Home
Twitter
RSS
Newsletter
Luke
05 Nov, 2007

Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock Review

Wii Review | Still rocking?
Who would pay over $100 for a game with a peripheral that would work with the one game only? That's the main question everyone was asking before Guitar Hero debuted on the PlayStation 2. Surprisingly, quite a few people went on to buy Guitar Hero and Activision and Harmonix reaped the benefits. A sequel was green lit, and earlier this year Guitar Hero II was released to much critical and commercial acclaim. After a quick PlayStation 2 song pack, the game's developer Harmonix left their successful franchise, and publisher Activision passed the series on to Tony Hawk veterans Neversoft and Vicarious Visions. While being the fourth release, Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock is a game of firsts, but does it rock, or pale in comparison to its predecessors?

Most people are familiar with Guitar Hero by now, but if you're not then the good news is that the game is remarkably easy to pick up. The game comes bundled with a wireless guitar peripheral for a larger than normal recommended retail price. In-game, the player is presented with a vertically scrolling bar with five grooves, featuring coloured markers which move down the screen as the music plays. Each of these coloured markers represents one of the different coloured fret buttons on the guitar peripheral. By holding the appropriate coloured fret button and hammering the strummer at the right time, you strum a note. Mess up the timing, and you're given a mangled, out-of-tune note in return. Single notes are shown with just a solitary marker, while long notes have a trail behind them, indicating that the appropriate fret button must be held for that length of time. Sounds easy doesn't it? Well it is, after a few hours on easy mode when you're only using three coloured fret buttons - then you'll move onto four and those that want a real challenge will use five coloured fret buttons.

Hot.

Hot.
Close
Things get even more difficult when chords are introduced and you have to hold two buttons at once and strum. If you miss these notes, then the 'rock meter' on the bottom right corner of the screen will go down. If the rock meter goes too far down then it's game over and you'll have to start the song again. However, if you hit many notes in a row then you'll start a combo - by hitting combos you'll earn multipliers which increase your score. There are also special star-shaped notes littered throughout each of the songs. Hit all the notes in these sequences and you’ll fill up your ‘Star Power’ meter, which once full enough, allows you to instantly double your multiplier by holding your guitar vertically. This is obviously the key to gaining the high scores, but can also come in handy for getting out of trouble during the more difficult parts of songs.

The main reason Guitar Hero has really taken off is because it's just a heck of a lot of fun. The series has been a huge success commercially, and the fact that the guitar peripheral is always in somebody's hand at your local games shop is a testament to the mass appeal of the game. Guitar Hero is also the type of game just about anyone can play - your dad will be able to pick up the guitar, your mates will enjoy it and, if you find an appropriate song, your grandma may get involved. Possibly. The other appeal of Guitar Hero is that the game pushes the player to try and achieve perfection, as at the end of every song you're given a score and a star rating, and most players will consistently try and and beat their own scores.

Given the greatness of the previous releases in the series, the task put upon Neversoft and Vicarious Visions was not an easy one. But Legends of Rock isn't just an expansion, it's a full blown sequel. There is more of everything and a few things have changed.

While the Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3 versions of Legends of Rock were developed by Neversoft (of Tony Hawk fame) the Wii version was developed by Vicarious Visions, whose recent development portfolio includes Spider-Man 3. Before you even start the game up there are changes - the guitar has finally gone wireless, which is sure to appeal to those who have been rocking out and tripped over the chord, only to end up looking like more of a dud than a rock star. The guitar for the Wii version is a little bit different as well - you'll need to assemble the guitar by literally clicking two pieces together, and it includes a dock for a Wii Remote.

Feel the energy.

Feel the energy.
Close
Inserting a Wii Remote into the guitar does change things a little - activating star power is still done by holding the guitar upwards, but as the game uses the Wii remote to sense when the guitar is being held up, it feels a little more accurate. We lost track of the amount of times we held the guitar up in Guitar Hero II without star power activating properly. The Wii remote also features sound, so when you miss a note you'll hear it locally, which is great.

Obviously the main difference with Legends of Rock is the track-list, which is one of the best yet. Activision certainly went to a lot of effort to add some variety, with over four decades of music covered. The Sex Pistols re-entered the studio for the first time in 30 years to re-record "Anarchy in the UK" and there are more licensed tracks than ever before, with bands such as Metallica, Muse, the Rolling Stones and Rage Against the Machine all featured in the game.

The single player campaign in Legends of Rock works much in the same way as the previous games. There is a tiered unlocking system, so you need to complete a certain number of songs to move onto the next tier. The game does include some animated cutscenes, but they aren't exactly memorable and add nothing to the game at all. While beginners won't notice, the game is actually a little less forgiving on the expert difficulty this time. Expert players will likely appreciate this, until they actually play through a song on expert, which is a heck of a challenge. Despite this, the game is still remarkably simple for players to get into - the easy mode was picked up by Guitar Hero amateurs in less than half an hour in an impromptu straw poll in our office - but expert mode really is a challenge.

Legends of Rock also features a two player battle mode. Battle mode is a little bit different, as if you hit a string of notes correctly you'll earn a power-up which can be used against your opponent. Power-ups include things like increasing the difficulty for your opponent, or doubling the number of notes your opponent will need to hit. The battle mode is enjoyable, but we preferred the face-off modes, which are back again. The battle mode actually does make it into the career mode, where players will have to face off against a few celebrity bosses such as Slash and Tom Morello. The boss battles don't really add anything to the game and your enjoyment of them will depend on whether the battle mode appeals to your or not.

Some of the places you'll play at are great.

Some of the places you'll play at are great.
Close
Guitar Hero has always been best with a friend and Legends of Rock is no different. Obviously players can just play in one-off battles, but there is also a co-op option which will appeal to those who would rather play along with friends, rather than humiliate them. The Wii version also includes support for the Nintendo WiFi connection. Friend codes are unfortunately back with a vengeance, but pleasingly there are several online options. Ranked matches allow players to play face-off, pro face-off and battle. There are also unranked player matches for those who are less competitive. The Wii version of Guitar Hero III does not at this point offer support for downloadable content, and we're not sure whether it will actually be coming or not.

Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock is a great addition to the franchise and well worth adding to your collection. The Wii version doesn't support downloadable content right now, but with a huge track list, a solid mix of songs, and the trusty Guitar Hero formula basically untouched, Legends of Rock is well recommended. Even with the change of developer, Guitar Hero is still a great franchise and one that deserves to be played by all.

Please note the images provided are not representative of the Wii version and are Xbox 360 screenshots.
The Score
Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock is a fantastic game and a great addition to the franchise.
Looking to buy this game right now? PALGN recommends www.Play-Asia.com.

Related Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock Content

New Wii Guitar Hero Bundle Announced
05 Mar, 2008 Now with two guitars.
Oz Guitar Hero III replacement program starts
23 Jan, 2008 Activision now taking pre-registrations.
Guitar Hero on Wii to get stereo fix
08 Dec, 2007 Mono since launch.
24 Comments
2 years ago
Awesome, can't wait to get it on Wednesday.

Anyone know who will be selling it the cheapest? I'll be buying it from EB because I have a voucher, but I'd like to get them to price match.
2 years ago
Get it from Big W on Saturday for $98! That's if you can wait 3 days n all, or waste $50 if you want it straight away. I'll be picking it up Saturday, can't afford to waste $50 with all this gaming goodness coming up.

Strumming along as Matt Bellamy to Knights of Cydonia = <3. Can't wait.
2 years ago
98 dollars?

How are they only charging 98 dollars?

Will EB price match that? icon_razz.gif
2 years ago
Yeah, but make sure it's this Saturday.
2 years ago
So luke compared to the other two what do you think will be best?
2 years ago
The boss battles etc.. are a bit tedious / pointless but I really enjoyed the tracklist for this game, I would suggest looking at the tracklist then making your own choices though, to be honest you can't really go wrong with any GH title though.
2 years ago
canetoad wrote
Strumming along as Matt Bellamy to Knights of Cydonia = <3. Can't wait.
I have waited for this moment for so long. icon_loved.gif
2 years ago
Mostlikely be picking up the PS2 Ver as I don't own any next gen consoles yet.
2 years ago
Im still deciding whether or not to get the PS2 or Wii version. What would someone in the know recommend? I dont have a PS2 ethernet adaptor (so can't access the net), but own both the original Guitar Hero games on the Playstation 2. I still want to get the bundle with the cordless guitar..

Will the PS2 have downloadable content at all?

Is the Wii remote finicky to install and remove into the guitar?


Damn.. hard decisions..
2 years ago
Get the Wii version, it's super easy to remove the Wii remote and the Wii remote fits in comfortably, the Wii version also features online play and the PlayStation 2 version doesn't.

I don't believe downloadable content will come to the PS2 or the Wii to be honest, but im 100% there will be no downloadable content on the PS2. By getting the Wii version your sorta future proofing for the next GH title too.
2 years ago
Thanks for the advice Luke. Done!
2 years ago
I would like to ask Luke a question about the Wii version of GH3, specifically was there any issues with the sound (Dolby PL II support not working/being output in one channel) similar to what has been reported on some forums.

http://www.guitarhero.com/forums/8/forum_topics/1258?page=1
2 years ago
Hey mate,

I dont have Dolby PL II support so couldn't test this but otherwise the sound sounded fine.
2 years ago
the dolby thing happened on GHII, it sounded way different. Because of the separate tracks for instruments (Not being mastered properly i'd say, as it's a game not an album) they come out at different volumes and it makes it sound really messy. Normal Stereo masked this a lot better. IMO. Eg: in Hangar 18, this is especially noticeable.

Don't know if they fixed that or not
2 years ago
Great review Luke. I will be picking this up on Saturday $98... most likely 360 but maybe Wii.
2 years ago
Quote
the dolby thing happened on GHII, it sounded way different. Because of the separate tracks for instruments (Not being mastered properly i'd say, as it's a game not an album) they come out at different volumes and it makes it sound really messy. Normal Stereo masked this a lot better. IMO. Eg: in Hangar 18, this is especially noticeable.

Don't know if they fixed that or not
Did you follow that link? There is definitely an issue with the Wii version of GH3 sound wise. Some people are even reporting that when the system is set to stereo (what Activision is telling customers at their support center who complain about surround sound issues) both channels are identical rendering the game effectively mono. Of course a lot of people might not even notice this problem, but if you record the sound being output by the game (for instance using some wii gameplay videos sourced from a competing gaming website) and view the left and right channel sound waves they are identical whereas if you do the same thing with the 360 version you can clearly see two different sound waves. This is far from proof, as those videos for one reason or the other may just happened to have been made mono, but it certainly makes me cautious about buying the game before Activision makes some sort of public statement.
I'm pretty much sick of trying to find information about this problem, I was looking forward to this game a lot.
2 years ago
looks like its a known issue from their tech support
2 years ago
I picked up the Wii version last night and the sound seems fine to me. I am extremely happy with the new wireless guitar. The buttons are firm to press, the whammy bar is longer so it's easier to get at (and it swivels smoother and easier), and the strum bar isn't too loose so you dont double strum by accident anymore (i used to sometimes). A massive improvement over the black and red Shredder Guitars.

I also picked up the PS2 version for a friend and the Kramer guitar is also a massive improvement over the originals, but i rated it below the Wii's Gibson model as there is no removable faceplate feature on the PS2 variant. If you're into Guitar Hero, definately pick up the new guitars - they are a pure joy to rock with and make the game that much more fun to attain personal records.

The Wi-Fi connection for online multiplayer was also seemless. After having doubts reading reviews of Guitar Hero III, they have all been stricken for my mind after playing it. Last night I was dog tired after work and only put the game on to test out the new guitar and game content and instead ended up playing 1h 41m worth!

If given the choice, GH III on Wii is the worthy buy compared to the PS2 version interms of online alone. I have a stereo TV and am no audiophile by any means, so I cant tell you if there's a Dolby problem with GH III on the Wii. Like I said, it sounded perfectly fine to me.
2 years ago
I bought this game today and can confirm that it is indeed outputting in mono. Don't get me wrong, it's still a fun game to play and the songs sound great, but when you output your Wii into your computer and record what is being played it's mono. Both channels (left and right) are identical.

I wouldn't be so annoyed if it wasn't for the fact that only a couple of websites have picked up on this and none of the mainstream game press has mentioned it at all.

Fact is, people with stereo tvs and no surround support are probably never going to notice that this game is in mono, it sounds good so why check right? But it's a pain in the arse for those of us that want Activision to stop hiding a problem that I'm sure they are aware of and actually do something about it.

Like I said this is a really fun game and I really can't see myself returning it despite this problem, I just want it to be recognised outside of a couple of forums.

edit: I'd just like to point out that this problem seems to only affect the actual in game audio, the intro i believe works in stereo.
2 years ago
I'm a bit annoyed about finding out GH3 doesn't have online abilities on the PS2 especially when it says this on the back cover icon_sad.gif

Quote
Rock out online or party offline
2 years ago
Yeah you're right! I've got a sealed copy infront of my that i got for my mate as a b'day present and it's a case of lazy cover printing. Perhaps it was withdrawn after the covers were printed and ready to go?
2 years ago
With the Wii version does anyone know if playing against others is also region locked?

ie. can you NTSC players play PAL players?

The reason I ask is that Metroid Corruption only allows you to trade Friend token amongst people of the same region .. and I have an NTSC Wii and would like to play against PAL gamers (in Australia).
2 years ago
I picked up my copy of GH3 on Thursday so happy with the out come of the songs especially with the Disturbed, Slipknot, DragonForce, Muse and of course the metallica.
2 years ago
I think that the fact there is no 'Stereo / Mono' setting at all in the Options screen of the Wii version of Guitar Hero III (when the manual states there is) points to a royal f*ck up. Im really not sure if this can be corrected with a simple downloadable 'patch'. A recall may be in order.

I just finished it on Medium. Good fun, but still have a ton of crap to buy from the store.
Add Comment
Like this review?
Share it with this tiny url: http://palg.nu/rP

N4G : News for Gamers         Twitter This!

Digg!     Stumble This!

| More
  Pre-order or buy:
    PALGN recommends: www.Play-Asia.com

Publisher:
  Activision
Developer:
  Vicarious Visions

Read more...
Currently Popular on PALGN
Bioshock 2 Review
Welcome back to Rapture...
Win 1 of 10 Bioshock 2 packs
Includes free stuffs!
PALGN Weekly Releases - 08/02/10
Christmas in February?
Dante's Inferno Review
Is it Divine, or unwittingly Comedic?