Home
Twitter
RSS
Newsletter
Matt Bassos
03 Nov, 2004

Enter the Fanboy

PALGN Feature | PALGN attempts to get inside a fanboy’s head.
fan n (fan)
An ardent devotee; an enthusiast.

boy n (boi)
A male child.

fanboy n (fan-boi)
A person which at all cost must protect the integrity of a video game, console or game-related topic, for the sheer reason of competition.

If you have never heard of the term “fanboy”, I’ll put it as simply as I can: someone who endures, at all costs to keep the reputation of a video game or console (or anything, really - Ed.)at levels where it benefits from positive publicity. Well that doesn’t sound so bad you might say, but unfortunately there is normally one clear way of upholding this “Fanboy Honour” which entails verbally bashing the living crap out of anything which directly competes with the video game or console in question.

It’s human nature to compete. We compete in sports, academic achievements and so on. You might be able to pass the term “fanboy” off in these instances, they are forms of competition so what’s the difference in the video game genre? Not a lot, however it’s the ignorant fanboys, found within this medium which separate the genres to such a great degree. These are the type of fans that will ignore all facts, unless it benefits their argument in some way. You have seen them on the message boards – “Grand Theft Auto: Vice City is the worst game eva man. it looks real bad and boring as.” Of course they ignore the fact that Vice City has averaged some of the best marks in video game history but that doesn’t matter to the fanboy. They want you to agree with their perspective, regardless of any well-known facts, and this wouldn’t be a major problem until you see fanboys versus other fanboys.


VERSUS


I’m going to use the recent debacle with the scoring on Killzone on IGN. It is not hidden fact that Killzone, an impressive first-person exclusive shooter on the Playstation 2 was being hyped by media publications as the “Halo Killer.” Xbox fanboys who have struggled against the Playstation 2 in verbal arguments for the sheer reason of competition always had the success of Halo to throw back in their faces. So when Killzone was being announced as the “Halo Killer" there was an uproar between both forces of fanboys. Playstation 2 fanboys were fanatical that an exclusive game could free them from the arguments of the great Halo. Xbox fanboys in turn verbally bashed the game's previews, saying it would never reach the status of Halo. Killzone was progressing nicely until IGN dropped the bombshell, the review of Killzone – overall score 7.5.

If the message boards of both games were a warzone before, this review turned them into a nuclear holocaust. Halo fanboys invaded boards with victory cries, laughing at Killzone, the great “Halo Killer.” Playstation 2 owners attempted to digest what had just happened, previous previews and even reviews from other publications said the game was a pretty solid shooter. They of course came to the conclusion that IGN was biased, unfair, Xbox fanboys themselves and even that they reviewed a 90-day old build of the game.

Below are some comments from a range of gaming boards, the authors will be left anonymous. Note that none of these posts have been edited in anyway.
*Warning - the below statements contain some offensive language.*

“always thought that ign was fair at reviewing games, but this just pulled it off. They are fan boys. Like you said, the AI is better in the demo then the bilt that ign review. I'm really pissedoff right now. I think that we should write a letter to them and thel them to review the game that was just realesd”

“ign made it sound like this game sucked halo's ass. dont beleive what the jakass who reviewed that ganme said, its bs. i dont need no damn review to tell me what i good game is, i no killzone is the sweetest looking game. damn! it sure does piss me off that they sadi all that tho”

“Those bastards just think that Halo 2 should win at any cost. I have the demo and the AI is waaaaay better than those dumbshits in Halo. Just letting you all know that I still root for killzone”

“watch now IGN will give Halo 2 a 9.4-9.9, there a bunch of Halo whores and i will no longer trust them for any more reviews, considering they gave ATV offroad fury a ****in 9.2 or sumthin like that”

“Well i personaly believe that Ivan was payed of or gave an unfair rating because killzone might look like a threat and thats why he didnt like it. I mean he wrote that the shooting range was totally awsome. he praised it......and that was a 13 month old buil HAHAHAHAHA Sulic i hope you die.”


Xbox fanboys were quick to retaliate with new revere.

“Uh excuse me bust didn't you little ps2 fans have to buy a HD to even get online? How much did that cost? Xbox live and Xbox are so superior over PS2 its not even funny.
Believe me, i used to have a PS2 and was a big fan, but after Halo sucked me in and Metal Gear Solid 2 was over, I sold that for a Limited Ed. Halo Xbox. W/ halo 2 around Xbox live will be the biggest gaming experience ever, Killzone has nothing now.”


Ivan Sulic, the reviewer of Killzone on IGN also received his own flak from the fanboys.

So why do fanboys fight each other in a barrage of flame wars in order trying to convince each other who has the better game? It’s not like the respective company is paying each and every one of them to bash the competition. More so I believe it lays in the fact that fanboys want the console they have brought with their cold earned cash to annihilate the competition. But what about those people who own all three consoles? Well it seems they have still put their preference first for a particular console; otherwise they wouldn’t be engaging in flame wars on the internet. Maybe bashing another console reassures the fanboy that they have made the right decision in the console war, maybe it’s some dark and hurtful memory the fanboy has about the other console. Whatever the reason “fanboyism” is something which should be overcome because…

If you don’t you really are missing out of the best of both worlds. I’ll think I let the following quote from a fellow board poster at a Killzone site sum up my words.

Posted by MasterChief @ Sunday 31 Oct '04

“Well being an Xbox owner all I have to say is good luck Killzone. Hopefully the game will score high marks so the PS2 also has an awesome shooter like Halo(2). Both games should be able to live together (Killzone shouldn't even be compared to Halo) so good luck on future reviews and hopefully fanboyism one day will end.”

Posted by MasterChief @ Sunday 31 Oct '04

“I wonder when we can all just enjoy the great games regardless of what system they come out to. I find it hard how some fanboys have to stick for their console just because they don't get a game or whatever. Just because I own an Xbox and probably never will play Killzone doesn't mean I want it to fail... Why the hell would anyone want that, so people don't get to enjoy well developed games that are fun? HELL NO... Xbox fanboys should stop coming in here and ruining this forum. Good Luck on Killzone.”

Fanboys should be happy that great games are being made for great consoles. You have all the right in the world to be a fanboy, but crossing that line of bashing another game or console to prove your point doesn’t do yourself any favors. The gaming world is always going to have “fanboyism” however, if we can keep that strictly in the sense of being a “fan” then maybe we all can live in happiness.

The views expressed in this article are solely that of PALGN staff writer, Matt Bassos and do not represent the views of the entire PALGN staff.

Related Content

Guerilla: Killzone 2 on 360 would be "impossible"
04 Sep, 2007 More next-gen hair-pulling.
Binge and Purge: For those about to save, I salute you
25 Oct, 2004 Quicksave? It’s for the meek!
New Halo 2 and Killzone websites
30 Sep, 2004 Big name first-person shooters launch new websites.
22 Comments
7 years ago
fantastic article Matt icon_smile.gif

Thanks Man - Matt
7 years ago
lol, the school's content filters 0wned that one, i'll read it when I get home ^^
7 years ago
Stupid goddamn filter. I bet it's a good article anyway. icon_razz.gif
7 years ago
Good article. icon_biggrin.gif
(Wonder what caused that to be filtered... maybe the "offensive language" warning? It doesn't tend to filter mirrors of bash.org, and that's quite bad icon_lol.gif)

Look at their post quality! Bahahaha icon_lol.gif
I'm not sure if flame wars like this between people who can write properly are worse or better...
7 years ago
that was a good article, though it made me ashamed to be a gamer in parts...

i only have a PS2 in the current console range, but most of my friends have XBox's... 1 or 2 are fanboys to the point they refuse to look at anything the PS2 puts out, which to me defeats the purpose, how can someone know something is better until you've played both? so i used the refuse to play games at their place, but that really only added fuel...

the main reason i bought a PS2 over any other console was for Gran Turismo... at the time PGR1 wasn't out but i'd seen a demo... i still prefer GT over PGR, with the exception of damage, i wish GT would add damage... that, and i don't like the XBox controller...

i'm not sure if i'll get Killzone, i'd like it, but shouldn't be spending money right now, i still haven't played Halo on an XBox, only PC, and to me, it wasn't that great... but i'll still probably give Halo 2 a burl...

on the plus side, fanboys are usually entertaining icon_smile.gif
(from afar...)
7 years ago
A good article indeed, I was accused of being a FFXI fanboy, until I pointed out all its failures. The reasons I continue playing despite this are simple:
- The Community
- The good points outweigh the bad points

Simple as that icon_biggrin.gif

Oh, and there is always a VG Cats strip for these situations.
7 years ago
Hyperworm wrote
(Wonder what caused that to be filtered... maybe the "offensive language" warning? It doesn't tend to filter mirrors of bash.org, and that's quite bad icon_lol.gif)
'Tis a content filter.

I hate fanboys, plain and simple.

...

What? icon_razz.gif
7 years ago
If Halo 2 gets great reviews, I'll go round GTPod's house, play it for a couple of hours then write a feature about how it totally sucks and deserves a much lower score, oh wait, GTPod hates Halo 2 too, damn, i'll have to find someone else...

"Grumpy Old Reviewers #1 - Jon puts up his flame guard as he tries to explain why Halo 2 sucks"
7 years ago
Quinsisdos wrote
If Halo 2 gets great reviews, I'll go round GTPod's house, play it for a couple of hours then write a feature about how it totally sucks and deserves a much lower score, oh wait, GTPod hates Halo 2 too, damn, i'll have to find someone else...

"Grumpy Old Reviewers #1 - Jon puts up his flame guard as he tries to explain why Halo 2 sucks"
Yes, you must protect yourself against such valuable members of society who's opinions really do matter. icon_razz.gif
7 years ago
Actually, I fear the fanboys...
7 years ago
Then you must defeat them man to boy, much like Ivan Sulic has done.

If you haven't read the above page, I suggest you do so thouroughly. Never before have I seen such an effective use of the english language to lay down the law to blithering idiots. What a way to go. icon_biggrin.gif
7 years ago
CerebralAssassin wrote
Then you must defeat them man to boy, much like Ivan Sulic has done.

If you haven't read the above page, I suggest you do so thouroughly. Never before have I seen such an effective use of the english language to lay down the law to blithering idiots. What a way to go. icon_biggrin.gif
Woah, the sheer idiocy of some people surprises me.
7 years ago
*sniff* Wonderful. icon_biggrin.gif
He seemed incredibly fair with those replies, too... there were a few mails in there that asked politely and weren't too forward, and he replied to them accordingly without going off on some kind of mad rage. icon_biggrin.gif

Melancholy at the end, though... icon_neutral.gif
Master of noob bashing, Ivan, wrote
Anyway, you see them? They are "gamers." They are the idiots on the other side of instant messages and bulletin board posts. They are the morons that dictate sales numbers.
It's true. And I fear they'll eventually kill the video game industry (or at least reduce it into a boring lifeless mess). icon_neutral.gif
7 years ago
Gamespot just reviewed Killzone and gave it 6.9.
Get ready for round 2.
7 years ago
do palgn get games before release like gamespot etc to review?
7 years ago
In a word: Yes.
7 years ago
I could think of a couple more words, but they're not appropriate for the boards. icon_razz.gif

(icon_biggrin.gif)
7 years ago
Nice article! I've always had some contention with fanboys, but as a fellow writer pointed out they also have a role to play in these things. They might look like an inherent evil, but they are at least passionate, despite their rampant ignorance. Then again, I've found that gamers in general are woefully ignorant, whether they are fanboys or not.

I suppose it's a matter of pride. I don't get either game: I thought Halo was a bit of a half-assed job when compared to the liked of Serious Sam and Killzone's over-reliance on often predictable scripted events proved to stunt its gameplay. But maybe the media is also to blame. Why did writers go out and call Killzone the Halo Killer, based purely on a few screenshots and that it was a PS2 exclusive FPS? I could really dislike the fanboys, but the writers are the ones who should know better and research a bit more, maybe exercise mroe discretion.

Bias is rampant in gaming and it's everywhere. Before we can even start to regard those at the lower ends of the ladder, perhaps we should look at those who incite these things in the first place with stupid and ill-advised comments. If IGN ever referred to Killzone as a Halo Killer prematurely, they deserve all the fanboy flame spam and then some. If they didn't then take it on the cheek. Any journo should know that fanboys don't know better. But I've long since suspected IGN's credibility...
7 years ago
Gamespot gave it a 6.9, hey? That's never a good sign. (Warning: Coarse Language, Hilarity)

It is indeed the screenshots people can only base a game on before reviews pop up. For a game that pulls so much out of the PS2 (in still shots at least), Killzone was perfect hyping grounds, I suppose.
7 years ago
hahah awesome stuff,

I think everything I would have wanted to say has already been said. One thing I would add is that "fanboyism" can have a positive effect in that it can keep older games from dying out completly , introducing the older to the newer generation.
Take Final Fantasy for example, If it werent for the fanboys all we would have nowadays would be a hoarding mass of FFX fans who are blinded by fantastic up to date graphics.
<hint, IS a fanboy himself>
but hey , its kind of like conservation , dont inflict your views on others e.g "FFX is **** , go play something older like FF5" but rather "so you like FFX... when I was young I played FF7 , <shows FF7> etc , and look at the drama! look at the battle system! LOOK IM A FANBOY".

bwargh 死んだ ごめんね
7 years ago
Very well put Noogle. icon_smile.gif
7 years ago
Thanks, Beepos!

Fanboys are old? I always thought they were younger. At least the most have to qualify as immature. But I also resent the idea tha fanboys keep the old games alive. I keep a lot of old games and old-school values alive, but I'm not a fan boy. Besides, how does that apply to all those WCG, CPL, Counter-strike and so on fan boys?

I think we should recognise the fine line seperating fan boys and enthusiasts.
Add Comment
Like this feature?
Share it with this tiny url: http://palg.nu/Hg

N4G : News for Gamers         Twitter This!

Digg!     Stumble This!

| More
Currently Popular on PALGN
Australian Gaming Bargains - 08/12/11
'Tis the season to be bargaining.
R18+ Legislation
R18+ Legislation
Naruto Shippuden: Ultimate Ninja Storm Generations Preview
Hands on time with the game. Chat time with the CEO of CyberConnect 2.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2007
24 titles to keep an eye on during 2007.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2008
And you thought 2007 was populated.