Home
Twitter
RSS
Newsletter
Luke
02 Nov, 2004

Luke's Rant # 1: N-Gage Vs PSP Vs DS

PALGN Feature | Luke covers the issues regarding Resident Evil 4 going to the PS2 and the PSP / DS war.
Gaming news is literally changing hourly and obviously the pressure is on us to deliver it as soon as possible. This can often mean that we miss out on delivering our own personal opinion on some of the issues surrounding gaming. So, without delay I thought it was time that I delivered my take on some of the issues surrounding gaming and PALGN.

Reviews and Review Scores:
Everyone's a critic... Unfortunately, due to the amount of traffic we get to this site nobody is ever going to agree completely with the scores that PALGN gives out. We've previously ranted about this but I think it is essential that i bring the issue up again. I am specifically looking at World Rally Championship 4 which i recently reviewed. Along with the review came a plethora of people who wanted to fuel the debate of Colin McRae Rally 2005 Vs World Rally Championship 4.

Reviews are purely subjective and are ONE person's opinion of a game. We generally try to take the interests of all our readers into account and personally i found that Colin McRae Rally 2005 was a better title than World Rally Championship 4. There is no right or wrong to this issue though, however, Gamerankings seems to agree with my contention.

If you don't agree with our opinion then that is completely understandable, but please take into account the fact that everybody has different tastes and every one of our staff members have different opinions.

PSP Australian Price:
Sony recently surprised the hell out of everybody by announcing a ridiculously cheap price for the PSP launch in Japan in December. This has everybody in other regions speculating on the price point when the PSP eventually comes out in other regions.

The following can only be taken as pure speculation but we would assume the Nintendo DS will launch in Australia at $199.95 and the PSP at $249.95. So what difference does $50 make? Well, not much, especially considering Australia's apprehension to anything Nintendo related. The pressure is seriously on Nintendo to include a pack-in game (Super Mario anyone?) or drop the price by another $50. As it stands, the only thing which could stop Sony is the battery life issue...

What about launch dates? Neither company is releasing any information and not responding to any speculation, it would be fair to say the Nintendo DS will have a respectable launch in Quarter 1, 2005 and the PSP will see the light of day in Quarter 2, 2005.

One thing that fans of either handheld seem to be forgetting is that either way gamers win. The Nintendo DS has meant Sony are going to be releasing a handheld at a ridiculously cheap price and there are bound to be some brilliant games on offer for both handhelds. Fighting about which company is going to win isn't going to make the company win so it is kind of pointless. One thing is for sure and that is that PALGN will be covering both platforms so don't worry.

Resident Evil 4 going to the Playstation 2:
Just to add fuel to the fire, we've also heard it will be making a cameo on the XBox soon as well...

Resident Evil 4 is going to be a graphical showcase for the Gamecube despite this announcement. The only way to play it for about nine months will be on the Gamecube and then Playstation 2 gamers will have their chance. Nine months is a ridiculously long time to wait for a game (Can you imagine waiting until August, 2005 for Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas?)

We doubt many people are going to hold off for an inferior version of the game, we are glad more people will be able to experience the inevitable greatness of Resident Evil 4 though. Playstation 2 gamers cannot complain either as they will be getting Devil May Cry 3 to tide them over in February.

N-Gage Vs PSP Vs DS:
Do people still remember the N-Gage? PALGN covers the N-Gage and we really haven't had much material to cover in the past few months. With two weeks and a half until the Nintendo DS launch in North America we were kind of expecting Nokia to reveal a lot of games or another hardware update.

Unfortunately, our expectations were too high and so far we're yet to see many announcements from Nokia. Could they be conceding defeat already? Some of the "big" games coming out for the N-Gage in the next few months include SSX: Out of Bounds, Pathway to Glory, FIFA 2005 and Urban GT.

This isn't exactly a stellar line-up but it is better than nothing. As it stands at the moment, the N-Gage is more expensive than the PSP and the DS look to be launching at, so a massive price drop will be needed for the N-Gage to stay in the game...

That's it for our little rant, but keep checking back to PALGN as we will have them as we see necessary. Feel free to add your comments on any of these issues in our forum.

The views expressed in this article are solely that of Luke Van Leuveren and do not represent the views of the entire PALGN staff.

Related Content

Win one of five copies of V8 Supercars 3: Create & Race
31 Aug, 2007 Enter and (possibly) win.
Nintendo continues to dominate UK
08 Aug, 2007 8/10 ain't bad.
E3 2004: Sega confirms content for both the PSP and Nintendo DS
12 May, 2004 Project Rub and Sonic DS confirmed.
66 Comments
8 years ago
You make some good points there. I like the analogy between RE4 and GTA. Our guests should really indulge in this kind of information.

As for me, I think the demasked project from the boys over at Warp Pipe will prove to be very interesting for the DS. Unfortunately, we won't know nearly enough until very close to or upon launch of the DS and PSP as to the real pros and cons of each system.
8 years ago
re4 isnt going to xbox, my affiliates and i have been doing some research on it and there are no plans for an xbox version because the xbox is terrible in japan and it would be a waste of money for capcom to take it there when they pulled the gamecube exclusivity because the previous installments didnt meet projections.

btw, my affiliates would be the affiliates of my resident evil site www.bio-hq.com, plug icon_lol.gif
8 years ago
You dont give up do you?

I link you to here:
http://www.eurogamer.net/article.php?article_id=57062
8 years ago
icon_lol.gif
8 years ago
i know everyone's a critic, but i think that adding the last 5 reviews or so by a particular reviewer (just the scores) might help people work out whether to trust someones judgement or not... i don't know how easy this would be but at least that way if you agree with the previous 5 opinions, chances are you'll agree with the 6th...

the other option is to simply bugger off and find a site that reviews everything well, that way you'll be happy with the good review...
8 years ago
Vidgamer wrote
You dont give up do you?

I link you to here:
http://www.eurogamer.net/article.php?article_id=57062
they never said they were taking it to xbox or had any plans to did they, everyone just assume because its going multiplatform, but its not going to xbox, i bet you my website on it.
8 years ago
theres one problem i don't want your website. Im not saying its confirmed im saying people shouldn't dismiss the idea.
8 years ago
i kinda read it as they did have plans for XBox, assuming they get the go-ahead...
8 years ago
ah the beloved fanboy...

i know how to identify them now icon_smile.gif
8 years ago
ObsoletE wrote
ah the beloved fanboy...

i know how to identify them now icon_smile.gif
Too late, the offending post was deleted icon_razz.gif
8 years ago
hehehe... ah well, we can only laugh at the memory then...
8 years ago
And another fanboy post (Same Person) deleted. Sheesh >.>
8 years ago
You think my article would open up their eyes huh...

Oh well.
8 years ago
Quin: You know, it's no good if for every post you delete, you create another equally spammy one icon_razz.gif

[/cheek]
8 years ago
look at it this way, the exclusive for nintendo was pulled because the series just wasnt selling well enough as it was on the playstation, the reason for that is that the gamecube has only sold about 15.2 million units worldwide, so they port it back to playstation which has sold about 75 million worldwide where they think it will boost sales which is not doubt will.
Ok so tell me this, they pulled it from nintendo because of its low market share, why would they take it to xbox when it has only sold about 15.5 million worldwide and under 1 million in japan where capcom is based.
There you go, if you think its smart business to waste money on a port that wont bring in any profit you go ahead, but it wont happen
8 years ago
lol dude wtf is that about?
8 years ago
You didn't see nothing. ¬_¬

That may be the case, but I could just as easily argue as to why they planned ot release it on the Gamecube in the first place. 15.2 Million userbase versus 15.5 Million (according to your stats) would indicate that the GCn would be the last in line to recieve a game going by your logic.

My point? That an Xbox port is possible, and while not currently planned, bot out of the question either.
8 years ago
capcom signed a contract with nintendo for 5 games, re4 just happened to be one of them, while the re creator mikami was hoping to boost the userbase in japan with the exclusiveness of re to the cube because apparently its his favourite console it obviously didnt work thats why its coming to ps2 because it can and will make more profit there, but to put it on the xbox would cost money they wont make back.
8 years ago
So you think that RE4 wouldn't sell enough copies on Xbox worldwide to make up whatever the production costs of a PORT were?
8 years ago
yep, there is no doubt they would probably add a few new things, plus paying the ppl to work on it, plus shipping, advertising, distribution, its just not worth it.
8 years ago
TransgenicX wrote
yep, there is no doubt they would probably add a few new things, plus paying the ppl to work on it, plus shipping, advertising, distribution, its just not worth it.
Similar to what will happen if Capcom decide to bring it to the PS2... Oh wait! They're.

No matter which way you look at it, it's a profit for the company. Although I highly doubt the possibility, since a Resident Evil hasn't been made for the Xbox and it'll be hard to determine how exactly it would sell worldwide, however, it's still very likely. Never rule out such a possibility with 'any' third-party games. You must remember they're(the developers) trying to make a living also, so if the more copies they can sell is only better for them.

I don't understand why you're getting so worked up about this though. It's clearly a rumour.
8 years ago
it coming to ps2 is NOTHING like it coming to xbox, ps2 sells 10 times more then xbox and they are guarenteed a huge profit, while if they take it to xbox it will sell the same as the cube and thats the whiole reason they took it to the ps2.

ps2=75mil
xbox=15 mil

how is it the same?
8 years ago
dude you're not understanding your own logic. if they just looked at console sales then RE4 for the Cube wouldn't be in development.
8 years ago
why do you think as soon as the contract ends they took it to ps2? the only reason it was on the cube is because of the exclusive deal.
Add Comment
Like this feature?
Share it with this tiny url: http://palg.nu/1n7

N4G : News for Gamers         Twitter This!

Digg!     Stumble This!

| More
Currently Popular on PALGN
Australian Gaming Bargains - 08/12/11
'Tis the season to be bargaining.
R18+ Legislation
R18+ Legislation
Naruto Shippuden: Ultimate Ninja Storm Generations Preview
Hands on time with the game. Chat time with the CEO of CyberConnect 2.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2007
24 titles to keep an eye on during 2007.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2008
And you thought 2007 was populated.