfortunately Clear Sky's myriad technical issues obscure a reasonably good game. Hopefully a series of patches will allow it to become fully realised, but as it currently stands, the game is far too filled with bugs to recommend.
Looking to buy this game right now? PALGN recommends www.Play-Asia.com.

Related S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Clear Sky Content

S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Clear Sky Preview
29 May, 2008 The skies should be blue, but not the screens.
S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Clear Sky out later this year
28 Mar, 2008 August, to be exact.
S.T.A.L.K.E.R Clear Sky images released
05 Mar, 2008 Looks cloudy.
8 Comments
1 year ago
Yea, I totally agree with the score. If they are going to repeat their mistakes with bugs a second time round they don't deserve a high score.

However I really enjoyed the first one so I bought this one on steam, which is about $20 cheaper than retail. Steam are pretty good on patches so I hope they fix the bugs sometime soon. Until then I might hold off from playing it.
1 year ago
^The weird thing is, the first game has been played through twice on the same machine, and only crashed once.
1 year ago
This is a incredible blunder on the part of GSC, I really digged the atmosphere and gritty combat from the first game (a lot actually) but found myself distracted with the bugs/poor performance etc.

I was really hoping Clear Sky would be their opportunity to fix the mistakes of the first game and capitalise on the fantastic ideas they have underneath but.. to hear that it's even buggier..

It really is a massive shame. Better AI, graphics, a new dialogue system and maybe some gameplay tweaks (in particular the RPG elements) and I think STALKER could have become a triple A title.
1 year ago
Kinda weird this is coming out the same time as The Witcher EE as both games are trying to make up for bugs and flaws in the original games which were quite good otherwise. I really enjoyed Stalker but like The Witcher it was the bugs that soured the experience. Fortunately CDProjekt fixed the majority of problems, whereas it seems GSC failed. I will probably pick this up when I hear of some bug fixing patches.
1 year ago
"command.sys"?

I think that proved the point way better than you intended icon_sad.gif
1 year ago
Nice catch. Can't believe that I wrote that wrong - especially after typing edit config.sys so many times all those years ago. icon_biggrin.gif
1 year ago
el_rezzo wrote
CDProjekt fixed the majority of problems, whereas it seems GSC failed
Comparing Clear Sky and The Witcher EE is a little rich given that one's a rerelease and the other's a new title. I also bought it from Steam but that only prompted me to finally finish Shadow of Chernobyl - runs much better on my 4850 than the old 1950. I'm hoping for a patch too by the sound of things.
1 year ago
I haven't even started the first one yet so by the time I get to this one (already bought it icon_wink.gif ) it should be all patched up and relatively good to go... unless they do what EA did with the patch for spore and make it far more buggy icon_sad.gif
Add Comment
Like this review?
Share it with this tiny url: http://palg.nu/z6

N4G : News for Gamers         Twitter This!

Digg!     Stumble This!

| More
  Pre-order or buy:
    PALGN recommends: www.Play-Asia.com

Australian Release Date:
  4/09/2008 (Confirmed)
Standard Retail Price:
  $69.95 AU
Publisher:
  Red Ant
Genre:
  Shooter
Year Made:
  2008

Read more...
Currently Popular on PALGN
Bioshock 2 Review
Welcome back to Rapture...
Win 1 of 10 Bioshock 2 packs
Includes free stuffs!
PALGN Weekly Releases - 08/02/10
Christmas in February?
Nier Preview
Nierly as dark and twisted as Drakengard.