Home
Twitter
RSS
Newsletter
Chris Leigh
04 Jan, 2007

2006 Reader Game of the Year awards - The Winners

PALGN Feature | Which games you loved most in 2006.
It's tuxedos 'n red carpet season once again here on PALGN. In the coming days, the staffers will be revealing what they thought were the best games of 2006, but not before we give our lovely readers their turn. Hundreds of you voted this year in eight different categories, and with some not-so-predictable results in parts. So read on to see what you installed as the Best Game of 2006, and, if you're Branden Laurie of QLD, then do so with an unbearably smug grin on your face, as you've just clinched yourself a copy of the Limited Edition version of Neverwinter Nights 2.

Anyway, on with the show.

Best PlayStation 2 Game of 2006

5. Metal Gear Solid 3: Subsistence [7.6%]
4. Canis Canem Edit [8.3%]
3. Shadow of the Colossus [11.0%]
2. Kingdom Hearts II [11.7%]
1. Guitar Hero II [18.6%]

For those who voted for RedOctane's plastic axe-wielding gem, we salute you. Yup - in 2006, you lot couldn't get enough of Guitar Hero II - a decision that both we and our poor crippled fingers can certainly relate to. Lower down the top five, things were a tad tighter for the runner-up spot, with under one per cent dividing Kingdom Hearts II and Shadow of the Colossus in second and third respectively. And controversy or not, there's no doubt about one thing when it comes to Canis Canem Edit - it's one damn fine title.

Chris on Guitar Hero II: "Guitar Hero II is pretty much everything you could hope it to be. It keeps everything that made the first game good, and then improves on just about everything else. The soundtrack this time around is somewhat aimed more towards the hardcore player - not only in terms of the choice of tracks, but also in the more complicated style of play they produce compared to the more laid-back vibe of the original’s tracks.

But the game doesn’t suffer as a result, and what you have here is a selection of more interesting songs to play through. With more content in every area, a vastly improved multiplayer and an expert difficulty setting that’ll challenge you for months, Guitar Hero II is every bit the essential purchase the first game was."




Best Nintendo DS Game of 2006

5. Children of Mana [3.6%]
4. Prof. Kawashima's Brain Training: How Old Is Your Brain? [5.8%]
3. Yoshi's Island DS [8.7%]
2. Metroid Prime Hunters [9.4%]
1. New Super Mario Bros. [34.0%]

Much like Giant Mario stomping his way through Goombas and Koopas, New Super Mario Bros. convincingly trampled the competition underfoot in this year's Nintendo DS category. It's barely surprising, given the bankability of Mario and the undoubted quality of his latest 2D platformer, though Metroid Prime Hunters (a game we awarded a cautious seven to) in second place may raise a few eyebrows. Late-2006 arrival Children of Mana squeezed into the top five thanks to a late surge in votes.

Matt on New Super Mario Bros.: "It’s not easy to put a final score on New Super Mario Bros. – while the game kicks the crap out of everything else currently available on both current generation handheld systems, it’s over a little too quickly. Some might argue that the game doesn’t have many innovative features, but in reality, all one really needs is a fun game, and fun is something that New Super Mario Bros. has truckloads of."

  


Best PSP Game of 2006

5. Killzone: Liberation [4.8%]
4. Daxter [6.3%]
3. Tekken Dark Resurrection [7.1%]
2. LocoRoco [11.1%]
1. Grand Theft Auto: Vice City Stories [28.6%]

A convincing triumph for Grand Theft Auto: Vice City Stories, which follows on from where predecessor Liberty City Stories left off in 2005 by scoring top spot in the PSP category for 2006. Positions two, three and four are all top-notch titles as well, but Killzone: Liberation in FIFTH place? Ahead of Tales of Eternia, OutRun and Gitaroo Man? Madness, we tell you.

Luke on Grand Theft Auto: Vice City Stories: "Vice City Stories is simply a superb title. The game is not without its faults, but they are quickly overshadowed by the sheer enjoyment you will get out of the game. Rockstar has learnt a lot in a year, and Vice City Stories is one of the most enjoyable titles on the PSP yet.

If you're a Grand Theft Auto fan, or own a PSP, then there should be no hesitation in picking this game up. It's a step up from Vice City and little enhancements have made the game a thoroughly enjoyable and essential portable experience."




Best Xbox 360 Game of 2006

5. Saints Row [2.0%]
4. Dead Rising [2.6%]
3. Viva Piñata [3.3%]
2. The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion [11.2%]
1. Gears of War [67.3%]

The prettiest game of the year was never going to have too much trouble taking home the top gong in the Xbox 360 category, though of course Gears of War is far more than just an exceedingly pretty face. Its single player campaign is short, but majestic, while on Xbox Live the game has seen unprecedented levels of success and popularity. Oblivion was a well-beaten second, but was another title to stretch technical boundaries, with outstanding results. The joyous Viva Piñata deservedly made the podium, while two more sandbox titles - Saints Row and Dead Rising - rounded things off.

Chris-Leigh on Gears of War: "What Epic has created here is a gorgeous, Hollywood blockbuster of a game, a title packed with soaring production values and a style of combat that manages to be highly engaging, despite its ultimately repetitive nature.

True, it's some way from being original, and it features a cast and a setting that's almost as old as the science-fiction genre itself. But to whimper about such things as innovation would be rather missing the point; that for your hundred dollars or fifty quid, you're buying in to (at least) ten to twelve solid hours of supremely entertaining gaming. This is a formidable title - miss it at your peril."




Best Wii Game of 2006

5. Super Monkey Ball: Banana Blitz [1.9%]
4. Red Steel [3.1%]
3. Rayman Raving Rabbids [3.7%]
2. Wii Sports [8.0%]
1. The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess [82.0%]

"Duh", frankly. As expected by every sane-minded individual under the sun, Zelda took home the Wii rosette by the most crushing of margins. The distance between Link's game and runner-up Wii Sports is a pretty emphatic testament to Twilight Princess's quality, yet could also be viewed as evidence that, beyond Zelda and Sports, there's not exactly an avalanche of top-notch titles available to Wii owners. Still, it's early days, and Twilight Princess was flippin' ace, providing as it did a forty- to fifty-hour ride of non-stop adventuring and entertainment. Lacking the barren patches that plagued Wind Waker (the sailing - ugh), it was a game that wisely drew on the best the Zelda franchise has to offer, yet was just as spectacular when doing things its own way.

Chris on The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess: "Twilight Princess is a game we could praise all day if we so wished - there are still plenty of good things worth mentioning that we haven’t touched on yet. Although still not a hard game by any means, the general increase in difficulty over Wind Waker is highly welcome, as is the ability to warp to a large variety of places on the Hyrule map. The side-quests are a joy to play, and the fishing especially is impressively deep this time around, with a giant lake to while the hours away in.

And then there’s the sheer length of the game: around 60 hours to do everything. Veteran Zelda players should finish the quest around the 30 - 40 hour mark, though realistically you’re looking at a lot longer for newcomers. With its genuinely interesting story, superb control scheme and near-faultless game design, Twilight Princess is one of the best games ever made and is as essential as a game can possibly be."




Best PC Game of 2006

5. Neverwinter Nights 2 [5.1%]
4. Half-Life 2: Episode One [5.8%]
3. Battlefield 2142 [11.6%]
2. Company of Heroes [12.3%]
1. The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion [24.6%]

Oblivion's brains may have succumbed to the brawn of Gears in the Xbox 360 category, but on the PC it fairly romped to victory. The excellent Company of Heroes - one of only three games in 2006 to score a 9.5 from this site - finished in second, and was closely followed by Battlefield 2142. Equally marginal was the battle for fourth spot, with Half-Life 2: Episode One edging out Neverwinter Nights 2. Oh, and to the numerous nuggets who voted for it: no, the original World of Warcraft isn't a 2006 title. Gawd.

Brendan on The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion: "On the whole Oblivion is excellent. Really excellent, actually, and arguably the strongest contender for game of the year yet. It’s possibly the most accessible RPG ever made, with a limitless scope for character creation and the fantastic ‘do what you want, when you want’ gameplay. It’s also really freakin’ huge, with a massive world to explore, a great central plotline and an endless number of side-quests to conquer – it’s completely pointless to try and put an hourly figure on it.

The flaws – frame rate issues, loading times, a somewhat empty world and a subjective world leveling system – are really miniscule in comparison to the magnificent journey the game offers. Everyone with a capable PC should already own a copy of this most excellent game – if you don’t, ring up work and ask for a month off, then rush down to your closest store and grab it right now. Oblivion – it’s here, it’s brilliant, and it will take over your life."




Overall Game of 2006

5. Kingdom Hearts II [2.9%]
4. Guitar Hero II [4.6%]
3. The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion [12.1%]
2. Gears of War [19.5%]
1. The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess [32.2%]

The biggie, and would you look at that - Zelda and Gears occupying spots one and two. Perhaps that's not terribly surprising given the same result can be seen on many other Game of the Year lists at the moment, but you know, it's always nice to have it confirmed. Again. Oblivion snatches the bronze medal, and we can only applaud you all for pushing Guitar Hero II into a lofty fourth place. Oh, and commiserations must go out to Shadow of the Colossus, your sixth best game of 2006, which was beaten in a photo finish for fifth by Kingdom Hearts II.



Most Anticipated Game of 2007

5. Crysis [2.9%]
4. Metal Gear Solid 4 [4.1%]
3. Super Mario Galaxy [7.0%]
2. Super Smash Bros. Brawl [7.6%]
1. Halo 3 [21.0%]

The first next-gen Mario? New Snake shenanigans? Rockstar's latest GTA offering? Forget all those for now - in 2007, Master Chief is where it's at for more than a fifth of our readers. Halo 3 simply waltzed away with the title of 2007's Most Anticipated Game, registering nearly treble the number of votes that pushed Super Smash Bros. Brawl into second place. Another Nintendo institution sits in third spot in the shape of Super Mario Galaxy, whilst Grandpa Snake appears at fourth spot. However, perhaps one of the most notable things about this list is the omission of Grand Theft Auto IV - it seems the lack of information and media on Rockstar's latest opus may have backfired in this case. All the same, it'll probably sell a couple of hundred or so.


--------------------------------------
And that, as they say, is that. All that's left to do is to remind you to keep your eyes peeled for the staff's picks in the coming days. Tune in then, and thanks again for all your votes!

Related Content

The Greatest 100 Games Ever: 5-1
14 Nov, 2005 The five games our readers regard as the greatest ever created.
The Greatest 100 Games Ever: 20-6
10 Nov, 2005 Eighty down, twenty to go; our Top 100 countdown nears completion.
The Greatest 100 Games Ever: 40-21
07 Nov, 2005 Twenty games that our readers deemed fit for a Top 40 place.
59 Comments
5 years ago
Guitar Hero II in at no4 icon_biggrin.gif

But Kingdom Hearts 2 at 5 over Shadow of the Colossus? Shame on you all! icon_razz.gif
5 years ago
Elder Scrolls????? that game has the dullest combat system ever, and that isn't ever counteracted with a decent leveling up system.

for some reason the format of the announcement of the results made me dizzy.
5 years ago
pathetic just like the monthy sales charts.
5 years ago
Good stuff. No real surprises on this list. This just reaffirms how knowledgeable the forumers around here are.

Random Thoughts:
GH2 is the only PS2 game from the list that I have played (SotC still sealed and waiting for a new PS2 to be bought) and definitely great fun. Interesting to see KH2 beating out SotC (granted not by very much) as I've heard there's some boring areas in the game while SotC has been heralded as brilliant from start to finish. Nice to see an out there game like LocoRoco at the number 2 spot for PSP (though I accidentally deleted my save file yesterday and need to start all over again now). The favourite DS, Wii and 360 games were obvious. Also nice to see Zelda taking the top spot overall.

Great write up Chris-Leigh. icon_y1.gif
5 years ago
I really enjoyed GH II and as a game its really unique. Also helps I like Rock&Roll.

Dead Rising is a game I didn't play but in all the GoTY awards it always figures highly. Maybe I should go look at this title.

Very good list of games.

2007 has an equally impressive line up so gamers from all walks should be really happy.
5 years ago
I am confused and saddened that Bioshock didn't make it on to the anticipation list - shame on you all! icon_razz.gif

But yeah, no real surprises there.
5 years ago
Good write up and a lot of expected results icon_smile.gif
5 years ago
Gears of War has been dogged. Then again PALGN's members are predominately Nintendo fans, so what else can you expect?
5 years ago
Karai Pantsu wrote
I am confused and saddened that Bioshock didn't make it on to the anticipation list - shame on you all! icon_razz.gif

But yeah, no real surprises there.
tell me about Karia, has anyone seen any gameplay or the actual RPG elements??!?

but of course super smash bros. makes the list.
5 years ago
I don't know just how much info there is out there about Bioshock - I've been actively not looking for info if you get me icon_wink.gif I want as much of it as possible to be new to me.

That said, I did watch a video of the lead designer (I think) talking through an area of the game, showing off a bunch of different stuff. I think he touched on the upgrade system a bit in that, but it's been a while.
5 years ago
i love that the fanboy card being played because someone's pick didn't get top spot.

(i voted for HL2E1 before any of you want to comeback with anything accusing me of perpetrating the issue.)

mostly what i expected through all the lists, though there are some little surprises here and there, especially on the PC gaming front, and Kingdom Hearts 2 scored quite a bit higher on both the PS2 and overall charts than i expected too.

as for SotC - well, from memory it was a page or two on the old thread before it was mentioned to remember that it was a 2006 game. pity icon_sad.gif

there must've been a HUGE amount of anticipated games, looking at the percentages. only 42% of people voting for those 5, and 3% for last place.
5 years ago
Hmm, Gears really should have taken the cake over Zelda, but hey, that's just me. Surprising list, didn't expect GHII to trump a few games.
5 years ago
I voted for Guitar Hero II. What?
5 years ago
Yea it was basically what I expected aswell but i'm surprised a peripheral based rhythm game even makes the list!

Had Zelda actually had Wii quality graphics (instead of Gamecube) it would've been a tough one but I still would've voted SOTC. That game was memorable for so many reasons....but mainly because it was so unique.
5 years ago
Hey, Zelda was my second choice..I wasn't so much implying that PALGN is Nintendo fanboy based, but that there is a larger number of Nintendo fans/owners.

Its obvious if there was a larger number of Microsoft followers here GoW would've won.

But that's more than fair, Zelda was my second choice.
5 years ago
Four out of six is a good effort for me. I put Oblivion as game of the year. Simply if a game can keep me engrossed for 100+hours and keep me coming back for a second go then it's definatly worth GoTY.

Twlight Princess would have to a close second with me (yet to play to mind you).
5 years ago
NeoSanity wrote
Twlight Princess would have to a close second with me (yet to play to mind you).
icon_dumb.gif
5 years ago
*insert smiley echoing the sentiment of the above poster*
5 years ago
NeoSanity wrote
Twlight Princess would have to a close second with me (yet to play to mind you).
I have no doubt there would've been a lot of these. icon_rolleyes.gif Just for the record...you really shouldn't be voting for a game unless you've played it imo. It really does f@#k with the results!

But it definately clears up a couple of things for me, so thanks NeoSanity!
5 years ago
I voted for GoW and Oblivion (tie) for GOTY. I haven't played LoZ:TP enough to make up my mind. Once I go to the Betty Ford Clinic for gamerpoint addicts I'll get stuck into some Zelda action. icon_smile.gif
5 years ago
Jim Dash wrote
Gears of War has been dogged. Then again PALGN's members are predominately Nintendo fans, so what else can you expect?
Jim Dash wrote
Its obvious if there was a larger number of Microsoft followers here GoW would've won..
You know I love ya Jim, but there's probably less Gears of War fans that are interested in Zelda than Zelda fans that are interested in Gears of War (based on the longevity of Zelda games alone). It sorta makes sense for Zelda to take the top spot based on that.

Also, the number 1 game was listed as "1. The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess [32.2%]" with no console name next to it. For all we know everyone voted for the Gamecube version. I don't wanna read that "Gamecube game with modified controls" crap in this thread. Even if we ignore the Wii version, Zelda:TP still comes out on top based on the GC version.

These are not fanboy comments. These are logical comments. I feel ashamed that I even need to point this out.
5 years ago
no hourble mention to Tokobot. icon_evil.gif
5 years ago
ugh the boot wrote
NeoSanity wrote
Twlight Princess would have to a close second with me (yet to play to mind you).
I have no doubt there would've been a lot of these. icon_rolleyes.gif Just for the record...you really shouldn't be voting for a game unless you've played it imo. It really does f@#k with the results!

But it definately clears up a couple of things for me, so thanks NeoSanity!
Argh...I felt bad at the time (and I guess I still do) voting for a game I haven't played. I mean I've played Guitar Hero 2 at Supanova, I guess hype really does contribute to these sort of things huh?
5 years ago
Hey, you're probably right Thrizz, but Zelda is definately deserving. I know there are a few here who are both Gears and Zelda fans.

Oh, and I <3 you too.

icon_razz.gif
Add Comment
Like this feature?
Share it with this tiny url: http://palg.nu/PA

N4G : News for Gamers         Twitter This!

Digg!     Stumble This!

| More
Currently Popular on PALGN
Australian Gaming Bargains - 08/12/11
'Tis the season to be bargaining.
R18+ Legislation
R18+ Legislation
Naruto Shippuden: Ultimate Ninja Storm Generations Preview
Hands on time with the game. Chat time with the CEO of CyberConnect 2.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2007
24 titles to keep an eye on during 2007.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2008
And you thought 2007 was populated.