Home
Twitter
RSS
Newsletter
Jeremy Jastrzab
27 Jul, 2007

Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix Review

Wii Review | At least it looks like Hogwarts.
With the US summer blockbusters having almost dried up and a lot of the big name games merely weeks away from release, we're quite relieved that most of the associated movie tie-ins are almost out of the way. With the fifth Harry Potter movie running through cinemas and the seventh (and final?) novel having been just released, there was always going to be a game tied in there somewhere. Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix is another EA production that has been released on just about every platform and obviously relates to the novel and movie of the same name. In particular, we'll be examining the Wii version of the game, which to an extent, is the most significantly different version available.

By this time, if you haven't at least heard about the exploits of the boy-wizard Harry Potter, please crawl out from that rock that you're still hiding under. Chances are you've missed things that are more important. Anywho, the fifth book is somewhat considered to be the least popular amongst the fans. Funnily, it's also the longest novel, yet ends up being the shortest movie. Go figure. The (very) basic story, is that Harry is back for his fifth year at Hogwarts School of Magic and has to contend with the death of a classmate, a potential connection of minds between him and the story's main villian, Voldemort, the prospect of the school being taken over by a tyrannical political agenda, countless moments of angst and of course, end of year exams. While maybe not as eventful as the other novels, the book was still an entertaining read.

If you've seen the movie, you'll know by now that it's really a supplement to the actual novel. Sure, it was quite well made and covered the basics, but the novel is the only place for the FULL story. As people who've read the book, we can't possibly imagine how someone who hasn't read the book would have been able to sit through the entire thing. The game however, actually follows the movie closer than the book. We don't know whether EA only have the license to the movies and can't really rely directly on the books, but given the size of the source material, it would have been much more gratifying to see a more indepth portrayal of the story. This is as opposed to the limited structure of the movie. As a consequence, if you haven't read the novel, we can't imagine how you'll cope with the game's plot. The plot sequences are raced through rather quickly and don't really go into much depth. Furthermore, they mirror what happens in the movie, very closely.

The whole crew is here, for now.

The whole crew is here, for now.
Close
In a way it's a good thing because it gives you more time with the game, but on the other hand, a lot of the potential in the story has been foresaken. This obviously means that aspects such as Quidditch have been left out of the game. Unless you know the story beforehand and are a fan of the novels, there really is no reason to bother with this game. Still, fans of the novels will at take solace in the fact that there are numerous references to previous novels. The game is littered with these references and Hogwarts itself is very faithfully recreated, if you consider looking like it does in the movie as faithful. Not to mention, it's utterly huge and will take a while before you're familiar with it.

The biggest aspect to the game is discovery. There are a whole lot of secrets to discover, some minor such as repairing a broken statue and some major such as discovering the password for a new secret passage. For every one of your discoveries, you'll get some discovery points that will eventually increase the levels of your spells. Don't discount the importance of these, as your spell level needs to be reasonably high towards the end of the game. There are a fair amount of extras to be unlocked from these discoveries as well. These range from “cups” to bonuses like commentary videos.

Most of the past Harry Potter games have been essentially Zelda clones. However, a major complaint with this latest game has been that the game ends up being something of a chore simulator. To an extent it's true, especially with the weak combat. One aspect that the game implements extremely well is the use of the Marauders map. Just like in the novels/movies, you bring up your map and pick a location or person to go to. When you put it away, you’ll notice that some footprints will track across the ground telling you which way to go. Essentially, it works like a GPS. While you will eventually learn the Hogwarts layout, this is an excellent tool not only for getting around but for learning more about the huge surroundings.

We’re quite grateful that the map is there. Because otherwise stumbling aimlessly from arbitrary task to (even more) arbitrary tasks, probably wouldn’t be worth our time. In an attempt to recreate the majority of major occurrences and the general “hunt-and-gather” nature of all of Harry’s tasks, the developers stuck us with rather rudimentary tasks. Virtually every single task, starts with someone wanting something, then Harry going to do/find it, while Ron and Hermione watch. It’s rather tragic because there happens to be so little that’s endearing. Occasionally, you’ll get a task that requires you to scale some heights or one where we donned the invisibility cloak but these tasks were few and far between. A couple were very annoying, where we had to find five talking gargoyles or six loudspeakers, with little to no help other than Hermione mentioning that one was in the area that you just walked into.

Nothing says endearing gaming like ringing a few bells.

Nothing says endearing gaming like ringing a few bells.
Close
To help with your tasks, often you’ll need your arsenal of spells to help you through. The non-combat spells and their implementation work reasonably well. The most useful spell will end up being Wingardium Leviosa, as you stack some benches to help you get to higher places or put items back where they’re supposed to be, while Reparo will be critical as well. The Wii controls are actually quite good, as they work and respond very well and are very easy to remember. However, the spell work is rather restrictive, where if you use the wrong spell, you’ll be met with a puff of smoke. The aspect that drags this side of the game down, is the targeting, which is not very well implemented. While you can point with the wiimote at your intended target, the system is plain and simply fails to register. It shows that the game needed more polish.

The aspect of the game that prevents the chore simulator tag from sticking is the combat. The idea is there, use a variety of disarming and pushing spells to knock down your opponent, then once more while they’re on their haunches. Thankfully, Protego deflects spells for a certain period, because otherwise, the magician battles would be very frustrating. Some of this comes down to the unresponsiveness of the controls, some to the stilted AI, which will aim exclusively for you when you’re down (your team mates are rather erratic with their help) and some to the cluttered and confusing rubble that fills the screen. You’ll almost be glad that some battles allow you to lose, because playing through too many of them is a chore on its own. One aspect of the game that was made a harsh reality on the Wii version was the camera. Unless the developers are highly skilled and can make a great fixed camera or alternate control method, Wii games will struggle without camera control. Order of the Phoenix is just one example, and while it was okay, there are many instances of obstruction and inconvenience due to the camera, particularly when it gets in the way of targetting.

Still, going around Hogwarts isn’t a complete farce. There are a scattering of mini-games, all faithful to the Harry Potter world, including exploding snap and wizard chess. The school has a reasonable atmosphere, with many students interacting differently with you as different events pass by and sometimes mentioning something nostalgic. Again though, the lack of variety and often random responses indicate that more work was needed. You’ve even got a few classes but they’re rather simple and not particularly prevalent.

So as we’ve mentioned, fans of the series are likely to be very pleased with the actual recreation of Hogwarts, as it really is quite superb. However, the closeness with the movie, probably hasn’t allowed for the developers to truly explore the depths of the source material. It’s this that highlights the fact that the game was in need of another year in development to really allow for the game to blossom. The underlying game is solid, it just needed some proper polish and the addition of endearing objectives. In the end, the game is really a supplement for the movie, which in turn, is a supplement for the novel. As such, anyone who is not a Potter fan, really shouldn’t bother with this game.

Not quite like escaping "The Rock".

Not quite like escaping "The Rock".
Close
The visual experience of Order of the Phoenix is not one to be sneezed at. Not only is Hogwarts huge and without any load times in the way but almost identical to the movie. There are a few dull corridors but for the most part, to looks mighty fine. Character likeness is quite good as well, as everyone makes the cut, tough there are a lot of repetitive NPC’s, simple models and stiff animations. Again, there is a coat of polish that is missing. Standard definition players are warned that in-game writing can be hard to read. The audio experience is quite good as well. The sound track is wonderfully orchestrated and recreated to give the movie feel but at times, it feels underused. The voicing is reasonable, but there are more than a few occasions where the lines sound like they’re being read off the script. A considerable amount of the actors have retained their roles. Sound effects get the job done.

Unlike a lot of games based off movies, Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix is not fundamentally flawed and doesn’t reek of cheap cash in. Unfortunately though, like most movie tie-ins, it was pushed out the door too early. The foundations for a great game are there, but it becomes obvious that restrictions were in place. Fans will probably overcome the chore work, especially as the moments that exude the history of the series come to the fore and there are some great little moments but once the combat and repetitiveness takes hold, it can be hard to swallow. Not to mention, the game’s stilted story leaves zero appeal for anyone who is not a Potter nut. We applaud the effort in visual recreation, but it really did need go the whole way.
The Score
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix was on the right track but needed more time to be great. Only fans will find any enjoyment. 6
Looking to buy this game right now? PALGN recommends www.Play-Asia.com.

Related Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix Content

E3 2007: Harry Potter demo goes Live
14 Jul, 2007 Downloadablo!
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix Wii screens
16 Jun, 2007 Has Harry got the magic on the Wii?
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix announced
22 Nov, 2006 Coming to every platform imaginable.
21 Comments
5 years ago
I rented this game from blockbuster for 2 days and i got 780 gamerscore from it. I played it heeeaaaaps though cos it was during my holidays. I thought it was rather enjoyable but alot of annoying things, Ron and hermione not moving out of your way, the chess is rediculously hard and the minigames are just a bore. But it was fun while it lasted. If you can get it for $50 at EB before Saturday, then i say it would be worth it.
5 years ago
so the Wii version controls well? anyone played it?
5 years ago
I think it controls pretty well (Wii version). There are some really frustrating times, but that are few and far between. The magic spells are fun, but could have been implemented better and as B3NBO said, Ron and herminoe allways get in your way!

Good review though Jeremy, a 6 is a fair score for it. Like you said, if your a fan of the series you'll like it, otehrwise I could see it getting old fast (so many fetch quests). Also as B3NBO mentioned, get it for under $50 and it will be worth it.
5 years ago
The Harry Potter game which I enjoyed the most was Prisoner of Azkaban and Goblet of Fire. You could play as Ron and Hermione and there was lots of Side-Missions too. I would of thought in this one you could play as them. The graphics seem pretty average judging by the screenshots. Great review Jeremy, I will give this a rent and might get it when I get a XBOX 360.
5 years ago
Thanks for the kind words boys icon_y1.gif

My personal favourite Harry Potter game was Chamber of Secrets. It was a top little game.
5 years ago
Nice review, I agree mostly. I think it's an alright game on Wii (yeah I have got one again), but I don't see how it could work on any other console, it'd just be too boring. I don't think the motion control just edges it into the 'playable' catagory though, it really gives it something, like being able to control Wingardium Leviosa in real time or physically fighting with spells. I'd say it's worth a rent, but only on Wii, I can't imagine it's any good at all without motion control.
5 years ago
What else can i say vut this looks crap the graphics are bad it dosent look at all good as the ones before although i do agree the handling is quite good icon_question.gif icon_confused.gif so i dont really no wat to say bout it
5 years ago
I got it for $50 on the PS3 from EB today for my wife who's a huge Potter fan.
5 years ago
I finished the game last week on 360 and loved it. Its so much better than the last Harry Potter games! Being able to explore the entire castle as the movie pictured it is awesome and the mauraders map is a great way of keeping track of where to go - much better than most mapping systems Ive used in games. The presentation is fabulous in the game too, I love the look of the menus. One of the best movie games ive played in ages.
5 years ago
GTPod wrote
I'd say it's worth a rent, but only on Wii, I can't imagine it's any good at all without motion control.
Everyone seems to forget that the PS3 version has motion control as well, don't just lump it in with the 360 version. I can certainly see what you mean though, Harry Potter and motion control go together very well which is why the Wii version is usually looked at as the best one, but I think the PS3 version is a nice compromise (weaker motion control but far better graphics).
5 years ago
I have played the game on PS2. The graphics are very poor for this late in the system's lifecycle. The actual gameplay, however, was quite fun.

I may look at getting the PS3 version for myself, is anyone sure how much better the graphics are on the PS3 as opposed to the PS2?
5 years ago
Yeah, the face models and the overall textures of things are much greater than the PS2 version icon_smile.gif
5 years ago
My brother rented this game out. There is tons of cutscenes during the start and it just skips to straight in the middle of the story. The locking on when you have to do spells in this game is pathetic because it locks on with other objects and you try to move and the next thing you know Hermione is in front of you and Ron is behind you. The voice acting for Hermione is horrible she sounds american its just abusing the pretty Emma Watson.
5 years ago
first off, i this book was my favourite icon_razz.gif


anyway, i downloaded the demo on PC and while moving the mouse in a particular way was new and interesting, it meant that camera control was almost non-existent.

still tempted 2 get it though icon_smile.gif
5 years ago
The game is average unless ur a huge potter fan.
I've played it on Wii and PS3, and the Wii version is superior in almost everyway except the Graphics, which are still not that bad.
The PS3 version running on a Sony Bravia Full HD 1080p LCD is awesome! Wii controls better, the wiimote actually feels like a wand.

The PS3 controls don't feel as natural, and there are a few framerate drops on both versions. Wii runs at around 30fps, PS3 a little higher....

Camera control is dodgy, and you can find yourself up against a corner, trapped by Ron and Hermione, who won't move to let u out.

All in all a good game if you can pick it up for under $70.
4 years ago
(wii) when I get to the first duel, I cannot target him to cast the spells on him, is there a spell lock button to keep him locked on so when I use my spells my cursor doesn't go everywhere and my spell misses?
4 years ago
Don't sign up and bump a topic that is a year old.
4 years ago
Sambo110 wrote
Don't sign up and bump a topic that is a year old.
... and when did you become a mod?

Demon_Paladin666 was obviously just looking for help.

Your point might must be justified, but if you are going to post such a criticism how about you suggest an alternative avenue for finding such information?
4 years ago
Well, I thought it would be obvious to make a new topic and ask. If you want help Demon_Paladin666 go to Nintendo gaming talk and make a new topic and ask, you will get more help there. And have you tried reading the manual? I'm sure it will tell you the lock on button.
4 years ago
4 years ago
And locked. Reviving old topics is never the best thing to do, but it happens when you simply google search. So all good.
Add Comment
Like this review?
Share it with this tiny url: http://palg.nu/6y

N4G : News for Gamers         Twitter This!

Digg!     Stumble This!

| More
  Pre-order or buy:
    PALGN recommends: www.Play-Asia.com

Australian Release Date:
  28/06/2007 (Confirmed)
Standard Retail Price:
  $99.95 AU
Publisher:
  Electronic Arts
Genre:
  Action Adventure
Year Made:
  2007

Read more...
Currently Popular on PALGN
Australian Gaming Bargains - 08/12/11
'Tis the season to be bargaining.
R18+ Legislation
R18+ Legislation
Naruto Shippuden: Ultimate Ninja Storm Generations Preview
Hands on time with the game. Chat time with the CEO of CyberConnect 2.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2007
24 titles to keep an eye on during 2007.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2008
And you thought 2007 was populated.