Home
Twitter
RSS
Newsletter
Chris Leigh
14 Nov, 2005

The Greatest 100 Games Ever: 5-1

PALGN Feature | The five games our readers regard as the greatest ever created.
18,000 words. 190 pictures. Over a hundred hours of counting and writing. Several hundred forum comments. About five of you with odd opinions on which Mario Kart is the best ever. And so far, 95 games. It's been a long old slog, this Top 100 Games malarkey but finally, praise be, we're down to the five games that our readers - yes, you, so don't be shouting at us - consider the finest ever published. If you're new to this chart (and where have you been?), then you can check out the games which occupied positions 6-100 at the links below. As for the rest of you, enjoy our final article in this series, and no scrolling straight to the #1 game, eh? Thanks.

100-81 | 80-61 | 60-41 | 40-21 | 20-06

05
Super Mario 64
Nintendo 64, 1996
D: Nintendo EAD | P: Nintendo
926 points

From the moment you first guided Mario across the grassy knolls overlooked by Princess Peach's Palace and clambered up a polygonal tree, it was clear that Super Mario 64 was something special. Indeed, Mario's first ever fully-3D outing was very special, and would quickly prove to be an undeniably crucial moment in the wider history of videogames, both as a title that inspired dozens of other developers to explore the possibilities offered by a third dimension, as well as a game that provided a sturdy stepping stone between digital and analogue control in videogames.

Almost ten years on, Super Mario 64 is still superior to many of the 3D platformers churned out today, an achievement that speaks volumes. The smooth-as-butter analogue control that felt so satisfying back in 1996 still handles flawlessly today, while the level design on display here is the very definition of 'timeless', an irrefutable testament to the immense talent of the team behind it. Even the smaller details - the hidden areas, the secret slide race, swinging Bowser about by his tail - are still nothing short of joyous. A platforming masterpiece then, and a jolly important one at that.


...


04
Resident Evil 4
GameCube, 2005
D: Capcom Production Studio 4 | P: Capcom
1,021 points

It's an unfortunate fact that the vast majority of games with a first-quarter release date are often shunted to the back of memories when it comes to deciding on the best game of each year. 2005 promises to be a one-horse race all the way however, with Resident Evil 4 the thoroughbred that looks set to finish several lengths ahead of its nearest rival. The fact that it was first released almost ten months ago has done nothing to dampen its quite stunning impact. Everything about Resident Evil 4 displays the trademarks of a developer that knows what it wants to do, and is damn good at getting it done. The visuals are as atmospheric as they are beautiful, the sound is wonderfully nerve-racking, the enemies are exemplary and the cut-scenes are simply magnificent.

It's the combat that steals the show however, with each and every enemy encounter meticulously weighted in order to generate as much tension as possible. With the shuffling undead of previous Resident Evil games now scrapped for an altogether craftier, quicker foe, and with the amount of ammunition granted to players impeccably well-judged, every individual skirmish between the player and the enemy becomes a hugely memorable battle. Even the plot is half-decent compared to previous titles in the franchise, though we'll admit that's perhaps not saying a great deal. It's all of these ingredients that make Resident Evil 4 the greatest survival horror title ever by a country mile, and one of the greatest titles of this or any other year.


...


03
Final Fantasy VII
PlayStation, 1997
D: Square | P: Square/SCEE
1,094 points

Gaming mythology has long held that Final Fantasy VII, one of the most critically acclaimed games of all time, also holds the dubious honour of being one of the most returned games ever, due to what is often perceived as a slow start to this majestic RPG. For those who persevered however (and with 8 million sales to date, that's probably a good number), Final Fantasy VII was vastly rewarding. It remains one of the finest examples of a videogame that can truly connect to players on an emotional level, and we're not just talking about individuals who can be classed as hardcore fans of the RPG genre.

Even those who usually find the world of RPGs a confusing and inaccessible place should make the effort in this case, for there's so much to love and admire about Final Fantasy VII - the inventive dystopian setting, the likeable characters, the emotive storyline, the cracking dialogue, the fabulous battles, the endlessly versatile Materia system - that the idea of missing out seems almost criminal. It's an epic package rounded off by a quite brilliant final encounter, and a game that should be experienced by everyone from three to one hundred-and-three. Essential.


...


02
Goldeneye 007
Nintendo 64, 1997
D: Rare | P: Nintendo
1,121 points

There is, of course, a great deal to sneer about when it comes to movie-to-game conversions, which makes the appearance of Rare's Goldeneye at #2 all the more sweetly ironic. It's hardly unmerited though, for this stellar Bondian adventure reaches some quite awe-inspiring heights. Most of these are to be found in the wonderful multiplayer mode, almost certainly the most fun that can be had with an N64 and three other friends - we dread to think of the number of patchy educations and even patchier relationships that can be attributed to Rare's decision to include a four-player mode.

Elsewhere, the singleplayer is hardly too shabby either, spread across a total of twenty levels of masterful design that positively ooze atmosphere. Weak levels? There's barely a weak moment, never mind a weak level. The range of guns is ridiculously well-rounded (though we'll admit that perhaps the KLO88 could have been excluded), while some of the set-pieces simply deserve dozens of playthroughs. And heck, we've not even touched on the superb stealth sections or the gadgets, two features that helped recreate the thrill of actually being Bond better than any game since has managed. Yes, it's getting on nowadays, but there can be no better tribute to the all-round brilliance of the game than the lofty position it occupies in this chart, especially as it comes from a genre so focussed on cutting-edge, modern technology. Infact, according to you lot, there's only one game out there that can eclipse it...


...


01
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
Nintendo 64, 1998
D: Nintendo EAD | P: Nintendo
2,157 points

Surprised? We're guessing not. Since its release in 1998, barely any other title has come close to taking top spot from The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time in any of the Top 100 charts that are routinely trotted out by other publications. True to form, the game racked up almost twice as many points as the second-placed title in this survey, and appeared in over half of your lists. The appearance of the game at the top of polls such as this one has almost become a cliché in itself by now. Yet like all clichés, there's a truth and fundamentally sound reasoning behind its revered, untouchable status.

For a start, it's a game that packs an emotional punch like few others, a title that genuinely inspires a wide range of feelings. Riding across Hyrule field on Epona felt utterly liberating, entering the Temple of Time for the first time felt foreboding, watching night fall across Lake Hylia felt strangely melancholic, and climbing the winding staircase on your way to a final confrontation with Ganondorf felt daring and epic. Emotion engine? Sony was three years too late, we're afraid. It's also a title with some breathtaking design. In all its brain-twisting glory, the Water Temple is perhaps the best example of this, though the standard simply never drops below 'scintillating' from dungeon to dungeon. It's a visually beautiful game as well, and it plays out to one of the great videogame soundtracks. It's engrossing, it's unforgettable and it's imaginative.

It's all of these things. But above all, it's the greatest game ever made.


...


___________________________________________


Surprised? Agitated? Pleased? Whatever your impressions are of our - sorry, your - list, feel free to speak your brain here. But before you do, take a few minutes to reflect on our final Top 100 below. And thanks for reading.

100...Final Fantasy XI [90]
099...Soul Calibur 2 [93]
098...NiGHTS Into Dreams [94]
097...Disgaea: Hours of Darkness [95]
096...WipEout 2097 [99]
095...The Sims [100]
094...Silent Hill 2 [103]
093...Quake II [105]
092...F-Zero GX [106]
091...Advance Wars: Dual Strike [107]
=89...Super Smash Bros. [108]
=89...Monkey Island 2: LeChuck's Revenge [108]
088...Gran Turismo 3 [109]
087...God of War [110]
086...Age of Empires 2 [111]
085...Warcraft III [112]
084...Super Mario Sunshine [114]
083...Star Wars Battlefront [115]
082...Conker's Bad Fur Day [116]
081...Chrono Cross [117]
080...Counter Strike [119]
079...Metroid Prime 2: Echoes [120]
078...Golden Sun [121]
077...Fire Emblem [122]
076...Diablo II [123]
075...Civilisation III [124]
074...Advance Wars [125]
073...Phantasy Star Online [127]
072...Lemmings [128]
071...Call of Duty [130]
070...Unreal Tournament [132]
069...The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening [133]
068...System Shock 2 [134]
067...Katamari Damacy [135]
066...Eternal Darkness [136]
065...Doom [137]
064...Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic [138]
063...Rez [139]
062...Tales of Symphonia [140]
061...Final Fantasy VI [143]
060...Grim Fandango [146]
059...Beyond Good & Evil [153]
058...Planescape Torment [157]
057...Killzone [161]
056...Banjo-Kazooie [162]
055...Pokémon Gold/Silver [165]
054...Devil May Cry 3: Dante's Awakening [170]
053...Sonic & Knuckles [173]
052...Soul Calibur [185]
051...Final Fantasy IX [191]
050...Maniac Mansion: Day of the Tentacle [195]
049...Burnout Revenge [198]
048...Sonic the Hedgehog [201]
047...Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty [204]
046...Gran Turismo 4 [209]
045...Mario Kart 64 [214]
044...The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind [217]
043...The Secret of Monkey Island [220]
042...Secret of Mana [226]
041...Pro Evolution Soccer 4 [228]
040...Baldur's Gate II [232]
039...The Legend of Majora's Mask [237]
038...Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time [238]
037...Deus Ex [243]
036...Grand Theft Auto: Vice City [250]
035...Kingdom Hearts [256]
034...Street Fighter 2 [262]
033...World of Warcraft [269]
032...The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past [292]
031...StarCraft [301]
030...Sonic the Hedgehog 2 [304]
029...Super Metroid [309]
028...Super Mario Kart [314]
027...Half-Life [325]
026...Final Fantasy VIII [337]
025...Super Mario World [342]
024...Perfect Dark [353]
023...Grand Theft Auto III [361]
022...Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island [385]
021...Ico [401]
020...The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker [408]
019...Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater [438]
018...Super Mario Bros. [453]
017...Chrono Trigger [457]
016...Final Fantasy X [466]
015...Halo 2 [473]
014...Super Smash Bros. Melee [485]
013...Halo: Combat Evolved [504]
012...Super Mario Bros. 3 [537]
011...Metroid Prime [589]
010...Burnout 3: Takedown [622]
009...Half-Life 2 [649]
008...Metal Gear Solid [690]
007...Tetris [765]
006...Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas [817]
005...Super Mario 64 [921]
004...Resident Evil 4 [1,026]
003...Final Fantasy VII [1,094]
002...Goldeneye 007 [1,121]
001...The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time [2,157]

Related Content

PALGN's GBA Top 5
27 Aug, 2003 The readers and writers of PALGN bring you their top 5 Game Boy Advance games.
52 Comments
7 years ago
Shame on you all, Re2 not even in the list, Re4 is great but Re2 is a better game.
7 years ago
And just so you all know: we'll be announcing the three voters who'll get a free game later this week! We haven't forgotten! icon_smile.gif
7 years ago
Goldeneye No. 2?
What a pleasent surprise.
I really should play Final Fantasy 7 one day to see what all the fuss is about.

RE4 is da bomb and SM64 is the greatest 3D platformer to date

As for Ocarina of Time, it doesn't really surprise that it's number one, what's really surprising is the margin from 1 and 2. Amazing stuff.

One thing, I can't help but feel that there's a game that's been forgotten.... but I don't know what
7 years ago
Futurama-

Awesome.....

Awesome to the max

I am justified, THE game, nay the EXPERIENCE, the right of passage that every true gamer should embark upon made it to first place.Its all here....goldeneye and mario and even res 4.Its all here......ahhh....

so great....such immense quality.

Only so much i can write at work, more to come later, but let me be the first to congratulate Chris on a bloody good job well done.I can only imagine the monotonous tallying of votes and and time spent on such an undertaking.*pats on back all round*

I found it thoroughly enjoying and it certainly bought back many a memory, from the first time i accidentally discovered the red switch palace in mario 64 or rusty bucket bays memorable tunes, it was all good.

Just most excellent icon_biggrin.gif
7 years ago
01
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time

And rightfully too!
7 years ago
Well done on a well written list.
I've only played 2 of the top 5 list, and one of those only in multiplayer.
But I don't like Zelda, Final Fantasy, or 3D Mario's, so it's OK.
icon_smile.gif
7 years ago
Pssssh.

Perfect Dark > Goldeneye

Anyday.

The list just feels so...cliche...
7 years ago
Quinsisdos wrote
Pssssh.

Perfect Dark > Goldeneye

Anyday.

The list just feels so...cliche...
The whole top five is a cliché, they're always fairly easy to predict.

But I agree with your statement on Perfect Dark over GoldenEye. Perfect Dark has one of the best multiplayer experiences to date.

Top effort Chris.
7 years ago
Four of the ten games I voted for got in the top five. Not bad, Zelda OoT I voted as firsty and Goldeneye was number five of my top ten off hand.
7 years ago
Also, I think OoT kinda got tiring the third time I played through it. I'm on (or was, I didn't bring the 'cube with me) my third run through Skies of Arcadia, and i'm not tired of it yet :/
7 years ago
Resident Evil 4 was so groovy - I'm glad it brightened up an otherwise predictable top 5. (Cept for Goldeneye - woot for 2nd possie)

C - Top work *thumbs up*
7 years ago
Don't think there was any suprises on number 1, just to see how much it won by.

To tell the truth, since I haven't played Ocarina of Time properly... It wasn't in my top 10, but I did play Majoras Mask and Windwaker end on end, putting about 150hours between those two titles, and soon I will be playing Ocarina of Time properly once I get a VGA / Component adaptor.
7 years ago
Re4 wasnt a predictable top 5
7 years ago
Predictable but fair.
BRILLIANT Job Chris, i know the tens upon tens of hours you put into this and the end result is brilliant and a great asset for the site.
7 years ago
I think the real winner of this poll is Nintendo, and all its fans. 4 out of the top 5! icon_smile.gif

Now that the whole list is up I can say I've played 89 of these games, some for not very long though. .

Just noticed that there's just 1 serious sport game in there, plus some gran turismos. Not many sport-centric gamers here? Perhaps the votes were spread out?
7 years ago
OoT deserves it's place as the best, for it still is damn well the best.

I can't believe Morrowind wasn't in there though. I hate you all icon_sad.gif
7 years ago
KLO88!! I've been calling it the KLOBB for the last 6 years!! Oh all these years, and nobody has corrected me.. what a dick I am. icon_redface.gif

Aaanyway...

Who didn't see this list coming? Well earned, but still quite inevitable. I think I can take pride in saying that I own thirteen of the top 20 games on this list, including all top 5 games. Who'd have thought I would have such impeccable taste? Hurrah for me.

Chris, what can I say... amazing, epic and dare I say it... HUGE. Just HUGE. Awesome effort! Let's not forget HUGE! It's been a pleasure reading your little blurbs that summed up each game with respect (even the ones that really shouldn't have been there...). You deserve some kind of medal. Maybe one with chocolate inside of it. Mmm, tasty victory.
7 years ago
That list was quite surprising though and though with certain games being and not being included in the list. Personally, the most notable aspect was, that not one game from the Splinter Cell series made the list.
7 years ago
Capoeira wrote
KLO88!! I've been calling it the KLOBB for the last 6 years!! Oh all these years, and nobody has corrected me.. what a dick I am. icon_redface.gif
Nah, it is a klobb - it was named after Ken Lobb, NOA's rep to Rare. He eventually left for Microsoft.

Another interesting fact - it's Ken's (slightly girly sounding) voice in the intro of Metroid 3. "The last metroid is in captivity..."
7 years ago
Says KLO88 in the Goldeneye instruction manual. icon_neutral.gif Though I've always said Klobb myself.
7 years ago
Death to the Klobb!
Long live Goldeneye
(although Perfect Dark was better, and my number one.)

I am suprised that Super Smash Bros Melee wasn't higher up the list, or Super Mario Bros. However, great article PALGN.
7 years ago
Fairly expected, but good choices.

And although there were some odd things, it could have been worse...like the 50 greatest games in Ralph Magazine, which has, if I'm not mistaken, Vice City as #1. Which is the dumbest thing I've ever heard.
7 years ago
DancesInUnderwear wrote
Which is the dumbest thing I've ever heard.
Yeah, mostlikly only because it was in Ralph. icon_wink.gif
7 years ago
Quote
From the moment you first guided Mario across the grassy knolls overlooked by Princess Peach's Palace and clambered up a polygonal tree, it was clear that Super Mario 64 was something special.
hehe the funny thing is that the trees were actually sprites
Add Comment
Like this feature?
Share it with this tiny url: http://palg.nu/kA

N4G : News for Gamers         Twitter This!

Digg!     Stumble This!

| More
Currently Popular on PALGN
Australian Gaming Bargains - 08/12/11
'Tis the season to be bargaining.
R18+ Legislation
R18+ Legislation
Naruto Shippuden: Ultimate Ninja Storm Generations Preview
Hands on time with the game. Chat time with the CEO of CyberConnect 2.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2007
24 titles to keep an eye on during 2007.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2008
And you thought 2007 was populated.