As for our critical philosophy, we place a high emphasis on originality, and games that don't do anything new will not receive the top marks.
The Scores
0 – 1
These scores are reserved for games which have low production values and are in various states of brokenness. If you press right on the controller and it causes the character to move left, that sort of thing. But if a game works, and is generally playable, it should not score this low. It's highly unlikely a knowledgeable gamer would ever buy a game that would score this low.
1½ – 2
Similar to the above, but for slightly less broken games. Games which feature sluggish controls, a poor camera system and which also suck in other ways. These scores can also be used for games which have very little content for the price, and are therefore terrible value.
2½ – 3½
A game in this range will be playable, and for a fan of the genre there may be some possible fun that can be wrung from it. But it will be semi-broken, ugly, far too short, overly simplistic, or all of the above.
4 – 5
A game that almost works, and may have potential, but all is wasted by poor execution. To get this score, a game should have at least one or two redeeming features, and may be some cheap fun if bought at a bargain price.
5½ – 6
To receive these scores, a game will be competent, have nothing major broken, but will be unimaginative, too short, simplistic, ugly, or technically unambitious. These are our base scores for your average semi-competent licenced game.
6½ – 7
Above average. Here we're getting into games that you may actually want to play even if they're not from your preferred genre. Games of these scores or above would be described as 'good' by most gamers. Most people should be able to enjoy this title to some degree if they like the gameplay type or property at all.
7½ – 8
Well above average. Games of these scores or above would be described as 'great' by most gamers. Games that are so good it will be worth going back to play them years later. They will only be brought down by a few minor flaws, or one slightly larger flaw.
8½ – 9
A potential 'game of the year', and a game so good it should be fun for anyone to whom the concept appeals. Graphics, control, sound, presentation and gameplay must all be outstanding for a game to score this high. The only thing holding it back must be that it lacks that 'creative spark' to bring it to the next level of greatness, or it could be a game that has that spark, but is brought down by a few minor technical or artistic flaws.
9½
The best of the best, a must buy title for almost all gamers. State of the art technically, and an artistic marvel. Creative gameplay mechanics, and level design beyond reproach. A game guaranteed to be shortlisted for 'game of the year'.
10
The absolute best. A score only one or two games a generation will receive.
You can also read the list of our all time highest and lowest scored games.
Loading...
