Home
Twitter
RSS
Newsletter
Jeremy Jastrzab
04 Mar, 2010

EveryonePlays: Just how successful are petitions?

PALGN Feature | By looking at some successful and innovative examples, see how you can help protect children from mature games.
EveryonePlays - Protect Children from Mature Games.

PALGN and Everybody Plays, in partnership with GAME retailers, have set up a petition for everyone who believes that Australian video game classifications should include an adult R18 rating, in order to protect children from mature games. In the first 48 hours alone, we've managed to secure over 3000 signatures alone. However, some may still be sceptical. Just how much do petitions help? After all, we’ve all heard about the lack of success of petitions, particularly online ones. Still, here are some examples of successful and interesting online petitions. Success isn’t necessarily needed for the petition to ‘work’, but it will always be seen favourably if it can reach its target number. So while you’re reading through these, remember that we have our own petition going and that it’s up to you to make sure that you make this is a successful one so that it may protect children from mature games.

Head to the new Everyoneplays website here.

Find your nearest GAME store by clicking here.

Petition: Whales Revenge
Date: 25 February 2008
Result: One of the biggest petitions ever held. On 25 February 2008, Melbourne resident Patrick Bonello reached his target of collecting one million signatures from all over the world, having set up the Whales Revenge website two years earlier. His aim was to display a united show of force to pressure the Australian government into more action against Japanese whaling. Including a basic Space Invaders style game (where you’d protect whales from advancing whaling ships), visitors to the site would play the game, sign the petition and pass it onto friends. Reaching 26,000 signatures one day and getting 1,000 on any good day, Mr Bonello hopes to keep the site going with a new goal to reach 10 million signatures.

Source

Partick Bonello, the man with the plan.

Partick Bonello, the man with the plan.
Close
Petition: Work Choices
Date: November 2005
Result: During the time that the highly infamous Work Choices Industrial Reforms were set for introduction in Australia, several online campaigns were setup opposing the changes. One of the most heavily supported campaigns was "Take a Stand Barnaby!", petitioning National Party of Australia Senator Barnaby Joyce to act on his concerns about the IR laws and vote against them in the Senate in November 2005. Even though the overall action wasn’t enough to stop the IR law changes from being made, the petition received 85,189 signatures, thought by the ACTU to be a record for an Australian online petition at that time.

Source

Good to see you're working hard Barnaby.

Good to see you're working hard Barnaby.
Close
Petition: Venezuelan recall referendum
Date: 15 August 2004
Result: The Venezuelan recall referendum was called on 15 August 2004, to see whether incumbent President Hugo Chavez ought to be recalled from office. While the result of the referendum was to have Chavez stay in office, the important part came leading up to the referendum. In 1999, a recall mechanism was introduced into Venezuelan law. Under its provisions, an elected official can be subjected to a recall referendum if a petition gathers signatures from 20% of the corresponding electorate. So to order the presidential recall vote in 2004 – for which the constituency was the entire nation – the opposition party required around 2.4 million signatures to push for the recall, which it successfully managed to attain.

Source

He may not like video games, but Chavez knows how to use cover.

He may not like video games, but Chavez knows how to use cover.
Close
Petition: Zappafrank
Date: 22 July 1994
Result: 3834 Zappafrank is a small main belt asteroid named after the legendary eccentric rocker, Frank Zappa. John Scialli, a forensic psychiatrist in Phoenix, Arizona headed a successful Internet campaign to name the asteroid, which apparently was one of the first worldwide online petitions. It involved Zappa fans in 22 countries and produced the most people supporting an asteroid's name, according to the International Astronomical Union. For the record, Scialli’s has a bizzare affinity with naming astrological and scientific discoveries after the legendary rocker.

Source

This man has an asteroid named after him. Among other things.

This man has an asteroid named after him. Among other things.
Close
Petition: Save La Femme Nikita
Date: January 2001
Result: When the television series La Femme Nikita was cancelled in 2000, the dedicated fan based worked to revive the series. The campaign was noted in particular for its size and innovation, which included an ‘online renewal petition’ that eventually led to a full-page advertisement in The Hollywood Reporter. Over 25,000 letters were sent to the USA Network and Warner Bros which included several memorabilia pieces that showed people still remember the show. As a result of these efforts, a fifth season of eight episodes was announced to air in January 2001.

Source

La Femme Nikita must've been pretty popular.

La Femme Nikita must've been pretty popular.
Close
Petition: Free Fiona
Date: 4 October 2005
Result: Free Fiona was an international campaign directed at Sony Music Entertainment. The aim was for them to release the third album from American singer-songwriter, Fiona Apple, named Extraordinary Machine. Dave Muscato established the website 'FreeFiona' for music fans all over the world to sign an online petition. Having attracted more than 36,000 signatures, the campaign received publicity from outlets such as The New York Times, People magazine, Rolling Stone, Spin magazine, MSNBC, ABC, MTV News, VH1, the Associated Press, Corriere della Sera, USA Today, Howard Stern, NPR, and many others. Extraordinary Machine was released on 4 October 2005, ending a successful campaign.

Source

Fiona Apple's album got release following a successful petition.

Fiona Apple's album got release following a successful petition.
Close
Petition: Anaheim Ducks mascot
Date: 26 January 2006
Result: The owners of what is probably the most famous ice hockey team in the world, announced at the start of the 2006–07 season, that the Mighty Ducks of Anaheim would change their name to the Anaheim Ducks. This included logo and team color changes. A change of mascot was also suggested, but many Ducks fans successfully petitioned the owners of the time to keep ‘Wildwing’ as the current mascot, because of the team's recent success and as link to the past.

Source

That movie was awesome!

That movie was awesome!
Close
Petition: La Toya Jackson
Date: 22 May 2006
Result: A successful petition was gathered by the fans of La Toya Jackson (sister of Michael Jackson) at ChurchofLaToya.com to persuade her label, Cherry Pop, to release her debut self titled album on CD for the first time in the UK. Originally released in the USA and mainland Europe in 1980, the belated UK release came on 22 May 2006.

Source

A lesser known Jackson has a substantial fanbase as well.

A lesser known Jackson has a substantial fanbase as well.
Close
Petition: Stand-In
Date: NYE 2007
Result: Stand-In was the Hungarian version of the popular improvisation show, Whose Line Is It Anyway? It had four actors playing improvisational games. When its original channel was set to finish off the show, an online petition was started to save it. After that, it was successfully aired on the Hungarian national public service television but one year later it was passed to a paid channel, due to financial reasons.

Source

Where's Drew Carey?

Where's Drew Carey?
Close
Petition: Earth Crisis in Mesa
Date: 21 February 2008
Result: Earth Crisis, among a variety of things, are best described as a ‘vegan straight edge metalcore’ band. And they supported animal rights. In 2008, the band was set to tour Mesa in Arizona. However, when residents of the town found out that one of the band members had a ‘White Supremacy’ tattoo, residents successfully setup an online petition to reject their tour stop. The tour stop was then relocated to Tuscan. “There is no room for racism in this day and age and not in this community!” wrote one visitor who signed his name only as ‘Matt’.

Source

Earth Crisis aren't wanted in Mesa.

Earth Crisis aren't wanted in Mesa.
Close
Petition: Billy Liddell
Date: November 2008
Result: William “Billy” Liddell was a famous Scottish footballer, who played out his entire career with Liverpool, and passed away in 2001. In 2007, the Billy Liddell Memorial Group was set up with the aim of having him honoured in his own country and home village. The group aimed at having Billy inducted into the SFA Hall of Fame, renaming the Townhill Sports Complex to the Billy Liddell Sport Complex and the erection of a lasting memorial to Liddell. An online petition to the Scottish Parliament to have Liddell inducted into the Scottish Football Hall of Fame was successful in November 2008, when he was one of eight inductees for the year.

Source

A Liverpool legend.

A Liverpool legend.
Close
Petition: Saving the NASA chief
Date: 1 January 2009
Result: While this may not be an example of a successful petition, it is certainly an odd one. Rachel Griffin, the wife of the chief NASA administrator of the time, Michael Griffin, setup an online petition to help save her husband’s job. The petition was going to be sent directly to President Barack Obama. Unfortunately, due to internal disputes and failure to reach certain goals, Mr Griffin resigned and was farewelled on the day of Obama’s inauguration.

Source

Not even a petition to the President was enough to save Micahel Griffin, but kudos to the thought.

Not even a petition to the President was enough to save Micahel Griffin, but kudos to the thought.
Close
Here are just a few of the more successful and innovative petitions that have come through the passage of time. We certainly hope that you will all be joining us with making the petition we have established for the inclusion of an R18 rating for video games a successful one, and help protect children from mature games. PALGN, Everybodyplays and GAME are in it for the long haul and we hope that you are too.

Related Content

WiiWare review round-up
26 Oct, 2009 More puzzle games than you can poke a stick at.
PALGN Game of the Year Awards 2008
29 Dec, 2008 Our favourite games of the year.
Christmas Buyer's Guide - PlayStation 3
07 Dec, 2008 What games should thee get on PlayStation 3 this Christmas?
8 Comments
2 years ago
I hate to say it, but only two of these examples are political, and neither have been overly successful in achieving their real goals. (Saving whales, preventing IR law introductions.)

This doesn't paint a pretty picture.
2 years ago
it never brought Carnivàle back either.......politicians generally not give a **** due to the fact that they were elected in the first place, which gives them the impression that anything they do, they are already doing for the majority and in the best interest.....
2 years ago
@JackSlack

Just goes to show that ego is an even more powerful force than money. Even companies are willing to be more democratic than our politicians. Maybe if a % of sales from R18+ games went to Michael Atkinson, then we'd see some change. Sad.
2 years ago
So... getting 2.4 million signatures in Venezuela to support a presidential recall doesn't count as political? How about lobbying to Scottish govt to induct a footballer into the hall of fame?

These are only a couple of examples. There are many others out there. You can all sit back, hold your head in your hands and denounce the potential of this campaign or you can at least try to show a smidgen of positive reinforcement. If you try, you have a chance of succeeding. If you don't try, you have NO chance of succeeding.

As I said in the outset. The success of a petition is not always measured in whether it gets a direct result, but in how many people are seen to follow the cause. And as we keep saying, this is only the beginning. Not the be all and end all.
2 years ago
And that's why I signed it, and got a friend to do so as well. I'm criticizing the article, not the movement.
2 years ago
Jeremy wrote
So... getting 2.4 million signatures in Venezuela to support a presidential recall doesn't count as political? How about lobbying to Scottish govt to induct a footballer into the hall of fame?

These are only a couple of examples. There are many others out there. You can all sit back, hold your head in your hands and denounce the potential of this campaign or you can at least try to show a smidgen of positive reinforcement. If you try, you have a chance of succeeding. If you don't try, you have NO chance of succeeding.

As I said in the outset. The success of a petition is not always measured in whether it gets a direct result, but in how many people are seen to follow the cause. And as we keep saying, this is only the beginning. Not the be all and end all.
While the Venezuelan petition was successful, it required 20% of the population. For this petition to be successful in the same way, by that math we would need 4 million signatures. That's a lot of signatures, especially considering that probably 75% (ok, I'm making this number up, but it's most likely a highly significant percentage) of the population don't feel particularly strongly about this cause, especially when there are more important things to worry about than the subtleties of our classification system. Things like getting the Kinglake area rebuilt after Black Saturday.

That being said, it IS still an important cause, and every siganture counts. If we are able to get even 100,000 signatures, surely someone would sit up and take notice.
2 years ago
Petitions rarely achieve anything. When they do, it's because enough people feel really strongly about the issue. That's not the case with R18+ video game ratings. People already have an opinion, and a list of names isn't going to change it.
2 years ago
Since NASA was mentioned, it's probably worth also mentioning that the Space Shuttle Enterprise (the first working prototype, which is now in the Smithsonian) was originally going to be named Constitution, but was renamed Enterprise after a large petition campaign by Star Trek fans. icon_smile.gif
Add Comment
Like this feature?
Share it with this tiny url: http://palg.nu/3Wb

N4G : News for Gamers         Twitter This!

Digg!     Stumble This!

| More
Currently Popular on PALGN
Australian Gaming Bargains - 08/12/11
'Tis the season to be bargaining.
R18+ Legislation
R18+ Legislation
Naruto Shippuden: Ultimate Ninja Storm Generations Preview
Hands on time with the game. Chat time with the CEO of CyberConnect 2.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2007
24 titles to keep an eye on during 2007.
PALGN's Most Anticipated Games of 2008
And you thought 2007 was populated.